Navigation Links
Consumer Court Dismisses India’s Biggest Ever Medical Error Clai

The apex consumer court in New Delhi Thursday dismissed the case of highest-ever medical compensation claim filed by India-born US scientist Kunal Saha for the death of his wife in 1998 due to alleged wrongful treatment//.

The judgement of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) has 'shocked' the AIDS researcher.

'This judgement is utterly shocking not just for myself, but also for the millions of ordinary Indian citizens who seek justice against the hitherto 'untouchable' Indian doctors,' Saha told IANS from Ohio.

He vowed to see the end by moving the Supreme Court immediately against the judgement.

Saha had filed a Rs.770 million ($17 million) claim against a Kolkata hospital (AMRI) after the death of his wife Anuradha Saha, 36, due to alleged wrong treatment by three senior doctors - Baidyanath Halder, Abani Roychowdhury and Sukumar Mukherjee - in May 1998 when the couple were on a visit to Kolkata.

The NCDRC observed in its judgement while dismissing the case: "Whether the courts or the consumer fora can sit in appeal against the decision taken by the expert doctors with regard to administration of a particular dose of medicine? Answer would be - No.'

'It is to be judged in the light of particular circumstance of each case. Jurisdiction of the consumer fora would be limited in case of apparent deficiency in prescribing dose of medicine, i.e., in cases where doctors have not taken reasonable degree of care in prescribing a particular dose of medicine,' said the order given by a three-member panel led by NCDRC president M.B. Shah.

'Claim in the complaint is in crores i.e. Rs.77,76,73,500/- which is rate while the disease suffered by the wife of the complainant was also rare- TEN (Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis) which affects only 1 or 1.3 persons, out of 10 lakhs (1 million),' the order said.

'We reiterate that doctors or surgeons do not undertake that they will positively cure a patient. With regard to the alleged deficiency in the treatment given to Mrs. Anuradha by opposite party doctors, there is no substance.

'The contention against the hospital that it was not having burns ward, and, therefore, the deceased suffered is also without substance. Hence, this complaint is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs,' the judgement said.

'The judgement failed to discuss the medical opinion from numerous experts that I've produced from around the world or the fact that none of the accused doctors was able to bring even a single medical expert,' Saha said.

'The judgement has also remained silent that I vouched under oath that every rupee from this case would be spent for promotion of health in India.'

'The NCDRC has dismissed the case on two basic grounds - that the primary doctors were acquitted and that the West Bengal Medical Council has found no fault in the treatment.

'Although the Calcutta High Court acquitted the three doctors from criminal charges after the trial court had convicted them, after hearing both sides, the Supreme Court has already allowed my special leave petition challenging the high court acquittal. The criminal case is currently pending at the court for final decision,' Saha said.

'We are aware about the corrupt nature of the medical councils. Do we even need a consumer court if the decision of the medical council is considered infallible?' he asked.

Saha formed the People for Better Treatment, a patients' forum, in course of his multi-million-dollar legal fight in the lowest to the highest court in India for justice.

Source: IANS News
'"/>




Related medicine news :

1. Paracetamol May Cause Live Damage Warns Consumer Education and Research Centre
2. Consumer group seeks Sibutramine ban
3. Identifying What Consumers Look For On Food Stuff Labels
4. Consumers Becoming More Health Conscious Than Calorie Conscious
5. With More Appearance Conscious Consumers The Need For Slimming Products Is Rapidly Rising
6. Consumers of soft drinks to be more alert
7. Consumers Worried About Trans-Fats The Most
8. New Plastic Surgery Unit Set Up In Kolkata To Meet Ever-Increasing Consumer Demand
9. Health care system “Consumer friendly” by 207
10. Chicken Prices Show an Upward Trend – Consumers, Not Scared Chicken Anymor
11. Consumer Court Dismisses Rs 143 Crore Negligence Claim
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:


(Date:9/25/2017)... ... September 25, 2017 , ... Emerald Ash Borers kill Ash trees in as little ... the Philadelphia region. A video by Rob Nagy, ISA Certified Arborist at Giroud Tree ... While several are dead or showing signs of decline from Emerald Ash Borers, two Ash ...
(Date:9/24/2017)... ... , ... Throughout the United States and the world, clinicians take a simple ... other providers work to give the best care possible to patients and communities, while ... today are threatening to tie our hands in carrying out that oath. The Graham-Cassidy ...
(Date:9/24/2017)... ... ... of Bethlehem Study”: is a thought-provoking essay focusing on the most monumental event since ... investigator who had has a long and eventful career in science and technology. ... an event so significant that it is referred to as the most monumental event ...
(Date:9/22/2017)... ... September 22, 2017 , ... MEDIA OPPORTUNITY: , Save Our ... interview citizens on why they are rallying against Mayo Clinic. Specifically, media can talk ... against Dr. Noseworthy’s (CEO) decision to close the Albert Lea hospital. , The rally ...
(Date:9/22/2017)... ... September 22, 2017 , ... ... financial setbacks, a senior finds a new lease on life with assistance from ... of people resolve their problem with unsecured debt. The senior is one of ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:9/6/2017)... , Sept. 6, 2017  Robert G. Szewc, ... Pinnacle Professional Member in recognition of his contributions to ... serves as a Nephrologist at the practice of Kidney ... medicine, kidney care and hypertension solutions. He has worked ... years of career experience, as well as expertise in ...
(Date:9/5/2017)... -- Sapheneia and Scannerside received FDA 510(k) clearance to ... third-party Vendor neutral CT product that makes it affordable ... current MITA standards. ... specifically designed to provide CT operators, prior to a ... a predefined threshold. Scannerside Dose Check is intended to ...
(Date:9/1/2017)... PALMER, Mass. , Sept. 1, 2017 ... Complete HealthCare Solutions, Inc , highlights opportunities for growth ... Street Journal report that Marlin Equity is seeking a ... is an annual award-winning 22-year-old healthcare solutions Value Added ... market.  "As the ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: