Navigation Links
Who should be saved? Study gets diverse MD community views on healthcare disaster planning
Date:5/14/2014

BALTIMOREIn the event of a flu pandemic, who should have priority access to life-saving ventilators, and who should make that determination? Few disaster preparedness plans have taken community values regarding allocation into account, but a new study is aiming to change that through public engagement with Maryland residents.

"In the event of a healthcare crisis, understanding the community perspective and having citizen buy-in will be critical to avoid compounding the initial disaster with further social upheaval," says principal investigator Elizabeth L. Daugherty Biddison, MD, MPH, Vice Chair for Clinical Operations in the Department of Medicine, Johns Hopkins School of Medicine.

"When life-saving medical resources become scarce, there are no ideal options, even among ethically-permissible ones. Understanding community perspectives and values will help policy-makers craft guidelines for those difficult choices," Biddison says.

To gain this perspective, Biddison and colleagues from the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics, Carnegie Mellon University and University of Pittsburgh Medical Center are exploring the use of "deliberative democratic methods" typically employed to understand how the public views potential policy changes. A pilot study consisted of two community meetings; one in affluent Howard County, which ranks top among the state's county health rankings, and the other in a neighborhood near Johns Hopkins Hospital in inner Baltimore City, which ranks last. The results were published online ahead of print in April in the Annals of the American Thoracic Society.

"We found that participants' ethical perspectives were framed in large part by their place-based life experiences," says Ruth R. Faden, PhD, MPH, director of the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics, a member of the study team. "Our results thus far underscore the importance of broad and diverse community input, to capture more fully the issues that matter to people of various backgrounds."

The community meetings followed the same procedures used to gather information on views related to controversial policy issues including marriage equality, regional tax sharing, and economic redevelopment. According to the study results, the Baltimore City group spent significant time discussing whether particular groups should be disqualified from access to ventilators, such as convicted felons and undocumented immigrants. The study authors connect these concerns directly to crime-rate and demographic trends in the area.

Members of the Howard County community group were recruited by a private-public partnership focused on strengthening local resilience to disasters, and focused on logistical concerns. According to the study, "County residents struggled with the implementation timeframe required by different approaches: would someone die without a ventilator while decision-makers were still making up their minds? County residents also expressed greater concern about the potential for bias in decision making."

Regarding the differences in focus between the two groups, the study states, "[T]he differences reflected distinct ways of thinking about the issues. This finding underscores the importance of achieving a diverse, regionally varied sample of Marylanders" for the project's planned expansion across the state. With such diverse feedback from citizens, "health authorities and elected officials will be better prepared both to shape and to communicate the content of Maryland's future framework in meaningful ways," the study concludes.

Biddison says that the state-wide expansion of the study will include at least 10 forums, five for general community members and five for healthcare professionals. The results will be shared with Maryland health officials for practical application to the state's policy on healthcare resource allocation in the event of a disaster.


'/>"/>

Contact: Leah Ramsay
lramsay@jhu.edu
202-642-9640
Johns Hopkins Medicine
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Canada should play a role in addressing the global cancer epidemic
2. New standards for treating traumatic shoulder injuries to improve patient care
3. Should oxygen be used for patients with chronic heart failure?
4. Men Can Still Ask for PSA Test, and Some Should, Doctors Say
5. Canada should significantly increase its funding of randomized clinical trials
6. Routine care for Crohns disease in children should include measurement of bone age
7. Older Women Should Not Take Calcium, Vitamin D: Task Force
8. Guidelines Issued for When Docs Should Order Vascular Testing
9. Presidential candidates should address childhood obesity and bullying, poll says
10. KORT Physical Therapist Says Shoulder Pain Shouldn’t Be Ignored
11. Ethics should drive health policy reform, especially with physician-owned specialty hospitals
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:7/27/2017)... ... 27, 2017 , ... Somnoware, a leading provider of digital ... solution to its healthcare management platform. This solution provides physicians with remote scoring ... of scoring in the cloud is on par with doing it on a ...
(Date:7/27/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... July 27, 2017 , ... The Los Angeles leg of the US ... 2017 at 7:00pm and will be held at the Clive Davis Theater inside the Grammy ... Camo Jacket, chronicles the story of the iconic Welsh rock musician, Mike Peters (of The ...
(Date:7/27/2017)... ... July 27, 2017 , ... Team Novo Nordisk, the ... to the men’s pro squad as a stagiaire for the remainder of the 2017 ... debut on July 31st at the Tour of Utah. , “Every season we are ...
(Date:7/26/2017)... ... July 26, 2017 , ... Capillus, LLC has announced the redesign of ... new Flexible Fitting Design offers a more comfortable, adaptable fit and is available for ... improvements to the home-use laser therapy caps intended to improve both user experience and ...
(Date:7/26/2017)... ... ... A major challenge many labs face is a direct result from a ... dry cycle are a few common challenges that can overcome when following best practices. ... and advancements in laboratory freeze dryers that will improve quality and reduce the time ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:7/27/2017)... Ind., July 27, 2017  Zimmer Biomet Holdings, Inc. ... quarter ended June 30, 2017.  The Company reported second ... 1.1% over the prior year period, and an increase ... 240 basis points of contribution from the LDR Holding ... the second quarter of 2016, or 0.3% on a ...
(Date:7/27/2017)... Pharmaceutical Services, Inc. (NYSE: WST ) today ... updated financial guidance for the full-year 2017. ... Reported net sales of $397.6 million, a record ... at constant currency (organic) grew by 3.9%. ... $0.60 in the prior-year quarter. Second-quarter 2017 adjusted diluted ...
(Date:7/26/2017)... July 26, 2017 E.I. Medical Imaging (EIMI) ... Bimini SharkLab to custom design the worlds first ultrasound system to ... in their native habitat. In preparation for a piece produced ... Shark Week, Dr. Guttridge approached EIMI with the idea ... directly to hammerhead sharks underwater. ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: