Navigation Links
We're emotionally distant and that's just fine by me

When it comes to having a lasting and fulfilling relationship, common wisdom says that feeling close to your romantic partner is paramount. But a new study finds that it's not how close you feel that matters most, it's whether you are as close as you want to be, even if that's really not close at all.

"Our study found that people who yearn for a more intimate partnership and people who crave more distance are equally at risk for having a problematic relationship," says the study's lead author, David M. Frost, PhD, of Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. "If you want to experience your relationship as healthy and rewarding, it's important that you find a way to attain your idealized level of closeness with your partner."

Results will be published in the April issue of the Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, and will also appear ahead of print online on February 13.

A sample of 732 men and women, living across the U.S. and Canada, completed three yearly surveys online. They answered questions about relationship closeness, relationship satisfaction, commitment, break-up thoughts, and symptoms of depression. Current and ideal closeness were assessed by choosing from six sets of overlapping circles; varying degrees of overlap signified degrees of closeness. This well-established psychological measure of closeness is known as Inclusion of Other in Self and indicates a couple's "we-ness" or shared identity, values, viewpoints, resources, and personality traits.

More than half of respondents (57%) reported feeling too much distance between themselves and their partner; 37% were content with the level of closeness in their relationship; and a small minority (5%) reported feeling too close. The degree of difference between a respondent's actual and idealtheir "closeness discrepancy"correlated with poorer relationship quality and more frequent symptoms of depression. The effect was the same whether the respondent reported feeling "too close for comfort" or "not close enough." Surprisingly, the negative effects of closeness discrepancies were evident regardless of how close people felt to their partners; what mattered was the discrepancy, not the closeness.

Over the two-year study period, some respondents' experiences of closeness became aligned with their ideals. In such cases, their relationship quality and mental health improved. The inverse was also true. Those who increasingly felt "too close" or "not close enough" over time were more likely to grow unhappy in their relationships and ultimately break up with their partners.

Closeness discrepancies could shape new approaches to psychotherapy, both for couples and individuals, because it takes seriously real differences in the amount of closeness people want in their relationships, says Dr. Frost, a psychologist and professor of Population and Family Health at the Mailman School.

"It's best not to make too many assumptions about what constitutes a healthy relationship," he says. "Rather, we need to hear from people about how close they are in their relationships and how that compares to how close they'd ideally like to be."

Ongoing studies are looking at the issue of closeness discrepancies from both sides of a relationship to see how someone's sense of relationship closeness might differ from their partners, whether someone's closeness discrepancy affects their partners, and how it affects their sex life. The concept could also be extended to non-romantic relationships such as co-workers, parent-child, and patient-provider interactions.

Contact: Timothy S. Paul
Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health

Related medicine news :

1. For Hospitals, Lowered Death Rates May Not Mean More Readmissions
2. Lung Cancer Asbestos Victims Center Now Urges All US Navy Veterans With Any Type Of Lung Cancer To Call Them About Possible Compensation-Were You Exposed To Asbestos
3. Lung Cancer Asbestos Victims Center Now Urges All Lung Cancer Victims To Call Them If They Were Exposed To Asbestos In The Workplace-For Possible Significant Compensation
4. Lung Cancer Asbestos Victims Center Now Urges Non Smokers To Call Them If They Now Have Lung Cancer And Were Exposed To Asbestos On The Job-Possible Major Compensation
5. Lung Cancer Asbestos Victims Center Urges Families Of Lung Cancer Victims To Ask The Victim If They Were Exposed To Asbesto On the Job And To Call Them If They Say-Yes
6. Lung Cancer Asbestos Victims Center Urges All Lung Cancer Victims With A Out Of The Blue Diagnosis To Consider Asbestos Exposure And to Call Them If They Were Exposed
7. Lung Cancer Asbestos Victims Center's National Initiative Is Focused On Financial Compensation For Lung Cancer Victims Who Were exposed To Asbestos In Their Workplace
8. US Drug Watchdog Now Urges Family Members Of Diabetics Who Used the Diabetes Drug Actos and Then Were Diagnosed with Bladder Cancer to Call The Johnson Law Group ASAP
9. At least 1 in 5 were infected in flu pandemic, international study suggests
10. Leading Melbourne Dentist Launches 100% Renewable Energy Powered Procedures for Cosmetic Dentistry, Implants and Dental Services
11. US Drug Watchdog Now Urges Women Who Had A Out Of The Blue Heart Attack Or Stroke Who Were Also Using Yaz or Yasmin Birth Control Pills To Call The Johnson Law Group ASAP
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/13/2015)... , ... October 13, 2015 , ... ... celebrating the opening of the Integrative Biosciences Center (IBio), a $93 million facility ... A grand opening celebration will be held at 10:30 a.m. Wednesday, Oct. 14, ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 14, 2015 , ... The ... of needle-placement technique in radiofrequency ablation for treatment of lumbar facet arthropathy ”. ... in nature, highlights the importance of anatomically correct needle placement technique for lumbar ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... The Lymphoma Research Foundation (LRF) ... and serving the lymphoma community through a comprehensive series of education programs, outreach ... A Commitment to Cure last night at the Mandarin Oriental in New York ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... 13, 2015 , ... “Women have 2 questions when they find out they ... second is, “Will I lose my hair?’” , Carly Klein is the Founder of ... medical professionals to develop personalized hair loss treatment plans. With 10 years’ experience in ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... Though trick-or-treating remains ... confines of their home. Whether it's making fun pre or post trick-or-treat snacks ... Florida Dairy Farmers. , Recipe 1: Green Chile Queso Dip with Sriacha ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/13/2015)... , October 14, 2015 ... The Global Nocturia Clinical Trials Review, H2, ... of worldwide Nocturia scenario, top line data ... as information on companies and institutes involved. ... . --> ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... NEW YORK , Oct. 13, 2015 ... been filed against Amicus Therapeutics, Inc. ("Amicus" or the ... action, filed in United States District Court, District of ... of a class consisting of all persons or entities ... October 1, 2015 inclusive (the "Class Period"). This class action ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... 13, 2015  The Alliance for Safe Biologic ... survey of 401 U.S. pharmacists showing strong support for ... for more transparency in labeling. Michael Reilly ... "This survey reinforces what ASBM has been hearing ... it clear that they prefer distinguishable names and more ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: