Navigation Links
Unrealistic optimism appears common in early cancer trials
Date:1/24/2011

(Garrison, NY) Can optimism be ethically problematic? Yes, according to a new study, which found unrealistic optimism prevalent among participants in early-phase cancer trials and suggested that it may compromise informed consent.

Many cancer researchers and ethicists assume that hope and optimism in the research context are "always ethically benign, without considering the possibility that they reflect a bias," write the authors of the study, which appears in IRB: Ethics & Human Research. "Others have claimed that unrealistic expectations for benefit are a result of misunderstanding and that the proper response to them is to provide patient-subjects with more information" But the study cast doubt on both assumptions.

The study included 72 patients with cancer who were enrolled in early-phase oncology trials in the New York metropolitan area between August 2008 and October 2009. Questionnaires assessed signs of unrealistic optimism, as well as participants' understanding of the trials' purpose. Unrealistic optimism, which social psychologists define as being specific to a situation and consider a form of bias, is distinct from "dispositional optimism," which is a general outlook on life and is neither realistic nor unrealistic. Individuals can have one form of optimism without the other.

Study respondents exhibited unrealistic optimism in response to three of five questions about the likelihood of particular events happening to them compared with other trial participants: having their cancer controlled by drugs administered in the trials, experiencing a health benefit from the drugs in the trials, and not experiencing a health problem from the drugs in the trials.

However, a substantial majority of the respondents 72 percent accurately understood that the purpose of the trials was to advance knowledge with the potential to benefit future patients and not necessarily to benefit them. Misunderstanding the purpose was not significantly related to unrealistic optimism, the study found.

The authors said that unrealistic optimism has the potential to compromise informed consent "by interfering with the ability to apply information realistically." They concluded: "Improving the consent process in oncology research will require us to do more than address deficits in understanding. It will require us to pay more attention to how patient-subjects apply information to themselves and to become more aware of the social-psychological factors that might impair decision-making in this context."


'/>"/>

Contact: Michael Turton
turtonm@thehastingscenter.org
845-424-4040 x242
The Hastings Center
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Optimism Could Help Kids Keep Depression at Bay
2. Optimism May Boost Immune System
3. Optimism boosts the immune system
4. Minimally invasive technique appears helpful to reanimate facial paralysis
5. Timely Surgery Appears to Cut Infection Risk, Costs
6. Rare, Severe Form of Morning Sickness Appears to Be Genetic
7. Sleep Appears to Aid Learning
8. Chronic Constipation Appears to Be Increasing Among Kids
9. Home Monitoring of Blood-Thinner Use Appears Effective
10. Treatment of retinal conditions appears to have changed significantly in previous decade
11. IV Aspirin Drip Appears to Be Safe, Effective for Migraine
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:6/25/2017)... ... 2017 , ... With a heatwave currently bearing down on Northern California pushing temperatures to the ... swimsuit ready is easy with laser hair removal. , The process of summer waxing ... routine when all you want to do is get out, dive in and cool off. ...
(Date:6/24/2017)... Tampa, Fla. (PRWEB) , ... June 24, 2017 ... ... Fla., is now offering genetic testing for medications in select Florida and Texas ... of pharmacogenomics. , This new application of genetic testing recognizes the role ...
(Date:6/24/2017)... York (PRWEB) , ... June 24, 2017 , ... ... the Dental365 family. Located at 217 Portion Road in Lake Ronkonkoma, Dental365 offers ... evenings and weekends so that visits to the dentist fit into their patients’ ...
(Date:6/24/2017)... , ... June 24, 2017 , ... Doorknobs are for ... security, such as getting a guard dog or having an alarm system installed. But ... secure against forced entry. Yair Frenkel, owner of TX Premier Locksmith in Killeen, TX ...
(Date:6/23/2017)... , ... June 23, 2017 , ... ... is needed and will ultimately do significant harm to people with all chronic ... , "While it leaves in place the Affordable Care Act (ACA) requirement ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:6/14/2017)... CALABASAS, Calif. , June 14, 2017 ... with the City of Fremont ... chain of the bio-pharma industry in California ... sharing technology, enabling executive networking, and fostering workforce development. ... the development and growth of start-ups, as well as ...
(Date:6/11/2017)... -- Eli Lilly and Company (NYSE: LLY ) announced ... galcanezumab, an investigational treatment for the prevention of episodic ... secondary endpoints for galcanezumab compared to placebo at both ... and REGAIN) will be presented today at the American ... Boston . "The detailed Phase ...
(Date:6/8/2017)... , June 8, 2017  Less than a ... hit more than 200,000 companies, including hospital networks, in ... heralded as one of the largest online extortion attempts ... the healthcare market, it is imperative that providers understand ... their data from this — and many other very ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: