Navigation Links
US Supreme Court Could Protect Medical Equipment Manufacturers from Law Suits

From abortion to consumer rights, the conservatives-dominated US Supreme Court seems set to leave its mark, whatever could be the ultimate fate of President George W. Bush.

It said on Monday that that it would hear an appeal raising the issue of whether the medical equipment manufacturers approved by the federal government may be sued under state law by patients injured by those devices.

At the end of the case, the federal government could win a ruling by which it could simply prohibit states from imposing more stringent consumer regulations than what it lays down.

True to his undisguised bias for the industry, Bush has been tacitly encouraging various federal agencies to adopt regulations that would preclude active state prosecutors and trial lawyers from bringing lawsuits that could result in higher safety standards for a variety of products and processes.

Agencies like the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and the Consumer Product Safety Commission, have proposed or adopted rules that would make it more difficult for consumers to bring lawsuits under state laws that are more favorable to victims than are federal regulations.

Critics of the Bush administration say that the approach strips consumers of valuable state protections. Supporters say the federal effort to pre-empt the states sets uniform national standards and discourages overzealous state prosecutors.

In the case before the Supreme Court, both the Bush administration and the defendant company, Medtronic, had urged the justices to reject the appeal of a patient who was injured when a balloon catheter it made ruptured during an angioplasty in 1996.

The patient, Charles R. Riegel, and his wife, Donna, sued Medtronic for a variety of state tort law violations, including negligent design and breach of warranty.

The company maintained that Mr. Riegels surgeon should not have used the balloon catheter because of Mr. Riegels condition and that the surgeon used the device in a manner inconsistent with its labeling.

Both a Federal District Court and a Federal Appeals Court in New York dismissed most of the Riegels claims. Those courts concluded that because the FDA had approved the balloon catheter after a rigorous review and before it went to market, injured patients could not file claims against Medtronic under state law.

The medical devices amendment forbids a state from adopting any requirement which is different from, or in addition to, any requirement in federal law.

Federal courts around the nation have taken different views of whether that provision bars state law damage claims against medical devices approved by the FDA.

The issue has so confounded the courts that three appeals courts reviewing the same medical device made by the same company have reached two different conclusions about whether patients could bring a lawsuit.

Lawyers involved in the Medtronic case say they expect the court to hear from manufacturers and business groups in support of Medtronic, as well as from states and consumer organizations on behalf of the patient who was injured. The case, Riegel v. Medtronic, No. 06-179, is expected to be heard by the court in the fall.

Significantly, a group of similar cases involving drugs is also moving through the courts.


'"/>




Related medicine news :

1. Supreme Court Quashed Reservation Quotas For PG Medical Courses
2. Supreme Court Verdict Gives Hope to Striking Medicos
3. Supreme Court Warns Medicos of Contempt Action
4. Supreme Court Verdict Gives Hope to Striking Medicos
5. Supreme Court Orders Striking Medicos To Call Off Agitation Immediate
6. Supreme Court Ruling On Health Care Not Respected. Alleged Physician
7. Doctors to Get Pay for Limited Strike Period : Supreme Court
8. Supreme Courts Order is a Vindication of Our Stand: AIIMS Medicos
9. Supreme Court Notice to Centre, MCI on Doctors Strike
10. Supreme Court Seeks Replies From Cola Firms
11. Mexico Supreme Court Accepts Petition To Review Mexico City Law Legalizing Abortion During First Three Months Gestation
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:1/19/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... January 19, 2017 , ... ... acoustic and privacy panel system. , The Tranquility privacy panel system was ... collaborative office environment. Tranquility panels help reduce noise and provide the visual privacy ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... , ... January 19, 2017 , ... Sam & Associates ... to commercial and residential clients in the California Bay Area, is launching a charity ... in the region. , Heart disease is the primary killer of adult men and ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... ... 19, 2017 , ... For the third year running, Noto ... the surrounding area, is inaugurating a charity event to help raise funds ... Lou Gehrig's disease or motor neurone disease, is a deadly neurological disorder that ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... ... January 19, 2017 , ... Creative messages ... Real Impact contest from Impact Teen Drivers and California Casualty. Entries from students ... , Educational grants totaling $15,000 will be awarded for the best peer-to-peer messages ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... San Diego, CA (PRWEB) , ... January 19, 2017 , ... ... for their 2017 collaboration with the American Heart Association; “Howe” Healthy is Your ... how to stay healthy and active. Each year, Bill Howe Plumbing, Heating & Air ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/19/2017)... England , January 19, 2017 ... and Otsuka in the Milner Therapeutics Consortium   ... scientists in Cambridge   ... (NYSE: PFE ) as a partner to ... the Consortium, which enables the efficient transfer of materials ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... 2017  ViewRay, Inc. (Nasdaq: VRAY ... clinical MRI-guided radiation therapy system, announced today that it ... million through a private placement of its common ... financing and was joined by certain of ViewRay,s ... Venture Partners, and an additional new institutional investor, ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... , Jan. 18, 2017 The Academy ... and Drug Administration (FDA) for its release today ... population health decision makers can proactively share clinical ... as well as emerging therapies awaiting FDA approval. ... consensus recommendations that AMCP developed during two multi-stakeholder ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: