Navigation Links
Why the MRC didn't fund research that led to the birth of the world's first test tube baby
Date:7/24/2010

Thirty-two years ago today, the world's first baby was born after in vitro fertilisation. However, the work that led to the birth of Louise Brown on 25 July 1978 had to be privately funded after the UK's Medical Research Council decided in 1971 against providing the Cambridge physiologist Robert Edwards and the Oldham gynaecologist Patrick Steptoe with long-term financial support. Today, an intriguing paper published in Europe's leading reproductive medicine journal Human Reproduction [1] reveals for the first time the reasoning behind the MRC's much-criticised decision.

The authors of the research, led by Martin Johnson, Professor of Reproductive Sciences at the University of Cambridge, and funded by the Wellcome Trust, write: "The failure of Edwards' and Steptoe's application for long-term support was not simply due to widespread establishment hostility to IVF. It failed, we argue for more complex reasons".

These reasons included:

  • A strategic error by Edwards and Steptoe when they declined an invitation from the MRC to join a new, directly funded Clinical Research Centre at Northwick Park Hospital, Harrow. They preferred to ask for long-term grant support at the University of Cambridge, but this meant they had to compete for funding with all the other research projects bidding for MRC support. This was also difficult for Cambridge, which lacked the back-up of an academic Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at that time.

  • Most of the MRC referees who were consulted on the proposal considered, in line with government policy, that it was more important to limit fertility and the growth of Britain's population than to treat infertility. Treating infertility was seen as experimental research rather than as therapeutic.

  • Concerns about embryo quality (would babies be born with severe abnormalities?) and patient safety made the referees doubt the wisdom of funding embryo transfer without conducting stud
    '/>"/>

Contact: Emma Mason
wordmason@mac.com
European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. OHSU Knight Cancer Institute researchers isolate importance of gene in breast cancer prognosis
2. $9M NIH grant renewal awarded to Case Western Reserve/UHCMC Center for AIDS Research
3. Researchers pinpoint key stem cells for eating and sex
4. Research links recreational pool disinfectants to health problems
5. BUSPH researchers link widely used chemicals to ADHD in children
6. Research consortium at CHLA receives $410,000 to study leukemia and lymphoma
7. Concordia researcher leads study that finds kids reduce physical activity for heart patients
8. U of Us Janice Morse inducted into International Nurse Researcher Hall of Fame
9. Researchers Use Ecstasy to Treat PTSD
10. Licensed Florida Tech research makes lab work easier
11. New research finds major activation themes in denture-stomatitis
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/29/2015)... Calgary, AB (PRWEB) , ... August 29, 2015 ... ... congestive heart failure, angina, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (including emphysema), or asthma, are ... conditions such as angina, previous heart attack, heart failure or heart-rhythm problems (arrhythmia ...
(Date:8/29/2015)... ... August 29, 2015 , ... Vascular Health ... and sell Arterosil and Arterosil HP, and that all claims and counterclaims have ... Health Sciences, LLC (VHS) in the United States District Court for the Southern ...
(Date:8/28/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... August 28, 2015 , ... An online ... decision to make the purchase of CPAP equipment more affordable by offering shipping at ... all types of CPAP products and orders of any size. My Cpap Store is ...
(Date:8/28/2015)... ... August 28, 2015 , ... An article published August 19th by ... has gone through to open a pizzeria in Westchester. Mr. LaRocco was aware from ... several months, but the current process, having already gone on for over a year, ...
(Date:8/28/2015)... VA (PRWEB) , ... August ... ... Risk Management for Medical Devices:, Understanding the FDA’s Position and Best Practices ... MD, http://www.fdanews.com/cybersecuritymd , This workshop, chaired by internationally renowned expert ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Heart Fit Clinic Sounds the Alarm on Forest Fire Smoke and Chronic Heart Disease in Calgary Area 2Health News:My Cpap Store Now Offering Delivery Special 0 Cost to You 2Health News:Article on Building Approval Process for LA Business Highlights the Need for a Bridge Between Businesses and City Officials, says Fire Protection Group Inc. 2Health News:FDAnews Announces — Software and Cybersecurity Risk Management for Medical Devices: Understanding the FDA’s Position and Best Practices for Compliance, Oct. 14-15 2Health News:FDAnews Announces — Software and Cybersecurity Risk Management for Medical Devices: Understanding the FDA’s Position and Best Practices for Compliance, Oct. 14-15 3Health News:FDAnews Announces — Software and Cybersecurity Risk Management for Medical Devices: Understanding the FDA’s Position and Best Practices for Compliance, Oct. 14-15 4Health News:FDAnews Announces — Software and Cybersecurity Risk Management for Medical Devices: Understanding the FDA’s Position and Best Practices for Compliance, Oct. 14-15 5
... from fungi and lower animals may well be suitable as ... a small protein molecule that can even destroy highly resistant ... and of the Danish company Novozymes AS have shed light ... as a promising lead compound for new antibiotics. These ...
... ... on board a flight from London to Los Angeles helped stabilize a flight attendant who suffered ... Montreal to care for this victim. , ... (Vocus) May 28, 2010 -- Dr. Semira Bayati was onboard United Airlines flight 935 ...
... Helicobacter pylori , which lives in the human stomach and ... a corkscrew, or helix. For years researchers have hypothesized that ... and thrive within the stomach,s acid-drenched environment, but ... first time, researchers at Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center have ...
... pleased to announce that Executive Director, Henry Gabelnick, Ph.D, ... International Microbicides 2010 Conference. This year,s conference, Building ... May 22-25 and before an audience of more than ... for his unparalleled commitment and dedication to the development ...
... into place instead of breaking it, researchers explain , ... for the treatment of bunions appears to correct the ... invasive surgery. , The novel procedure -- developed by ... and ankle program and an assistant professor of orthopedic ...
... Study found mood of those with sensitivities worsened when ... -- Allergy season may not mean just the inevitable ... your mood. , Researchers reported that finding at the ... week. , "Depression is a very common disorder and ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:New weapon against highly resistant microbes within grasp 2Health News:Orange County Plastic Surgeon Helps Stabilize Wounded Flight Attendant Requiring an Emergency Landing 2Health News:Orange County Plastic Surgeon Helps Stabilize Wounded Flight Attendant Requiring an Emergency Landing 3Health News:Shape matters: The corkscrew twist of H. pylori enables it to 'set up shop' in the stomach 2Health News:Shape matters: The corkscrew twist of H. pylori enables it to 'set up shop' in the stomach 3Health News:Henry Gabelnick receives lifetime achievement award 2Health News:New Bunion Procedure Aims to Replace Invasive Foot Surgery 2Health News:Allergies Might Trigger Depression 2
(Date:8/27/2015)... PARAMUS, N.J. , Aug. 27, 2015   Women Grow ... the cannabis industry, is partnering with the Cannabis World ... Angeles to produce 15 business-focused educational sessions. CWCBExpo ... Los Angeles Convention Center in ... business event on the West Coast for the marijuana industry. ...
(Date:8/27/2015)... MARIETTA, Ga. , Aug. 27, 2015  MiMedx ... regenerative medicine company utilizing human amniotic tissue and ... and therapies for the Wound Care, Surgical, Orthopedic, ... healthcare, responded today and corrected the multiple inaccuracies ... Transplant Foundation ("MTF") regarding the recent rulings from ...
(Date:8/27/2015)... 27, 2015   NineSigma the leading innovation partner ... in estimated overall revenue growth and anticipates the creation of ... Open Innovation Incentive (OII). In 2013, the ... grant of over $2 million to accelerate adoption of open ... Million and $1 Billion in revenues. To date over 45 ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Cannabis World Congress in Los Angeles Boasts Women Grow Sponsored Education 2Cannabis World Congress in Los Angeles Boasts Women Grow Sponsored Education 3Cannabis World Congress in Los Angeles Boasts Women Grow Sponsored Education 4MiMedx Corrects Inaccuracies In MTF Press Release Regarding The Recent Rulings From The Patent Trial And Appeal Board 2MiMedx Corrects Inaccuracies In MTF Press Release Regarding The Recent Rulings From The Patent Trial And Appeal Board 3MiMedx Corrects Inaccuracies In MTF Press Release Regarding The Recent Rulings From The Patent Trial And Appeal Board 4State of Ohio and NineSigma Collaborate to Drive Regional Economic Growth and Job Creation 2State of Ohio and NineSigma Collaborate to Drive Regional Economic Growth and Job Creation 3
... 4, 2007 - Molecular Insight,Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (NASDAQ: ... the results of several preclinical studies at,the ... Nuclear Medicine (SNM) in,Washington, D.C. The presentations ... clinical-stage, targeted,radiotherapeutic candidate for the treatment of ...
... ZymoGenetics,Inc. today announced that interim findings were presented ... B-cell chronic,lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL) at the American Society ... included intravenous,administration of higher doses than had been ... was well-tolerated and biologically,active at all dose levels ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Molecular Insight Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Presents Preclinical Data,at Society Of Nuclear Medicine 2007 Annual Meeting 2Molecular Insight Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Presents Preclinical Data,at Society Of Nuclear Medicine 2007 Annual Meeting 3Molecular Insight Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Presents Preclinical Data,at Society Of Nuclear Medicine 2007 Annual Meeting 4ZymoGenetics Reports Results From Atacicept Phase 1b Clinical Trial,in B-Cell Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia 2ZymoGenetics Reports Results From Atacicept Phase 1b Clinical Trial,in B-Cell Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia 3
... Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) is produced in the ... the gonads [1,2,3]. DHEA serves as a ... has relatively weak androgenic activity, estimated at ... neonates, peripubertal children and in adult women, ...
... is the first, easy-to-use, non-invasive diagnostic ... rule-in cardiac dysfunction including acute heart ... high-risk cardiac conditions. Designed to seamlessly ... products enable clinicians caring for cardiac ...
... by 5-monodeioination of thyroxine (T4) in extrathyroidal ... occurs at a rate which is ~3-fold ... T3 from the thyroid gland into the ... 80-100 micrograms/day for T4. In addition, approximately ...
... Binding Protein (GHBP) is the soluble, extra-cellular domain ... an integral component of the growth hormone-insulin-like growth ... it is either a cleavage product of the ... GH receptor gene. Growth Hormone receptor cleavage ...
Medicine Products: