Navigation Links
Bi-Partisan Legislation Introduced Would Repeal Controversial Medicare 'Competitive Bidding' Requirements for Home Medical Equipment
Date:3/18/2011

HARRISBURG, Pa., March 18, 2011 /PRNewswire/ -- Pennsylvania Association of Medical Suppliers (PAMS) today applauded legislation introduced by Congressmen Glenn "GT" Thompson (R-Centre) and Jason Altmire, (D-Allegheny) that would repeal Medicare's controversial competitive bidding program for home medical equipment.  H.R. 1041, titled the "Fairness in Medicare Bidding Act," is already endorsed by numerous patient groups and consumer organizations, including the Three Rivers Council on Independent Living and United Cerebral Palsy of Pittsburgh.

"We are an industry that supports robust competition.  But the use of the term 'competitive' is hardly descriptive of what this program actually does," said John Shirvinsky, Executive Director for the Pennsylvania Association of Medical Suppliers (PAMS).  "At best, the term is perversely applied."

"From the very beginning, we believed CMS's bid program to be poor healthcare policy," said Georgie Blackburn of BLACKBURN'S Physicians Pharmacy Inc.

The bidding program was implemented on January 1, 2011, in nine metropolitan areas across the U.S. and will expand to an additional 91 areas later this year. Medicare beneficiaries who live in Charlotte, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Dallas-Fort Worth, Kansas City, Miami, Orlando, Pittsburgh, and Riverside, California are affected by this program now.  The bidding applies to medically required oxygen therapy, enteral nutrients (tube feeding), continuous positive air pressure (CPAP) and respiratory assistive devices, power wheelchairs, walkers, hospital beds and support surfaces, and mail-order diabetic supplies.  

Shirvinsky maintains that the Medicare bidding scheme is designed to eliminate the vast majority of competitors from the Medicare market.  "You cannot eliminate 80-90 percent of competitors and expect to arrive at a competitive outcome.  It's fundamental: Competition requires competitors.  Competition also requires free access to growing markets, which this program prohibits."

In the Pittsburgh market, which includes all of Altmire's district and part of Thompson's, 58 percent of contracts went to out of state firms with no base of operations in the market.  Shirvinsky noted that this outcome is "not a patient-friendly outcome."

Economists and auction experts have called the program's projected 32 percent savings "unrealistic."  Shirvinsky said, "there is a serious disconnect when an industry that earns a 5 percent return on average takes a 32 percent reduction in reimbursements.  This is simply unsustainable.  Companies need positive cash flow in order to sustain operations.

"In Pittsburgh, we are already seeing layoffs and salary reductions.  Winners and losers alike are living in a state of fear and uncertainty.  We are watching a slow-motion train wreck as revenues dwindle.  Our economy and our Medicare patients deserve better than this."  

"Two months into the program, OUR business is facing incalculable losses.  We don't want to reduce services, we don't want to lay off people and we don't want to close offices," added Blackburn.  

The American Association for Homecare has received hundreds of complaints about the bidding program from beneficiaries, physicians, case managers, and homecare providers.  These complaints are expected to increase exponentially as the program progresses because the payment rates established under this system are unsustainable over the long term.  These payment rates are leading to the provision of lower-quality medical equipment and reduced services associated with home medical equipment.

Blackburn also noted that her company and other compliant providers across the nine bid areas have been "replaced by various companies that do not have the same level of financial stability, purchasing capability or service capability."

A number of patient advocacy and consumer groups also support H.R. 1041 – the ALS Association, the Brain Injury Association of America, the Christopher and Dana Reeve Foundation, the International Ventilator Users Network, the Muscular Dystrophy Association, National Emphysema and COPD Association, the National Council on Independent Living, the National Spinal Cord Injury Association, and United Spinal Association, among others.

The bottom line is this: the "competitive bidding program will increase Medicare costs. It disrupts the continuum and coordination of care between doctors, discharge planners, patients, and homecare providers.  It will lead to longer, more expensive hospital stays and more physician office visits, nursing home admissions, and emergency room visits," said Shirvinsky.

Since the January 1 implementation of the bidding program in nine areas in the U.S., the following types of problems and complaints have been reported:

  • Difficulty finding a local equipment or service provider;
  • Delays in obtaining medically required equipment and services;
  • Longer than necessary hospital stays due to trouble discharging patients to home-based care;
  • Far fewer choices for patients when selecting equipment or providers;
  • Reduced quality; and
  • Confusing or incorrect information provided by Medicare.

In November, 2010, 167 leading economists, including two Nobel laureates and auction experts who have experience in the design and application of auctions around the world, warned Congress that Medicare's bidding design for home medical equipment will fail.  Those experts, who design market-based auction systems, found that this particular bidding program designed by Medicare has irreparable flaws that will prevent it from achieving its objectives of establishing accurate reimbursement rates while maintaining high quality equipment and related services.  Under this system, the bidding companies are not bound by their bids, which undermines the credibility of the process and encourages "low-ball" bids that create an unsustainable process and threaten the long-term viability of the program.

Last year, a bipartisan group of 260 members of the U.S. House of Representatives supported legislation similar to the Thompson-Altmire proposal to repeal the bidding program.


'/>"/>
SOURCE Pennsylvania Association of Medical Suppliers
Copyright©2010 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine technology :

1. Department of Defense Funding Shows Continued and Bi-Partisan Support for STB® Lifesaving Technologies Products to Stop Blood Loss
2. Control Risks Forecasts New Reality for Business in 2011 Brought by Emerging Markets, Legislation
3. New Legislation Seeks to Boost Participation in Clinical Trials for Rare Diseases
4. California Legislature Passes Historic HIV Testing Bill (AB 682); AHF Urges Governor to Sign Crucial Lifesaving Legislation
5. High Tech Vet Medical Warming System Introduced at Orlando
6. Natural Orifice Surgery Introduced to Relieve Acid Reflux
7. Hill-Rom® P500 Therapy Surface Introduced for Use With Most Flat Deck Bed Systems
8. Treatment with Elektas Leksell Gamma Knife Perfexion Introduced to Cancer Patients in Australia
9. MitraClip(R) Therapy Introduced in Austria
10. Sixty Percent of Surveyed Type 2 Diabetes Patients in the U.S. Who Use Insulin Indicate They Would Request a Switch to a Less Expensive Biosimilar Insulin if Such an Agent Became Available
11. Sermo Study Shows 63% of Physicians Would Utilize New Gout Treatments
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/23/2017)... 2017 Research and Markets has announced the ... Strategies - 2016" report to their offering. ... The latest research Autism Spectrum ... data and benchmarks in the global Autism Spectrum Disorder market. ... What are the key drugs marketed for Autism Spectrum Disorder and ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... MELBOURNE, Australia , Feb. 23, 2017 ITL Limited, ... to announce excellent results for the half year ended 31 December ... ITL BioMedical Growth Update" presentation can be viewed here . ... of $2.12m (Dec 2015: $1.04m; up 104%) Earnings ... Revenue of $17.5m (Dec 2015: $15.7m; up 11%) ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... Research and Markets has announced the addition ... 2016" report to their offering. ... The latest research Oesophageal Cancer Drugs Price ... in the global Oesophageal Cancer market. The research answers ... key drugs marketed for Oesophageal Cancer and their clinical attributes? How ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
(Date:2/23/2017)... ... 2017 , ... Healthcare Research & Analytics® (HRA®) in cooperation ... cancer, has produced a seminal study that asked cancer survivors and their caregivers ... a webinar, Defining Compassionate Care Through the Voices of Patients and Advocates that ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... ... (PRWEB) ... opportunity for the nation to come together to combine its ... – with its favorite fruit – apples! To celebrate National ... to join the “Apple Madness” bracket tournament – a five-week, ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... ... February 23, 2017 , ... Top cosmetic and periodontal dentist ... program today with a new Indiegogo campaign . Individuals are now able to ... the Los Angeles area, either as a participating patient or through an Indiegogo donation. ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... , ... February 23, 2017 , ... HealthPostures, the desk ... an expert sit stand solutions representative to the Minneapolis Home and Garden Show which ... the event that is garnering national attention is the Minneapolis Convention Center. , ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... ... February 23, 2017 , ... Carlos Gutierrez ... has also continued to spiritually evolve, which is the purpose of everyone in this ... Spiritual Truths ” (published by Balboa Press) attempts to guide readers to expand one’s ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):