Navigation Links
Unreliable 'outcomes' measures hamper efforts to assure better, safer care
Date:4/7/2011

With a push to make hospitals and doctors more accountable for health care quality, more attention must be paid to the accuracy and reliability of measures used to evaluate caregivers, says a prominent Johns Hopkins patient safety expert.

Writing in the April issue of the journal Health Affairs, Peter J. Pronovost, M.D., Ph.D., a professor of anesthesiology and critical care medicine at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, argues that as the desire to evaluate and improve health care intensifies, there remains little consensus as to which measures are scientifically valid and accurate assessments of quality. This risks misinforming patients who may make decisions based on metrics that poorly reflect the state of health care provided by hospitals and may ultimately lead to a failure to make improvements in hospitals where quality is judged to be better than it is, he says.

"There is bipartisan support behind efforts to start paying for value rather than volume," Pronovost says. "This is great, but we act as if there's a whole library of reliable outcome measures for us to use and the fact is that serious work needs to be done to create them. We can't shrink from doing this science. We need to be guided by it."

Acknowledging that substantial shortcomings in the quality of care persist, causing needless patient harm and increasing health care costs, Pronovost says fixes can't be put in place until rigorous scientific data show exactly where systems are broken and until hard comparative evidence points to what types of repairs work best.

In the absence of such safety and efficacy science, he says, there will remain little consensus among hospitals and physicians about the best methods to judge quality or improvement. For example, he notes that overall hospital death rates are an imperfect reflection of quality of care, but in some cases they are the only measures used.

Pronovost, writing with Richard Lilford, Ph.D., an epidemiologist at University of Birmingham in England, points also to research that compared four different measurement services used to assess the same data from the same hospitals to determine in-hospital mortality. Forty-three percent of hospitals that showed higher-than-expected mortality by one commercially available metric showed lower-than-expected mortality by another.

Pronovost and Lilford call for the creation of an independent agency, the equivalent of a Securities and Exchange Commission for health care, to create rational and standardized outcome measures similar to the accounting rules the SEC creates for businesses. "The goal is to make the process of determining quality standard and transparent, and make data meaningful for consumers and usable by clinicians, ultimately improving patient outcomes," Pronovost says.

Doctors support the use of outcome measures if they are valid and reliable enough to enable conclusions to be drawn about the quality of care, Pronovost says. Too often, he says, they aren't. Hospitals, he notes, once were being fined for hospital bloodstream infections after government regulators screened billing claims for codes signifying infections to calculate infection rates. "That measurement gets it right only one in four times 25 percent of the time," he says. "Clinicians have never used that data because they thought that it was useless, because it was useless."

Now, government regulators make judgments based on Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data, which include lab tests, temperature readings and other signs and symptoms of infection far more accurate measures, he says.

Meanwhile, Pronovost says some states penalize institutions for what they deem are preventable complications contracted by patients during their hospital stays. But, he says, hospitals don't know exactly what they are being judged on because those states use a proprietary algorithm created by a private company to determine which hospitals are "successful" and which ones should be sanctioned. Clinicians and the public neither know how accurate the measures are nor how they were calculated.

"The process should be transparent and reproducible; instead it's a black box," he says. "We don't know if it gets it 5 percent right or 95 percent. We ought to know how imperfect it is."

In a second article also published in Health Affairs, Pronovost, along with Jill A. Marsteller, Ph.D., of the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, and Christine A. Goeschel, Sc.D., R.N., M.P.A., M.P.S., in the Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, present a case study of a success story in measuring outcomes: central line-associated bloodstream infections.

The group outlines the Hopkins-led effort to virtually eliminate bloodstream infections in intensive-care units throughout Michigan, which is now in nearly every state and has reduced the number of deaths. Infection rates have fallen dramatically in ICUs where Pronovost's cockpit-like checklist and culture-of-safety program were implemented. This is one of the few, perhaps only, national success stories documenting measurable improvements in patient outcomes. The Hopkins program is now being implemented across the United States. Data from the first 22 states that have participated in the program for over a year suggests infections have been reduced by approximately 40 percent.

"There are precious few outcome measures deemed valid by clinicians," he says. "This is one of them."


'/>"/>

Contact: Stephanie Desmon
sdesmon1@jhmi.edu
410-955-8665
Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Mortality rates are an unreliable metric for assessing hospital quality, study finds
2. Study shows that modern surgery for scoliosis has good long-term outcomes
3. Updated agenda available for Optimizing PCI Outcomes Symposium
4. Outcomes improved by longer delays between heart attacks and elective surgeries
5. Trauma patients protected from worse outcomes associated with so-called weekend effect
6. Chasing the pot of gold: WSU researchers study gambling subtypes and treatment outcomes
7. Referral to high-volume hospitals for operations fails to improve outcomes statewide
8. Perinatal safety initiative reduces adverse obstetrical outcomes
9. Study in PLoS: Intensive adherence counseling to HIV treatment improves patient outcomes
10. Anti-clotting agent does not improve outcomes of patients with severe pneumonia
11. Healthy lifestyle, positive attitude can help improve patient outcomes
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:12/9/2016)... ... December 09, 2016 , ... MEDI+SIGN®, ... announced today that a new solution for Emergency Departments (ED) has been added ... space in Emergency Department examination rooms, and with a simplified pallet of information ...
(Date:12/8/2016)... ... 08, 2016 , ... After enjoying record-breaking attendance at its ... its 33rd Annual Issues & Research Conference, March 2-3, 2017, at the ... conference is “Persistent Challenges and New Opportunities: Using Research to Accelerate the Dialogue." ...
(Date:12/8/2016)... Plainsboro, NJ (PRWEB) , ... December 08, 2016 , ... ... patients, cancer centers and advocacy groups, has aligned with Upstage Lung Cancer in efforts ... In making the announcement, Michael J. Hennessy, Jr said, “CURE Media Group is honored ...
(Date:12/8/2016)... ... December 08, 2016 , ... Launching of ... Unified Instance Manager architecture, meeting the needs of multichannel growth and doubling ... unattended auto-dialing system without agents, Presence Robodialer, provides greater operational capacity, administrative ...
(Date:12/8/2016)... ... December 08, 2016 , ... Today’s patients are encouraged ... in mind, SIGVARIS has created a new line of anti-embolism stockings to help ... provide the benefits of graduated compression when transitioning from recovery to early rehabilitation. ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:12/9/2016)... Dec 9, 2016 Research and Markets ... 2016-2020" report to their offering. ... The report forecasts the global optical transceiver ... 2016-2020. The report covers the present scenario and ... To calculate the market size, the report considers the revenue generated ...
(Date:12/9/2016)... Dec. 9, 2016  Harmar Mobility, LLC announced today that Steven ... of the Board of Directors. Photo - http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20161209/447552 ... ... Mr. Dawson,s executive career includes ... across a variety of industries. He brings to the company deep ...
(Date:12/9/2016)... Dec. 9, 2016 aTyr Pharma, Inc. (Nasdaq: ... of Physiocrine-based therapeutics to address severe, rare diseases, today announced that ... BMO Prescriptions for Success Healthcare Conference at the InterContinental Barclay Hotel ... 14, 2016, at 4:20 p.m. ET. About aTyr ... aTyr ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: