Navigation Links
When is it ethical to prescribe placebos?
Date:5/30/2012

The American Medical Association's Code of Ethics prohibits physicians from prescribing treatments that they consider to be placebos unless the patients know this and agree to take them anyway. But this policy is not clearly the best way to protect or benefit patients, concludes an The American Medical Association's Code of Ethics prohibits physicians from prescribing treatments that they consider to be placebos unless the patients know this and agree to take them anyway. But this policy is not clearly the best way to protect or benefit patients, concludes an article in the Hastings Center Report. A commentary by two AMA bioethicists responding to the article also appears in the journal.

Placebos are commonly understood to be inert treatments, such as sugar pills, that have no pharmacological effect, but the AMA defines placebos more narrowly, as therapies that a physician believes lack a specific pharmacological effect on the conditions being treated. The physician's belief may or may not align with the prevailing medical view of a treatment. "There are borderline and controversial cases, such as acupuncture and antidepressants, in which individual physicians might reasonably disagree with the medical community's consensus about whether a treatment is an active treatment or a placebo," writes Anne Barnhill, a philosopher and bioethicist who is studying social work at Columbia University.

The article cites a recent poll of American internists and rheumatologists that found that a significant number of them admit to giving patients placebos without disclosing the therapies as such. While some placebo use is patently unethical providing a treatment that "has no scientific basis and is dangerous, is calculated to deceive the patient by giving false hope, or which may cause the patien
'/>"/>

Contact: Michael Turton
turtonm@thehastingscenter.org
845-424-4040 x242
The Hastings Center
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Conference explores ethical dimension of NHS
2. Updating ethical guidelines for biomedical engineering
3. Internists remind physicians about universal ethical principles
4. Researchers see ethical dilemmas of providing care in drug detention centers
5. Author who revealed unethical Guatemala syphilis study writes for Bioethics Forum
6. Mayo Clinic review of ethical decision making with end-of-life care
7. Mayo Clinic finds withdrawing ventricular assist device support ethical
8. Hopkins faculty lead development of report to FDA on ethical, scientific issues related to post-market clinical trials
9. Scholar calls for a new legal, ethical framework for research with human tissue specimens
10. Primary care physicians nationwide face clinical ethical conflicts with religious hospitals
11. TV Doctors Bring Unethical Behavior to Prime Time
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/22/2014)... Americans know little about how Ebola is transmitted and harbor ... United States, a new survey shows. About four in ... a major Ebola outbreak in the United States, and one-quarter ... get sick with the deadly virus in the next year, ... However, those opinions don,t match reality, the Harvard researchers ...
(Date:8/22/2014)... Mi40x , the latest guide from ... people how they can use a simple 4-minute trick to ... of weeks has caught the attention of Shane Michaels, prompting ... the most well-known bodybuilders in the industry, and if he ... that in itself is a testament to how effective this ...
(Date:8/22/2014)... 2014 Paying tuition and other related ... coming year for four nurse educators pursuing advanced degrees, ... for Nursing Foundation for Nursing Education . This year’s ... $10,000 more than in 2013, thanks to these named ... Elizabeth Isaac Marcil Endowment Funds, both donated by Kathy ...
(Date:8/22/2014)... (PRWEB) August 22, 2014 Mueller Sports ... Plantar Fasciitis, an exciting new product that provides non-drug ... to stay active while you heal. The package includes ... truly a new technology – it is not kinesiology ... FasciaDerm® PFTape™ System for Plantar Fasciitis is ...
(Date:8/22/2014)... NJ. August 22, 2014. A new study ... persons with multiple sclerosis (MS) may be able ... The study was epublished ahead of print on ... Helen Genova, Hali Griswold, Nancy D. Chiaravalloti & ... persons with multiple sclerosis doi: 10.3233/NRE-141113). Self-awareness is ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Many Americans Harbor Unfounded Fears About Ebola Outbreak: Survey 2Health News:Mi40x: Review Exposes Ben Pakulski’s Guide to Packing on Lean Muscle Fast 2Health News:NLN Foundation for Nursing Education Announces 2014 Faculty Scholarship Awards 2Health News:NLN Foundation for Nursing Education Announces 2014 Faculty Scholarship Awards 3Health News:Mueller Introduces FasciaDerm® PFTape™ System for Plantar Fasciitis 2Health News:Kessler Foundation study of self-awareness in MS has implications for rehabilitation 2
... leading cause of infections in hospitals can be dramatically reduced, ... The program, cheap and easy to implement, is sparking intrigue ... , HPMC is the first acute care facility to successfully ... urine, currently under increased scrutiny for causing deadly infections in ...
... ,missiles, to hurl at visitors for his own amusement, report ... Santino, a male chimp at the Furuvik Zoo in Lund, ... the zoo opened collecting rocks and other "ammunition" to hurl ... around mid-morning. , He stored the items at various sites ...
... to Provide Information on Medicare Advantage Special Needs ... ROCK, Ark., March 9 A series of ... with chronic illness maintain a healthy lifestyle and ... for their unique needs will be offered during ...
... National Commander of the Disabled American Veterans begins a ... for budget reform legislation to ensure sufficient, timely and ... urging them to reject a contentious proposal that would ... from the government,s side of the ledger to insurance ...
... in the international journal Chest , by Neil ... disease (COPD) who breathed a mix of 60% helium ... to exercise longer and harder than those who breathed ... significant because research has shown that patients who perform ...
... announced in 2004 an initiative to have the health records of all ... this daunting task. However, unfortunately, unsatisfactory progress has been made to ... goal will likely be met by the 2014 deadline previously announced. ... ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Hollywood Hospital's Trend-Setting Program to Drastically Cut Infections 2Health News:Thinking Man's Chimp Shows 1st Animal 'Planning' 2Health News:Thinking Man's Chimp Shows 1st Animal 'Planning' 3Health News:Free Seminars Offered to Arkansas Seniors with Diabetes and Other Chronic Illnesses 2Health News:Disabled Veterans Leader Presses Issues with Key Lawmakers 2Health News:Helium helps lung patients breathe easier 2Health News:EMRConsultant.com Supports the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 2
(Date:8/21/2014)... , Aug. 21, 2014  IBM (NYSE: IBM ... ( DESY ), a leading national research center in ... and storage of massive volumes of x-ray data. The ... on IBM software defined technology can handle more than ... and help scientists worldwide gain faster insights into the ...
(Date:8/21/2014)... -- Seventy-one percent of Americans believe the abuse of strong prescription ... and safety issue in the United States ... Repass & Partners, a Cincinnati based ... of the prescription medication abuse problem and the need for ... situation facing our country," Rex Repass , CEO of ...
(Date:8/21/2014)... BreedIT Corp., (OTCQB: BRDT) ... worldwide license holder and distributor of highly sophisticated ... today is pleased to announce the formation of ... a leading Israeli medical Cannabis breeder. ... breeds of medical Cannabis to meet the requests ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:DESY and IBM Develop Big Data Architecture for Science 2DESY and IBM Develop Big Data Architecture for Science 3Consumers Desperate For Measures To Curb Prescription Drug Abuse 2Consumers Desperate For Measures To Curb Prescription Drug Abuse 3BreedIT Ltd. and Seach Ltd. Form KanaboSeed to Develop New Medical Cannabis Varieties 2BreedIT Ltd. and Seach Ltd. Form KanaboSeed to Develop New Medical Cannabis Varieties 3BreedIT Ltd. and Seach Ltd. Form KanaboSeed to Develop New Medical Cannabis Varieties 4
... Health Organization has issued a warning to medical travelers: ... heels of a growing threat of an antibiotic-resistant superbug, ... the region in India where it was discovered. "Many ... or knee replacements, ACL surgeries, root canals and spinal ...
...  Neuro Kinetics, Inc. (NKI) ( www.neuro-kinetics.com ), manufacturers ... test for vestibular and neurological conditions, said today ... control and analysis software at the upcoming annual ... Boston ( http://am2010.entnet.org/ ). NKI will ...
Cached Medicine Technology:New York Plastic Surgery News: Medical Tourists Beware of Drug-Resistant Superbug NDM-1 2Neuro Kinetics to Showcase Enhanced Control & Analysis Software at Otolaryngology Conference 2
Reusable shielded cable...
... The STREP A OIA MAX test ... of Group A Strep with a simple, ... minutes. This combination of performance, speed, and ... care while reducing overall costs for diagnosing ...
The GC OIA test is a rapid assay for the diagnosis of gonorrhea. Thermo solved the challenge of developing a specific rapid assay for Neisseria gonorrhea by using the proprietary ribosomal protein, ...
... a high performance assay for the undifferentiated ... with a simple, easy-to-use test that provides ... Assay advantages include superior performance with mucoid ... 14-day viral culture enables you to decrease ...
Medicine Products: