Navigation Links
Quality Versus Quantity: Transforming Kidney Transplant Policy

A new article published in American Journal of Transplantation examines the dilemmas faced in trying to change kidney transplant policy; addressing the need to balance the benefits of immediate transplants with those to be had from waiting for a more suitable match.

The article highlights some of the important points to be considered in any new policy-making, and suggests a new method for allocation, whereby the patients are involved in the decision process.

The majority of deceased-donor kidneys are allocated to patients with end-stage renal disease on a first-come, first-serve basis, rather than through careful matching, despite the fact that there is little risk of immediate death from renal ailments.

As a result, donated kidneys in excellent condition may be given to patients who are almost certain to die long before the replacement organ wears out, while patients with longer life expectancies may be given organs with a high chance of graft failure, making second or even third transplants necessary later in life.

Recent attention has been focused on designing new methods of prioritization, one that allocates kidneys based on matches with the most favorable risk factors for long-term graft survival. Patients would be ranked based on the expected gain in years-of-life compared to continuing dialysis.

However, such a system comes with a number of significant trade-offs, with some ethnic and age groups being more likely to benefit from transplants, and therefore ranking higher than others. The challenge for policy makers is to create a ranking system that takes into account those who do not meet maximum benefit requirements.

In this editorial, Richard B. Freeman, Jr., M.D. presents a solution suggesting that patients themselves decide what level of graft failure risk he or she deems acceptable. Recipients would only be offered kidneys that meet their own standards, rather than being directed by arbitrary allocation policies.

Freeman claims that such a system would have many benefits, including better educating patients so that they could make informed decisions, allowing patients to personally decide where the trade-off between the qualitative and quantitative benefit of a transplant lies, as well as speeding up the organ placement program. An approach of this sort would not prevent low risk grafts from being given to patients with short life expectancies, or vice-versa, but it would ensure that the decision rests with the patient, in contrast to a system where quantitative benefit would always take priority with no patient or care giver input.


'"/>




Related medicine news :

1. Quality of life after cancer
2. Steps To Improve Quality Of Plant-Based Drugs
3. Quality of lives of older people
4. Life Quality For Patients With Multiple Sclerosis
5. Relationship Between Genetic Structure And Quality of Life
6. Poorer Quality of Life Observed In Overweight Kids
7. Childhood Obesity May Influence The Their Quality Of Life
8. Indian Hospitals – A Destination For Quality Medical Care
9. The Growing Rise In Clinical Research Could Lead To A Compromise In Quality Of Research And Ethics
10. Quality Awareness In Hospitals Can Reduce Mortality Rate Of Patients
11. Data On Quality Of Health Care Can Be Easily Obtained
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:12/2/2016)... ... , ... Sourced from the Isbre Springs beneath the 5,000 year old Hardanger ... of just 6 ppm TDS (Total Dissolved Solids) in addition to its excellent taste ... several ShopRite and FoodTown stores in NJ and received rave comments from consumers. , ...
(Date:12/2/2016)... ... December 02, 2016 , ... Clarify Health ... has raised $6.0 million in an initial round of funding. The round was ... and their caregivers can receive far better care through the application of the ...
(Date:12/2/2016)... ... ... ‘Tis the season for giving! Today, 20 creative teams across the nation ... the Drug Enforcement Administration as part of the National Red Ribbon Week Photo Contest. ... decorated their campuses with this year’s Red Ribbon Week theme: “YOLO. Be Drug Free,” ...
(Date:11/30/2016)... ... November 30, 2016 , ... Standard ... 75, an annual ranking and recognition of the largest closely held companies headquartered ... ranked from 2008-2016. In addition, Standard Process was awarded the Talent Award for ...
(Date:11/30/2016)... ... 2016 , ... The Cronovo Smartwatch, the first on the ... at an affordable price, is now available on the crowdfunding website Kickstarter ... changer” when it comes to the smartwatch. , "With Cronovo, we’ve combined the ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:12/2/2016)... -- Boston Scientific Corporation (NYSE: BSX ) ... assets and capabilities of the Neovasc, Inc., (NASDAQ: ... as well as a 15% equity stake in Neovasc, ... Neovasc advanced biological tissue business makes elements used in ... System. * Upon completion of the transaction, the ...
(Date:12/2/2016)... , Dec. 2, 2016 Lianluo ... Smart" or "the Company") which develops, markets and ... in China and international ... Disease Diagnosis and Treatment New Progress Forum, co-hosted ... Guangdong Province , Guangdong Provincial People,s ...
(Date:12/2/2016)... 2016 On Thursday, the NASDAQ Composite ... while the Dow Jones Industrial Average managed to stay in ... markets, which prompted Stock-callers this morning to look at the ... NUVA ), Smith & Nephew PLC (NYSE: ... and Cesca Therapeutics Inc. (NASDAQ: KOOL ). You ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: