Navigation Links
Vulnerable groups are not at higher risk of physician-assisted death

Claims that vulnerable groups, such as the elderly and people with physical or mental disabilities, are at an increased risk of physician assisted death are not supported by evidence, says an expert in this weeks BMJ.

Physician assisted death (both voluntary active euthanasia and physician assisted suicide) has been openly practiced in the Netherlands for more than 25 years and was formally legalised in 2002. Physician assisted suicide was also legalised in Oregon in 1997, writes Professor Timothy Quill of the University of Rochester, USA.

Many concerns still surround the practice, but evidence now exists to answer questions about the risks and benefits of legalisation.

For example, a study published in this weeks Journal of Medical Ethics analysed data from Oregon and the Netherlands and found no increased incidence of physician assisted death in elderly people, women, people with low socioeconomic status, minors, people with physical disabilities or mental illness.

These findings call into question the claim that the risks associated with legalisation will fall most heavily on potentially vulnerable populations, says Quill.

Further evidence dispels the concern that these practices become more common over time. In Oregon, physician assisted death accounts for around one in 1000 deaths each year, with no significant change in frequency over nine years. The Dutch practices of physician assisted death have also remained stable over the duration of four studies, and hospice and palliative care have become more prevalent in recent years.

Evidence from the US also shows higher rates of assisted death in areas where these practices are prohibited than in Oregon after legalisation. Although the data are not directly comparable, none the less, it raises the possibility that legalisation and regulation with safeguards may protect rather than facilitate the practice, says Quill.

The argument that legalisation is a slippery slope is also not supported by the evidence, he adds. A recent study found that four out of six Western European countries where assisted death is illegal had a much higher incidence of unreported cases than is seen in the Netherlands.

Finally, limited data suggests that the practice of terminal sedation, which has been legal in the US since 1997, accounts for up to 44% of deaths, while in the Netherlands, it accounted for 5.6% of deaths in 2001 and 7.1% in 2005.

These days, patients who are dying are faced with a wide array of uncertainties and choices, and the physical and psychological challenges they experience are more complex, says Quill.

Studies help clarify the risks and benefits of controversial practices like physician assisted death or terminal sedation and suggest that outcomes are more favourable when practitioners work together with patients and families in an open and accountable environment.

Patients who are dying and their families need us to be as objective and honest as possible in these deliberations, he concludes.


Contact: Emma Dickinson
BMJ-British Medical Journal

Related medicine news :

1. Obese Adults Undergo Less Medical Tests And More Vulnerable To Diseases
2. Biologically Women Are More Vulnerable To HIV Infection
3. Teenage Boys More Vulnerable And Emotionally Engaged In Romantic Relationships
4. Vulnerable Suffer As NHS Budgets
5. New Asthma Medicine Targeting Vulnerable Inner-City Children Tested
6. Bottleneck in Blood Supply Makes Brain Vulnerable to Strokes
7. ‘Gypsies and Travellers Health Much Worse Than Other Vulnerable Group
8. Black Children More Vulnerable to Tobacco Smoke Effects
9. The Mental Health Bill Will Not Help Vulnerable Patients, Say Doctors
10. Women More Vulnerable to Multiple Sclerosis, Research Shows
11. No link between blood groups and prostate cancer
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... ... The American Institutes for Research ( AIR ) developed a collection of ... experienced sexual assault and other trauma. The toolkit, funded by the U.S. Department of ... Act's 21st anniversary. , AIR developed the Safe Place toolkit ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... , ... Vision Group Holdings, the largest LASIK provider in North America, announced ... LASIK Vision Institute and TLC Laser Eye Centers, Vision Group Holdings has performed more ... , Global Laser Vision will continue to operate in San Diego as it has ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... Sir Grout of Greater ... the local Boston chapter of Ronald McDonald House Charities® (RMHC®). This donation was made ... Sir Grout of Greater Boston since its inception. , “We believe strongly in the ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... CURE Media ... today announced a new partnership with the International Waldenstrom’s Macroglobulinemia Foundation (IWMF) ... non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, their families and physicians. , “Waldenstrom’s Macroglobulinemia is a so-called ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... "My friend's son suffers from ... his infected cheeks," said an inventor from Platteville, Colo. "I came up with this ... He developed the UNTOUCHABLE to prevent a child from rubbing or scratching his or ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/13/2015)... 2015  SRI International has been awarded a ... five years by the National Institute of Allergy ... Institutes of Health, for the development of products ... of radiation exposure. Under this multi-year contract, ... will provide services, facilities, expertise and capabilities to ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... 2015 ) ... & European markets for Meniscal Repair - 16 ... --> ) has announced the addition ... Meniscal Repair - 16 Countries (2010-2021)" report ... Markets ( ) has announced the addition ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... 2015  Graduate students across the country, with ... will soon have the opportunity to learn about ... drug discovery and development process. Eli Lilly and ... 10 leaders from academic institutions to create an ... of Drug Development."  Lilly will formally unveil the ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: