Navigation Links
Wyeth v. Levine: Preemption and The Facts
Date:10/17/2008

n of the drug to Ms. Levine, the product labeling listed four separate warnings about risks of improper administration of IV Phenergan. The appropriate use of the product and the wording of the warnings had been reviewed multiple times over the years by FDA as well as by an expert advisory committee, and reflected FDA's careful consideration of decades of data on Phenergan use. All drugs have risks, and FDA must balance those risks against the benefits to the public health. There is no evidence, argument, or even suggestion that Wyeth concealed or failed to provide the FDA with any relevant information about the risks associated with Phenergan.

Notwithstanding the view of the FDA, a Vermont jury determined that Wyeth failed to adequately warn about the risk of IV push Phenergan. However, the FDA-approved labeling for Phenergan was mandated by federal law. Absent any new evidence, Wyeth could not change Phenergan's labeling to comply with the labeling sought by the Vermont jury without violating federal law. This is true even if the change is intended to add or strengthen a contraindication or warning.

-- Preemption Protects Everyone

The Constitutional principle of preemption is not new. Preemption arises from the U.S. Constitution, which under the Supremacy Clause invalidates all state laws that conflict or interfere with federal law. In Wyeth v. Levine, the Vermont's jury verdict was in direct conflict with the FDA's considered scientific judgment.

Patients and physicians need to be able to rely on a single federal standard and guidelines for the risks, benefits, and use of medicines -- the FDA-approved labeling. The public health is better served by having a single expert regulatory body making decisions about risks, benefits, and warnings -- rather than an ad hoc system that could produce hundreds of conflicting results that would be impossible for manufacturers, physicians, and patients to reconcile or interpret. Such a system would u
'/>"/>

SOURCE Wyeth
Copyright©2008 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Wyeth and Nycomed Announce Court Denial of Preliminary Injunction
2. Wyeths Pearl River, N.Y. Facility Celebrates 100 Years of Achievements in Health care
3. Wyeth Announces Election of Bernard Poussot as CEO of Company Effective January 1, 2008
4. Wyeth Announces the Election of Robert M. Amen to Its Board of Directors
5. Wyeth Comments on PREVNAR and Trends in Pneumococcal Disease
6. Wyeth to Appeal Nevada Hormone Therapy Trial Verdict
7. Wyeth Reports Earnings Results for the 2007 Third Quarter and First Nine Months
8. Wyeth Consumer Healthcare Initiates Voluntary Recall and Replacement Program for Several Robitussin Products and Childrens Dimetapp Cold & Chest Congestion
9. Wyeth Consumer Healthcare Announces the Availability of Centrum Cardio and New Formula Centrum Products
10. Wyeth to Present at the Credit Suisse First Boston Healthcare Conference
11. Wyeth Receives FDA Approval of Protonix for Delayed-Release Oral Suspension
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:11/1/2014)... HealthDay Reporter FRIDAY, Oct. ... anger and alter their behavior in response to it, new ... Andrew Meltzoff, co-director of the University of Washington Institute for ... from their own direct social experiences but from watching the ... was most surprised at how emotionally "sophisticated" the babies were ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... Springboard Biodiesel, a California-based biodiesel ... BioPro™ biodiesel processors, announced on Thursday the release ... performance and efficiency of small-scale biodiesel producers throughout ... will recover more than 99% of the excess ... by-product produced while making biodiesel. After the ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... 31, 2014 Daily Gossip writes in its ... described as the fastest fat loss program ever developed. It ... a month. , There is no wonder after all that ... all time. The new nutrition and workout fat loss program ... expert. , According to the author of this fat ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... Lake City, UT (PRWEB) October 31, 2014 ... announce the new Activz Silver line offering ... and cleansing wipes. For over a century, silver has ... formula found in Activz Silver products is the most ... U.S. patents, has a unique chemical structure that supports ...
(Date:10/31/2014)... cost, patients with early stage breast cancer may ... proton therapy versus whole breast irradiation (WBI), according ... MD Anderson Proton Therapy Center. , ... patient characteristics, researchers used Medicare reimbursement codes to ... partial and whole breast irradiation therapies and treatment ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Study Shows How Toddlers Adjust to Adult Anger 2Health News:Study Shows How Toddlers Adjust to Adult Anger 3Health News:Springboard Biodiesel Announces Release of New and Unique Methanol Recovery and Glycerin Treatment Equipment 2Health News:Springboard Biodiesel Announces Release of New and Unique Methanol Recovery and Glycerin Treatment Equipment 3Health News:Xtreme Fat Loss Diet Review Reveals How to Transform Your Body in 25 Days 2Health News:New Collection of Nano-particle Natural Silver Products by Activz Whole-Food Nutrition 2Health News:New Collection of Nano-particle Natural Silver Products by Activz Whole-Food Nutrition 3Health News:New Collection of Nano-particle Natural Silver Products by Activz Whole-Food Nutrition 4Health News:Proton therapy shown to be less costly than some alternative radiotherapy techniques 2Health News:Proton therapy shown to be less costly than some alternative radiotherapy techniques 3
... 12 The American Medical,Association (AMA) proudly presented ... Service Award Saturday at its semi-annual,policy-making meeting. Dr. ... award, which is granted for meritorious service in ... has devoted himself to advancing medical education," said,AMA ...
... 13 The following,release was issued today by ... will release Poverty in America: Beyond,the Numbers, a ... of,how and where local Catholic Charities agencies across ... in need of healthcare, food,employment, and housing services. ...
... , The Zaire species of Ebolavirus (ZEBOV) remains ... alone is responsible for 88% of human deaths from ... was moreover the species involved in the two-month long ... (DRC) .In spite of the mass of scientific data ...
... serious enough to require hospitalization are much less likely ... antiviral medications, according to a new study published in ... available online. While previous clinical trials have shown the ... if they were treated within 48 hours of the ...
... 12 What does a,thirty-nine foot Airstream Land Yacht ... more than 800 midlands, men last month, it was ... the disease. The Drive Against Prostate Cancer is ... cancer. Doctors Care and WIS-TV,sponsored The Drive in the ...
... Study Reinforces Organization,s Mission: Cancer ... Support for the Whole Family, the Whole Time, ... varied,medical treatments lies a new groundbreaking report confirming the ... of Medicine (IOM) has just released a study, Cancer ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Portland Physician Wins AMA Distinguished Service Award 2Health News:Catholic Charities USA to Release Report on November 15th that Shows Challenges Facing America's Poor 2Health News:New genetic lineage of Ebola virus discovered in great apes 2Health News:New genetic lineage of Ebola virus discovered in great apes 3Health News:Antivirals reduce deaths from flu in hospitalized patients 2Health News:UCI Medical Affiliates, Inc. Sponsors Doctors Care Record-breaking Drive Against Prostate Cancer 2Health News:Gilda's Club Worldwide is a Proven Partner in Quality Cancer Care 2
(Date:11/1/2014)... companies EBI, LLC, of New Jersey , and ... pay the United States $6.07 million to ... the companies, bone growth stimulators. The settlement this week ... Biomet, Yue Yu, pursuant to the qui tam provisions ... , LLP, a Philadelphia -based personal injury law ...
(Date:11/1/2014)... Wash. , Oct. 31, 2014 Talyst, ... at the 2014 American Society of Consultant Pharmacists (ASCP) ... The meeting and expo will bring together pharmacists and ... the latest technologies. In recent years, ... focus for LTC pharmacies. The InSite® System, Talyst,s LTC ...
(Date:11/1/2014)... and CHICAGO , Oct. 31, 2014 ... Durata Therapeutics, Inc. (NASDAQ: DRTX ) today ... granted early termination of the waiting period under the ... to Actavis, pending acquisition of Durata. Logo ... termination of the HSR waiting period satisfies one of ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Biomet to Pay Over $6 Million to Resolve Whistleblower Claims That It Paid Kickbacks to Doctors 2Talyst Exhibits at ASCP Annual Meeting 2Actavis and Durata Therapeutics Receive U.S. FTC Clearance for Actavis' Proposed Acquisition of Durata 2Actavis and Durata Therapeutics Receive U.S. FTC Clearance for Actavis' Proposed Acquisition of Durata 3Actavis and Durata Therapeutics Receive U.S. FTC Clearance for Actavis' Proposed Acquisition of Durata 4Actavis and Durata Therapeutics Receive U.S. FTC Clearance for Actavis' Proposed Acquisition of Durata 5Actavis and Durata Therapeutics Receive U.S. FTC Clearance for Actavis' Proposed Acquisition of Durata 6
... 2011 As part of a nationwide effort to prevent ... supporting National Prescription Drug Take-Back Day, which is ... on Saturday, October 29. "Unused prescription medicines that ... are not handled properly," said Paul Kaplan, M.D., BCBSD Vice ...
... information from a recent proprietary study affirming that seeing is ... seeing was an overwhelming choice, selected by 10 times as ... "This research affirms how important seeing is to people and ... VisionSpring President. "With over 700 million people in the world ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Blue Cross Blue Shield of Delaware Supports the Drug Enforcement Administration's "National Prescription Drug Take-Back Day" 2VisionSpring Research Finds Seeing to be the Most Important of Five Senses 2
... Progesterone (pregn-4-ene-3, 20-dione) is a C21 steroid ... double bond between C-4 and C-5 (?4).,This ... which, in conjunction with estrogens, regulates,the accessory ... is particularly important in preparing the,endometrium for ...
Microalbumin Turbidimetric Lipid / Protein Quantification 021-SDX001...
... Angiotensin Converting Enzyme (ACE), also known ... (EC 3.4.15.1) with a molecular weight of ... glycoprotein shows a single polypeptide chain, a ... is present in many different cell types ...
Beta-2 Microglobulin EIA Lipid / Protein Quantification 025-BC-1061...
Medicine Products: