Navigation Links
U.S. Appeals Court Reinstates Claim That Controversial Diet Drug Redux Should Never Have Been Offered to American People
Date:8/19/2010

CINCINNATI, Ohio, Aug. 19 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- An Ohio Federal Court of Appeals ruling issued yesterday is reinstating the late victim's claim that the recalled diet drug Redux (commonly called fen-phen) linked to her death should never have been marketed to the American people by Wyeth due in part to its pre-approval concerns about potentially lethal side effects. The Court, in remanding the case to the trial court, held that Federal drug regulations do not preempt Ohio negligence claims, and indicated that the Supreme Court's 2009 landmark pharmaceutical manufacturer preemption decision (Wyeth v. Levine) may apply beyond inadequate warning-label claims.

Benjamin H. Anderson, Esq., of Anderson Law Offices, LLC of Cleveland, Ohio, counsel for the plaintiff, said, "Mary Buchanan, like so many others, turned to a drug to help her lose weight and as a result she lost her life. She and her surviving family members deserve justice; this is an important decision in her case and for the harms and losses she sustained, as well as the many millions of Americans taking prescription medications who have long been concerned about drug companies being shielded from appropriate state negligence laws. Significantly, the appeals court has also reinstated and remanded to the trial court our claim for punitive damages."

In reversing key sections of the trial court's finding for the defendant on summary judgment in Wimbush v. Wyeth et.al., 6th Cir. No. 09-3380, the three-judge appeals panel held that the trial judge erred in concluding that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) preempted the Buchanan family's negligence claims that the drug should never have been made available to Americans given Wyeth-Redux's known health risks, particularly Primary Pulmonary Hypertension (PPH). Mrs. Buchanan, a hard-working and dedicated 66- year-old nurse from Maple Heights, Ohio who took the weight-loss drug during 1996 and 1997, lost her life to PPH in 2003 within a few months after filing the complaint. The drug company, which spent more than $50 million marketing the wildly popular and profitable drug after its launch in April 1996, pulled it on September 15, 1997 at the request of the FDA and under mounting criticism by independent researchers and reports in respected medical journals.

Though Redux was only on the market  for a relatively short period, to date it is estimated that Wyeth has paid thousands of victims of Redux and its predecessor, Pondimin – and/or their survivors – more than $20 billion in damages. In evaluating the potential side effects of Redux, researchers noted that PPH is a devastating pulmonary disease for which there is still no cure, and the associated heart-valve problems may and often did require high-risk heart surgery. The controversial, high-risk diet drug had previously been evaluated and pulled from pharmacies overseas and it was banned in some individual states before the total recall.

In its decision, the appeals Court stated, "...we are not persuaded that it is always impossible to comply with both state law duties and FDA regulations in the process leading up to FDA approval." It added, "...we cannot agree with the district court's conclusion as, not only is there a presumption against preemption, but the case law supports the conclusion that Congress did not intend to preempt state tort law claims when it passed the Food, Drug, and Cosmetics Act (FDCA)."

In a footnote, it commented "...the overwhelming take-away from the Levine majority opinion is that state tort law has historically played a substantial role in the regulation of drug manufacturers and that Congress has never indicated an intent to change this role. Thus, while Levine did leave open the possibility that there may be some state law claims that would conflict with the FDA's regulatory authority and function, the claim at issue in Levine was not one of them. We do not believe that Buchanan's pre-approval negligence claims are, either."

Attorney Anderson, commenting on the interpretation of the Levine ruling in the case, said, "Drug companies are now on notice that they cannot lie to and conceal from the FDA crucial information in the pre-approval process  and then expect to be held harmless once their drugs are responsible for causing pain, suffering and, as in Mrs. Buchanan's case, death."

The Court affirmed the dismissal of the balance of the plaintiff's  claims, and Attorney Anderson said he will  evaluate with appellate counsel Paul Flowers, Esq., and Mrs. Buchanan's family all appropriate legal options.


'/>"/>
SOURCE Anderson Law Firm
Copyright©2010 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine technology :

1. U.S. Court of Appeals Rules on Validity of Lillys Gemzar Method-of-Use Patent
2. Federal Appeals Court Rules Pharmaceutical Sales Reps Entitled to Overtime Pay
3. Watson Says Appeals Court Affirms Concerta(R) Patent Invalid
4. U.S. Court of Appeals Upholds AstraZeneca AWP Settlement
5. German District Court Finds RENASYS™ GO NPWT System Non-infringing
6. Appellate Court Sides With Terminally-Ill Medical Marijuana Patient
7. CRESTOR® Patent Upheld By US Court
8. Appellate Court Decides in Favor of Fenwal
9. Texas Court Asked to Appoint Receiver for Key Subsidiary of TSX Listed Northstar Healthcare, Inc. (TSX NHC) on Claims of Mismanagement and Breach of Fiduciary Duty
10. Pharma CI Conference Amy Yueh Pays $52,000 to Apaporis LLC to Satisfy Judgment Against Her In Superior Court Of New Jersey Case
11. Montana Supreme Court Decision Endangers Most Vulnerable Citizens
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/12/2016)... , Kalifornien, 12. Februar 2016  Sequent ... der Aufnahme von Patienten für eine Studie zur ... Aneurysmen („WEB") speziell für die Behandlung von rupturierten ... , MD, Leiter der Neuroradiologie an der Universitätsklinik ... und Hauptprüfarzt der CLARYS-Studie hat den ersten Patienten ...
(Date:2/12/2016)... INDIANAPOLIS , Feb. 12, 2016  Eli Lilly and ... High Court decided the Alimta® (pemetrexed disodium) vitamin regimen patent ... in the UK, France , ... instructions to dilute the product only with dextrose solution.  ... of 2015, the UK Court of Appeal held that Lilly,s ...
(Date:2/12/2016)... February 12, 2016 ... auf den ungedeckten medizinischen Bedarf bei Lungen- ... seines klinischen Forschungsprogramms bekannt. Das Programm, das ... Verbesserungen ihrer respiratorischen Funktionen und anderer klinischer ... ein Medizintechnikunternehmen, das sich auf den ungedeckten ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
(Date:2/12/2016)... Omaha, NE (PRWEB) , ... February 12, 2016 , ... ... list of the five most searched jobs via the website of healthcare staffing leader ... professionals in travel nurse jobs , travel therapy positions and in ...
(Date:2/12/2016)... ... February 12, 2016 , ... The aging population and ... long term care. With that, says Patrick Loughney, president of Longtree & ... in long term care environments. His company, which offers prep courses and workshops ...
(Date:2/12/2016)... ... 12, 2016 , ... Basketball is a game for everyone, not just those ... series, sign language translation is featured in the top right of the screen. Every ... lessons has a sign language translator to teach kids the game and how to ...
(Date:2/12/2016)... ... February 12, 2016 , ... With the exception of restorative dentistry, to date there has been ... the recent approval by the FDA, there is a now a new protocol in stopping ... is very simple and quick to apply. The application is as simple as drying ...
(Date:2/11/2016)... ... ... Fitbody Personal Training offers outdoor training classes which includes an equestrian boot ... healthy. Located in Phoenixville, PA, the classes are structured as fun and friendly. , ... want to lose weight and tone up. This class offers a balance of exercises ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):