Navigation Links
Students Light Up Despite School Anti-Smoking Programs

It may take more than anti-smoking lessons in the classroom to keep school-age children and teens from lighting up, according to a recent review of studies.//

There is little strong evidence that school-based programs are effective in the long term in preventing kids from taking up smoking, said Dr. Roger Thomas, lead reviewer and a professor in the family medicine department at the University of Calgary in Alberta, Canada.

The review appears in the July issue of The Cochrane Library, a publication of The Cochrane Collaboration, an international organization that evaluates medical research. Systematic reviews draw evidence-based conclusions about medical practice after considering both the content and quality of existing medical trials on a topic.

Thomas and colleagues identified 23 high-quality randomized controlled trials that examined the effectiveness of school-based smoking prevention programs taught to school children ages 5 to 18. The majority of these studies took place in the United States, the rest in Canada, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom.

Each study measured whether the students were nonsmokers before and immediately after the intervention program, as well as six months and two years later. Five types of tobacco-education programs were evaluated.

In information-giving education programs, students learned about smoking and its risks. Only one information-giving intervention met high-quality standards, but it did show a positive effect on students’ smoking.

Social competence programs taught students behavioral skills, such as goal-setting, to help them learn to avoid smoking. When researchers pooled the results of the two best-quality social competence trials, they found a positive, but not statistically significant effect on student smoking.

Thirteen studies evaluated the effectiveness of social influence interventions, which helped students discuss ways to say no t o smoking and make public commitments to not smoke. Of these, nine showed some positive effect on students’ smoking prevalence.

“There is some evidence that school programs incorporating social influence models can affect smoking behavior in the short term,” the reviewers wrote. But when they pooled the results of the social influence interventions, they were not statistically significant.

Combined programs used both social competence and influence methods in their anti-smoking interventions. One study found significantly decreased the prevalence of student smoking; another study indicated that the smoking intervention decreased student smoking, but only when health educators provided the smoking education, as opposed to students receiving information via self-instruction.

Of the four studies that evaluated multi-modal programs, which combined school-based programs with parent and community initiatives, three showed that the programs effectively reduced the prevalence of smoking in students.

The Cochrane review also mentioned the largest and most rigorous tobacco education study, the Hutchinson Smoking Prevention Project, which took place in 40 school districts in Washington state. The study found that an intensive eight-year program had no long-term effect on student smoking behavior when students were reassessed two years after high school.

The reviewers said that over the past three decades, efforts to influence youth smoking have focused on schools. Today, about 70 percent of U.S. middle school students and 50 percent of U.S. high school students receive tobacco prevention education in the classroom, according to the background information.

“The key problem for future research is whether more of the social influences programs can be improved so that they are effective,” Thomas said.

The reviewers also concluded that when educators and parents examine smoking education programs, e ffectiveness is not the only issue. The cost of teacher training and extra classroom time spent are important factors to consider as well. “Those planning services will need to determine whether these costs are justified in the light of the existing evidence,” Thomas said.

But David Schonfeld, M.D., director of the Division of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center, said that the results of this review do not necessarily point to the ineffectiveness of school anti-smoking programs.

“The lack of rigorous evidence is not the same as rigorous evidence that something is ineffective,” Schonfeld said. He also suggested that the positive effects on students’ smoking behavior found in some of the trials may have been deemphasized in this review.

Tobacco use is responsible for an exceptional amount of social, personal and economic cost to our society, Schonfeld said. “If you take into account lost productivity and health costs, in the United States alone, it exceeds $167 billion dollars. Even a small impact — even a 1 percent drop in smoking interest in kids — that would be a savings,” he said.

“What I would take from [this study] is that this is an important problem. We would like to see even more research in this area,” Schonfeld said.

(Surce: Newswise)
'"/>




Related medicine news :

1. Exposure to Pesticides in Schools Produces Illnesses Among Employees, Students
2. Pharma Companies May Influence The Decisions Of Medical Students
3. Students Involved In Bullying And Victims Were Equally Stressed
4. A Comparative Study On Dietary Habits In Middle School Students And Increase In Weight
5. Students wants to extent Tution waiver in Ontario
6. Disadvantaged Students May Not Go In For College Education
7. Students Die after a Fatal Crash
8. Students Seek Help From Prisoners for Kidnapped Childs Release
9. Ignorance about AIDS rampart in Third of College Students: Chinese survey
10. Chinese Students Affected By Unknown Flu
11. Advertisements in High School Newspapers Encourage Students to Sport a Tan
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:2/13/2016)... ... February 13, 2016 , ... The National Association for Children ... organization representing the growing community of recovering individuals (now over 23 million), to ... in policies addressing addiction. , Although many of the presidential candidates of ...
(Date:2/13/2016)... , ... February 13, 2016 , ... The producers of ... of American businesses. , The increasingly modern world of instantaneous consumption proves very ... non-renewable energy sources such as oil and coal, which pollutes our air, water, and ...
(Date:2/13/2016)... , ... February 13, 2016 , ... When an Au Pair comes all ... sure what they are in for and they are often worried things won’t go well. ... were hoping for. This year’s Au Pair of the Year winner’s all commented how their ...
(Date:2/12/2016)... ... February 12, 2016 , ... According to an article published ... for a significant portion of hernia repairs throughout the United States. Commenting on this ... Center notes that this trend has not only been expected, but it seems to ...
(Date:2/12/2016)... and Washington, DC (PRWEB) , ... ... ... and the Siemens Foundation today announced a new initiative—the Siemens Foundation-PATH Ingenuity ... low-resource settings. The partnership will recruit top students from U.S. universities who ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/12/2016)... Texas , Feb. 12, 2016 On ... for Robotic Surgery at St. David,s North Austin Medical ... da Vinci ® Xi ® Surgical System ... 7000dV. Thiru Lakshman , M.D., colorectal ... a total proctocolectomy utilizing Integrated Table Motion technology, which ...
(Date:2/12/2016)... North Carolina , 12 februari 2016 ... Inc. (AAI/CML), een toonaangevende leverancier van productie ... en biotechnologische industrieën, kondigt vandaag een uitbreiding ... mogelijkheden op haar locatie in ... vraag heeft geleid tot meerdere recente investeringen. ...
(Date:2/11/2016)... Feb. 11, 2016 The primary goal of ... adoption patterns on the usage of liquid biopsy. Key ... - Timeframe of liquid biopsy adoption amidst ... and Evs—by organization type - Sample inflow to conduct ... saliva, stool, serum, and so on. - Correlation analysis ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: