Navigation Links
Used football faceshields are susceptible to breaking on impact
Date:5/23/2011

COLUMBUS, Ohio Game-worn football faceshields are more susceptible to breaking when subjected to high-velocity impact than are new faceshields, according to recent research.

In the study, researchers used an air cannon to hurl baseballs at new and used polycarbonate faceshields. All of the new shields withstood the strongest impact tested, which was designed to match the force of a kick to the face. More than a third of the game-worn faceshields fractured in response to the testing, which included lower forces of impact as well.

In a related survey of college football equipment managers, the researchers found that 98 percent of football programs allow faceshield use, while 18 percent of the players wear a shield. Of the programs that responded, only 21 percent require the use of a faceshield in players with poor vision in one eye. Half of the respondents reported that their school had established a replacement policy for the shields.

The combination of findings led the Ohio State University scientists to recommend that intercollegiate football programs develop a policy for routine inspection and replacement of used faceshields. The researchers also said that coaches or trainers should strongly recommend that football players with poor vision in one eye wear a faceshield during all practices and games.

The most common cause of poor vision in a single eye among children and middle aged adults is a disorder called amblyopia, also known as lazy eye, which affects up to 3 of every 100 children, according to the National Eye Institute. Because the disorder originates in the area of the brain that controls vision, loss of vision in the affected eye can become permanent if it is not treated before about age 8.

"Any football player who has a vision problem should consider wearing a faceshield," said Aaron Zimmerman, assistant professor of optometry at Ohio State and lead author of the study. "Something could happen to their good eye. Why take a chance, especially if there's a way to prevent that?"

The research is published in a recent issue of the journal Optometry.

This study is a follow-up to a previous Ohio State study that determined that the two most popular brands of football helmet faceshields could withstand a hit equivalent to a kick in the face and provide that protection without disrupting players' vision.

In this more recent study, the researchers sought to determine how the faceshields performed after the rigors of standard football action, as well as exposure to sun or freezing temperatures. The group also sent a survey to equipment managers at 117 Division 1 Football Bowl Subdivision programs in the National Collegiate Athletic Association. Fifty-nine managers responded a 50-percent response rate.

In the tests of structural integrity, a baseball was used to mimic the hardness and curvature of the toe end of a cleat or a fist. The scientists tested the two most popular collegiate and professional football helmet faceshields by manufacturers Oakley, based in Foothills Ranch, Calif., and Nike, based in Beaverton, Oregon. The average cost is $45 to $50 per shield.

Using game-worn shields donated by two football programs, the researchers tested their impact resistance at five velocities ranging from almost 150 miles per hour to 116 miles per hour. The highest velocity equated to an impact force of about 2,500 Newtons, or 562 pounds of force comparable to the force generated by an adult soccer player kicking a ball. The lowest velocity equated to an impact force of about 1,933 Newtons, or almost 435 pounds of force.

For this impact study, the scientists randomly assigned groups of the donated used shields to each of the velocity levels. At the highest velocity, 10 faceshields fractured. Three shields broke at the middle-range velocities, and one shield broke at the lowest velocity.

Zimmerman and colleagues also subjected 24 new faceshields to sunlight for an average of 3 hours per day and five days per week for 10 weeks to mimic exposure to ultraviolet radiation during a football season. Previous research has suggested that solar radiation can weaken polycarbonate. None of these shields broke when impact-tested at velocities of 150 miles per hour.

In a small sample of game-worn faceshields exposed to freezing temperatures of 14 degrees Fahrenheit for one hour, four of five used shields broke when tested at velocities of about 130 miles per hour.

Many of the shields that fractured showed the most stress on the sides, where the faceshields attach to the helmet. But a few shattered into multiple pieces that had potential to tear the retina or even penetrate the eye.

"Based on the results, we felt that multiple impacts to shields were probably the likely cause for the lower resistance to impact over time," Zimmerman said. "No matter what the cause is, you do not want to have a protective device fail and potentially cause a more severe injury."

The survey of football equipment managers confirmed for the researchers that no universal guidelines exist for inspecting and replacing faceshields to prevent such equipment failures.

Forty-one percent of the programs had established faceshield-related policies for players with poor vision in one eye: 21 percent required the use of faceshields for those players, and 20 percent recommended faceshields. Fifty percent of the programs had established replacement policies for the faceshields, and a fourth of the programs instructed players to inspect their own shields for signs of damage.

Use of the faceshields in most cases is driven by player choice, according to the survey. Fifty-two percent of programs approve the use of a faceshield if a player asks for one. The rest of the programs require approval from a trainer, coach or team physician.

The main reason players ask for faceshields, according to the survey: About half of the players want to wear them because the shields look good and resemble the equipment worn by professional football players. More than a third use the faceshields for general protection, 11 percent are protecting their eyes from a repeat injury, and 1.5 percent of players have good vision in only one eye.

About 70 percent of programs issue new faceshields at the start of a season. A little over half of the programs replace faceshields that show a small scratch or crack, and about one-third replace faceshields only if the scratch or crack is considered substantial. Ten percent of the programs replace faceshields only when the player's vision is impaired by a damaged shield. One manager reported that players receive a new faceshield for every game.

Faceshields have been recommended for younger football players for more than a decade. The sports safety committees of the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Academy of Ophthalmology issued a report in 1996 recommending that football helmets be equipped with a polycarbonate faceshield for face and eye protection. They were responding to a 1993 report by Prevent Blindness America indicating that football was the fifth-greatest contributor to sports-related eye injuries in patients younger than 25.

"We feel that each institution should have some sort of similar policy," Zimmerman said. "Once a week the shields should be inspected, particularly where they fasten to the helmet. But players should be encouraged to glance a faceshield over before each practice and game. And if there's a deep scratch or crack present, it definitely needs to be replaced."


'/>"/>

Contact: Aaron Zimmerman
azimmerman@optometry.osu.edu
614-247-6188
Ohio State University
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. QuestNet and AFC: Raising the Bar of Asian Football
2. Europes top football venues are not prepared for treating spectators who suffer heart attacks
3. Sharing Miracles Television Program to Feature Legendary College Football Coach Bobby Bowden
4. Football Injuries More Likely on Certain Artificial Turf
5. Getting extra sleep improves the athletic performance of collegiate football players
6. How football playing robots have the future of artificial intelligence at their feet
7. Artificial Turf Helps Football Players With Agility Drills
8. New frozen smoke material: 1 ounce could carpet three football fields
9. New national study finds increase in football-related injuries among youth
10. Experts Call for Twist on Football Helmet Design
11. Youth Football Injuries on the Rise, Study Finds
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:6/23/2017)... ... June 23, 2017 , ... Jusino Insurance ... to communities in the greater Chicago metropolitan area, is embarking on a charity ... youth in Chicago. , Founded in 1897, Hephzibah Children’s Association is one of ...
(Date:6/22/2017)... CA (PRWEB) , ... June 22, 2017 , ... Plastic ... named as a Top Doctor for 2017. Each year, research and information firm, Castle ... First winning the title in 2015, this marks the 3rd time that Dr. ...
(Date:6/22/2017)... ... June 22, 2017 , ... The VA Maryland Health ... Network has awarded the Baltimore VA Medical Center, a division of the VA ... its efforts to promote waste reduction and promote recycling. Also, Practice Greenhealth ...
(Date:6/20/2017)... ... June 20, 2017 , ... Connance, a leading ... will present how predictive analytics drive reimbursement optimization, with a focus on denial ... 25-28. , “The traditional approach to denied and underpaid claims leaves money ...
(Date:6/20/2017)... , ... June 20, 2017 , ... Fresenius Vascular Care, ... minimally invasive techniques to treat and manage a wide range of vascular conditions, has ... initiative. With more than 65 centers represented by more than 40 local brands, a ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:6/11/2017)... 10, 2017  Eli Lilly and Company (NYSE: ... 3 studies of galcanezumab, an investigational treatment for the ... on several key secondary endpoints for galcanezumab compared to ... studies (EVOLVE-1, EVOLVE-2 and REGAIN) will be presented today ... in Boston . ...
(Date:6/8/2017)...   Responding to Heath Ledger,s father,s recent ... singer Chris Cornell in May, the mental health ... free online psychiatric drug side effects search ... psychotropic drug risks. The father of the ... accidental overdose, has called for tighter rules on prescription drugs. ...
(Date:6/5/2017)... 2017 The Cincinnati location ... Inc. (NYSE: DPLO), has been awarded a Top Workplaces ... Results are based on an employee survey administered by ... workplace improvement. The survey measures several aspects of workplace culture, ... ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: