Navigation Links
Wyeth v. Levine: Preemption and The Facts
Date:10/17/2008

n of the drug to Ms. Levine, the product labeling listed four separate warnings about risks of improper administration of IV Phenergan. The appropriate use of the product and the wording of the warnings had been reviewed multiple times over the years by FDA as well as by an expert advisory committee, and reflected FDA's careful consideration of decades of data on Phenergan use. All drugs have risks, and FDA must balance those risks against the benefits to the public health. There is no evidence, argument, or even suggestion that Wyeth concealed or failed to provide the FDA with any relevant information about the risks associated with Phenergan.

Notwithstanding the view of the FDA, a Vermont jury determined that Wyeth failed to adequately warn about the risk of IV push Phenergan. However, the FDA-approved labeling for Phenergan was mandated by federal law. Absent any new evidence, Wyeth could not change Phenergan's labeling to comply with the labeling sought by the Vermont jury without violating federal law. This is true even if the change is intended to add or strengthen a contraindication or warning.

-- Preemption Protects Everyone

The Constitutional principle of preemption is not new. Preemption arises from the U.S. Constitution, which under the Supremacy Clause invalidates all state laws that conflict or interfere with federal law. In Wyeth v. Levine, the Vermont's jury verdict was in direct conflict with the FDA's considered scientific judgment.

Patients and physicians need to be able to rely on a single federal standard and guidelines for the risks, benefits, and use of medicines -- the FDA-approved labeling. The public health is better served by having a single expert regulatory body making decisions about risks, benefits, and warnings -- rather than an ad hoc system that could produce hundreds of conflicting results that would be impossible for manufacturers, physicians, and patients to reconcile or interpret. Such a system would u
'/>"/>

SOURCE Wyeth
Copyright©2008 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Wyeth and Nycomed Announce Court Denial of Preliminary Injunction
2. Wyeths Pearl River, N.Y. Facility Celebrates 100 Years of Achievements in Health care
3. Wyeth Announces Election of Bernard Poussot as CEO of Company Effective January 1, 2008
4. Wyeth Announces the Election of Robert M. Amen to Its Board of Directors
5. Wyeth Comments on PREVNAR and Trends in Pneumococcal Disease
6. Wyeth to Appeal Nevada Hormone Therapy Trial Verdict
7. Wyeth Reports Earnings Results for the 2007 Third Quarter and First Nine Months
8. Wyeth Consumer Healthcare Initiates Voluntary Recall and Replacement Program for Several Robitussin Products and Childrens Dimetapp Cold & Chest Congestion
9. Wyeth Consumer Healthcare Announces the Availability of Centrum Cardio and New Formula Centrum Products
10. Wyeth to Present at the Credit Suisse First Boston Healthcare Conference
11. Wyeth Receives FDA Approval of Protonix for Delayed-Release Oral Suspension
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:4/27/2015)... Texas (PRWEB) April 27, 2015 Fitness ... the Nation, is starting a health and fitness revolution, ... the fight against obesity. For several years, Houston, the ... one of the fattest cities in America. With help ... and make it one of the fittest and healthiest ...
(Date:4/27/2015)... Los Angeles, CA (PRWEB) April 27, 2015 ... titled “How to Get Rid of Stretch Marks ,” ... stretch marks . Stretch marks are a ... women. Stretch marks are caused by a breakdown of the ... beneath the epidermis. (see: goo.gl/iRdmEe) , “Stretch mark removal ...
(Date:4/27/2015)... According to a recent report from NIDCR ... back pain, TMJ disorders are the second most ... In addition, the report revealed that TMJ disorders affect ... an estimated 4 billion dollars annually. , These estimates ... unrelated symptoms such as headaches, neck pain, tenderness of ...
(Date:4/27/2015)... Thanks to a $7.5 million grant ... half-dozen institutions, including American University, will operate in a ... and behavioral research aimed at ending the AIDS epidemic. ... with HIV or AIDS, according to the latest statistics. ... population over the age of 13 was living with ...
(Date:4/27/2015)... 27, 2015 Doctors on Liens ... a lien basis for over twenty years. So when attorneys ... best doctor in the Fresno area , Doctors on ... and his team of medical specialists. With a medical ... therapist, Dilanchian Chiropractic is now helping more personal ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Houston Celebrities Take a Stand and Rebel Against Obesity 2Health News:Stretch Marks: The Latest Treatment Options for Stretch Mark Removal 2Health News:Dentist in Graham NC Reveals that a Jaw Disorder May Be the Cause of Chronic Headaches and Back Pain 2Health News:D.C. Center for AIDS Research Established with New Grant from NIH 2Health News:D.C. Center for AIDS Research Established with New Grant from NIH 3Health News:Eminent Doctor Joins Forces with Doctors on Liens in Fresno 2
... a recognized leader in providing turnkey electronic billing ... announced today that it has signed an agreement ... Corporation, to provide electronic clearinghouse services for Aon ... will enable Aon eSolutions, clients and medical providers ...
... highlights new hospitalist HIDI(TM) process at the 2009 ... ExecutivesSEATTLE, March 23 Hospital executives find themselves ... percent of America,s hospitals now operating at a ... Hospital leaders seek to control costs while maintaining ...
... Adds Advanced Drug Safety and Risk Management Applications to Extend ... News Facts , , ... that it has agreed to acquire Relsys International, Inc. ("Relsys"), ... with advanced analytics for the health sciences industry. , ...
... Volumes Seen in Houston Physician-Owned Hospitals, According ... 23 HealthLeaders-InterStudy, a leading provider of ... Texas laws favoring physicians have traditionally enabled ... directly with health systems, these regulations may ...
... (Nasdaq: WBMD ), the leading provider of ... a long-term strategic relationship with Boots UK Limited, the ... Kingdom, to jointly develop a consumer health and wellness ... will leverage WebMD,s online consumer health assets and expertise ...
... 23 Dr. Kevin Polk, a clinical psychologist with ... offering a new web program and DVD for stress ... Training (ACT). It emphasizes decreasing struggling with stress and ... traditional stress management techniques such as deep breathing and ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:WorkCompEDI Announces Agreement with Aon eSolutions for Electronic Billing Services 2Health News:Sound Inpatient Physicians Report on New Clinical Processes to Reduce Healthcare Costs and Enhance Care 2Health News:Oracle Buys Relsys 2Health News:Oracle Buys Relsys 3Health News:In Texas, Favorable Regulations for Physicians May Backfire in Light of Market Downturn 2Health News:WebMD Announces Strategic Relationship with Boots UK to Launch New Consumer Health Portal in UK 2Health News:WebMD Announces Strategic Relationship with Boots UK to Launch New Consumer Health Portal in UK 3Health News:Surfing Your Stress to Success Program Offers a New Way of Dealing with Stress 2
(Date:4/27/2015)... 2015  Recognizing the unique position Massachusetts ... the most respected organizations in the New England medtech community, ... Industry Council (MassMEDIC), have partnered to celebrate the region,s ... Annual Massachusetts Medtech Week. This celebration will take place May ... Center in Boston . For more information ...
(Date:4/27/2015)... Mass. , April 27, 2015 ... a collaboration with Brainlab AG, a leading software-driven ... planning and surgical navigation. The collaboration provides patients ... Stimulation (DBS) therapy. DBS is intended to treat ... help reduce symptoms for movement disorders such as ...
(Date:4/27/2015)... , April 27, 2015  CryoLife, Inc. (NYSE: ... processing company focused on cardiac and vascular surgery, announced ... the United States Food and Drug Administration ("FDA") verifying ... in place following the warning letter it received from ... letter follows a re-inspection in March 2015 by the ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:First Annual Massachusetts Medtech Week Celebrated this May 2First Annual Massachusetts Medtech Week Celebrated this May 3Boston Scientific Announces Strategic Collaboration With Brainlab AG 2Boston Scientific Announces Strategic Collaboration With Brainlab AG 3Boston Scientific Announces Strategic Collaboration With Brainlab AG 4CryoLife Announces Resolution of FDA Warning Letter 2
... Corporation , today announced that the U.S. Patent and ... which brings their total portfolio to 20 and bolsters ... wireless location systems (RTLS) for hospitals. (Logo: ... cover Awarepoint,s most accurate mesh-based location algorithm to date, ...
... opening ceremony for the world,s largest stem cell medical center ... ( www.rnl.co.kr ), South Korea,s premier adult stem cell firm ... in Beijing, China. Beijing RNL Stem Cell Medical Center is ... Li Hailing, www.yandaco.com ). Beijing RNL Stem Cell Medical ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Awarepoint Advances Industry Leadership with New Patented Technology 2RNL Opens the World's Largest Stem Cell Medical Center in Beijing, China 2
Set of six replacement burrs for E0824 Storz corneal burr set. Dull finish. Most popular size or model....
Replacement burr for E0819A or E0819B Algerbrush rust ring remover. Dull finish....
0.5 mm replacement burr for Algerbrush rust ring remover (E0815 A). Burr can also be used with Algerbrush rust ring remover (E0815 B). Dull finish....
5.5 mm disk shape burr. Diamond coated tip. Use with E0824 B handle....
Medicine Products: