Navigation Links
Why the MRC didn't fund research that led to the birth of the world's first test tube baby
Date:7/24/2010

Thirty-two years ago today, the world's first baby was born after in vitro fertilisation. However, the work that led to the birth of Louise Brown on 25 July 1978 had to be privately funded after the UK's Medical Research Council decided in 1971 against providing the Cambridge physiologist Robert Edwards and the Oldham gynaecologist Patrick Steptoe with long-term financial support. Today, an intriguing paper published in Europe's leading reproductive medicine journal Human Reproduction [1] reveals for the first time the reasoning behind the MRC's much-criticised decision.

The authors of the research, led by Martin Johnson, Professor of Reproductive Sciences at the University of Cambridge, and funded by the Wellcome Trust, write: "The failure of Edwards' and Steptoe's application for long-term support was not simply due to widespread establishment hostility to IVF. It failed, we argue for more complex reasons".

These reasons included:

  • A strategic error by Edwards and Steptoe when they declined an invitation from the MRC to join a new, directly funded Clinical Research Centre at Northwick Park Hospital, Harrow. They preferred to ask for long-term grant support at the University of Cambridge, but this meant they had to compete for funding with all the other research projects bidding for MRC support. This was also difficult for Cambridge, which lacked the back-up of an academic Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at that time.

  • Most of the MRC referees who were consulted on the proposal considered, in line with government policy, that it was more important to limit fertility and the growth of Britain's population than to treat infertility. Treating infertility was seen as experimental research rather than as therapeutic.

  • Concerns about embryo quality (would babies be born with severe abnormalities?) and patient safety made the referees doubt the wisdom of funding embryo transfer without conducting stud
    '/>"/>

Contact: Emma Mason
wordmason@mac.com
European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. OHSU Knight Cancer Institute researchers isolate importance of gene in breast cancer prognosis
2. $9M NIH grant renewal awarded to Case Western Reserve/UHCMC Center for AIDS Research
3. Researchers pinpoint key stem cells for eating and sex
4. Research links recreational pool disinfectants to health problems
5. BUSPH researchers link widely used chemicals to ADHD in children
6. Research consortium at CHLA receives $410,000 to study leukemia and lymphoma
7. Concordia researcher leads study that finds kids reduce physical activity for heart patients
8. U of Us Janice Morse inducted into International Nurse Researcher Hall of Fame
9. Researchers Use Ecstasy to Treat PTSD
10. Licensed Florida Tech research makes lab work easier
11. New research finds major activation themes in denture-stomatitis
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:7/2/2015)... ... July 02, 2015 , ... Following the recent report by JAMA Internal ... outnumber merely overweight Americans, Samir Becic emphatically declared a war on obesity in the ... now," Becic said. "We must understand the magnitude of this discovery. For that reason, ...
(Date:7/2/2015)... , ... July 02, 2015 , ... ... Edwards (D-Md.) for her introduction of the Stop Overdose Stat (S.O.S.) Act of ... Senator Jack Reed (D-R.I.), this Act seeks to decrease drug overdose – especially ...
(Date:7/2/2015)... , ... July 02, 2015 , ... ... parking structure retrofit project at the University of Minnesota, they knew it would ... it would also be an award-winning choice: the total energy savings after installation ...
(Date:7/2/2015)... ... ... Many Fourth of July celebrations will include fireworks this summer, so it’s important ... tips to promote the proper use of fireworks. , According to the U.S. Consumer ... fireworks-related injuries in the month surrounding the Fourth of July. Amica is sharing the ...
(Date:7/2/2015)... ... 02, 2015 , ... With summer in full swing, Americans are flocking to Canada’s many lakes ... spots for fishing in the world, and it’s easy to understand why. From the Pacific ... fish. , Recreational fishing is a huge industry, and Americans make up the vast ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Samir Becic's Health Fitness Revolution Declares War Against Obesity in America 2Health News:Samir Becic's Health Fitness Revolution Declares War Against Obesity in America 3Health News:Samir Becic's Health Fitness Revolution Declares War Against Obesity in America 4Health News:AAPCC Supports the Stop Overdose Stat Act of 2015 2Health News:AAPCC Supports the Stop Overdose Stat Act of 2015 3Health News:Kenall’s TekDek™ Helps University Achieve Award-Winning Energy Savings in Parking Structure Lighting Retrofit 2Health News:6 Fireworks Safety Tips from Amica Insurance 2
... based in Boston, MA, is pleased to announce that ... Products ("IZI" or the "Company"). Founded in 1991, IZI ... in Image Guided Surgery ("IGS"), radiology and radiation ... used with MRI, CT, and PET technologies, to highly ...
... PRA International, a leading Clinical Research Organization, announces it ... Congress scheduled for April 21-24, 2009, in Washington, D.C. ... Management at PRA, will chair the session, while Mark ... discuss "Assessment of stakeholders for risk mitigation strategies." The ...
... Research Network (MRN) will bring world-leading technology to ... a device for non-invasive measurement of brain activity ... MEG technology to study brain function and disorders ... organization will upgrade to the Elekta Neuromag MEG ...
... Alliance for Progress program, to improve healthcare in the developing world ... ... (PRWEB) April 17, 2009 -- In recognition of the World Federation ... hemophilia in developing countries through its Global Alliance for Progress (GAP) ...
... M.D., explains why the Law of Diminishing Returns applies ... obstacle to reaching a normal weight MIAMI, April ... Florida-based weight-loss practice, Siegal Medical Group, today confirmed the ... part of reaching a healthful weight is shedding the ...
... Intensive Care UnitATLANTA, April 17 The Marcus Foundation ... System to improve emergency care to trauma and acute ... enable Grady to expand hospital space for trauma and ... and acute neurological emergencies. The new facilities will ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Riverside Partners Teams with Management to Acquire IZI Medical Products 2Health News:PRA International to Present Key Challenges for Safety Professionals at the World Drug Safety Congress: PRA Experts discussing REMS at Washington DC Conference 2Health News:Elekta Chosen to Deliver Sophisticated Brain Mapping Technology to the Mind Research Network 2Health News:Elekta Chosen to Deliver Sophisticated Brain Mapping Technology to the Mind Research Network 3Health News:CSL Behring Marks World Hemophilia Day with $2M Coagulation Factor Donation to World Federation of Hemophilia 2Health News:CSL Behring Marks World Hemophilia Day with $2M Coagulation Factor Donation to World Federation of Hemophilia 3Health News:CSL Behring Marks World Hemophilia Day with $2M Coagulation Factor Donation to World Federation of Hemophilia 4Health News:Losing the Last Ten Pounds is the Hardest Part of any Diet Confirms Weight-Loss Expert and Author Dr. Sanford Siegal 2Health News:The Marcus Foundation Gives $20 Million to Grady Health System 2Health News:The Marcus Foundation Gives $20 Million to Grady Health System 3
(Date:7/2/2015)... and VANCOUVER , July 2, 2015 ... EPI) announced today that its common shares have been approved ... under the symbol "EPIX". ESSA will begin trading ... its listing on the TSX Venture Exchange under the symbol ... the common shares on the NASDAQ, each of the Company,s ...
(Date:7/2/2015)... ResMed Inc. (NYSE: RMD ) today announced ... ended June 30, 2015 results on Thursday, July 30, 2015, ... release with ResMed,s results will be issued after 1:00 p.m. ... to discuss operating results and future outlook. The ... Pacific Time and the live webcast of the call can ...
(Date:7/2/2015)... July 2, 2015  New product launches are critical ... role in educating thought leaders about new products, Medical ... influence how well a new therapy performs at launch. ... research and consulting leader Best Practices, LLC, critical aspects ... focus on are early stage thought leader (TL) interaction, ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:ESSA Pharma Inc. to Commence Trading on the NASDAQ Capital Market 2ESSA Pharma Inc. to Commence Trading on the NASDAQ Capital Market 3ESSA Pharma Inc. to Commence Trading on the NASDAQ Capital Market 4ResMed to Announce Fourth Quarter and Fiscal Year-End 2015 Results 2Medical Affairs Role in Thought Leader Education is Key Success Factor for New Product Launches in the Pharmaceutical Industry 2
... MOUNTAIN VIEW, Calif., Jan. 24, 2011 Based on ... (PERS) market, Frost & Sullivan recognizes BeClose with the ... Innovation of the Year for its innovative BeClose System ... (Logo:   http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20081117/FSLOGO ) While PERS ...
... Jan. 24, 2011 PharmAthene, Inc. (NYSE Amex: ... Court of Chancery, which commenced January 3, 2011, in its ... Friday, January 21, 2011. The Company anticipates that post trial ... of the court will be complete by the end of ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Frost & Sullivan Recognizes BeClose as a Technology Innovator for 'Aging Independently' in North America 2Frost & Sullivan Recognizes BeClose as a Technology Innovator for 'Aging Independently' in North America 3Frost & Sullivan Recognizes BeClose as a Technology Innovator for 'Aging Independently' in North America 4PharmAthene Provides Update on Litigation With SIGA Technologies 2
... Thermo Labsystems was designed specifically to combine ... such as the new fast dial system ... help to define this as a new ... interchangeable handle plate offers a custom fit ...
... new Finnpipette Focus from Thermo Labsystems was ... performance. Advanced features such as the ... volume adjustment on microvolumes help to define ... channel pipettes. The new interchangeable handle plate ...
... the range from 2ul to 5000ul. Fills ... design prevents inadvertent volume change. Novel hand ... pipette is autoclavable at 121C(250F). To prevent ... Suitable for one-handed operation. Auto or Normal ...
... The AlphaPette Pipettor is the #1 ... Offers accuracy, comfort, and reliability. Continuously ... volume readout sub-micrometer. Easy interchangeable ejector ... tiny hands. Adjustable rapid pipet tip ...
Medicine Products: