Navigation Links
U-M study challenges notion that umpires call more strikes for pitchers of same race
Date:5/22/2013

ANN ARBORA University of Michigan study challenges previous research that suggests umpire discrimination exists in Major League Baseball.

The study, a collaboration between researchers at U-M and the universities of Illinois and Florida, looks deeper into the controversial argument over whether MLB umpires discriminate by calling more strikes for pitchers of the same race. It found little statistical evidence to support that claim, said Jason Winfree, associate professor of sport management at the U-M School of Kinesiology.

Winfree and co-authors Scott Tainsky of Illinois and Brian Mills of Florida, analyzed millions of pitches between 1997 and 2008 and ran the data through various statistical models. Their results suggest that findings of discrimination were questionable.

A draft of the earlier study that initially found evidence of discrimination was released in 2007 and published by the American Economic Review in 2011. National media reported on both the draft of the study and on its later publication.

In the U-M study, Winfree and his co-authors analyzed both their own data as well as that of the previously published study, but did not get consistent results when using different statistical methods and variables.

"Based on what we found, it's(discrimination) certainly not conclusive, and we could make an argument that there's actually reverse discrimination if you look only at averages," Winfree said. "Our point is (that) with something like this you want to look at the data a lot of different ways and see if you get a consistent result each time with each method. It's a pretty bold claim to say there is racial discrimination."

Winfree and colleagues found that the only specifications that suggested discrimination were when the analysis treated pitchers as completely separate players when pitching in stadiums where umpires were monitored. This seemed to drive much of the findings in the earlier study, they said.

The U-M study and others that look at discrimination in sports are significant not only for sports fans and franchises, but because it's very difficult to test for discrimination in most other occupations, Winfree said. However, because professional sports keep such detailed statistics, discrimination or lack of it is more quantifiable.

"This is a place where it's easy to test for discrimination, and if you find it here, it might be present in other work scenarios where you can't really test it," Winfree said.

The issue of discrimination among referees and umpires has raised debate in other sports as well. For instance, in 2010 the Quarterly Journal of Economics published a study that suggested racial bias among referees in the NBA.

The U-M study, "Further examination of potential discrimination among MLB umpires," appears online in the Journal of Sports Economics.


'/>"/>

Contact: Laura Bailey
baileylm@umich.edu
734-647-1848
University of Michigan
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. More Kids Getting Donor Organs, But Gaps Persist, Study Finds
2. Underactive Thyroid and Heart Failure a Bad Combination: Study
3. Study shows that insomnia may cause dysfunction in emotional brain circuitry
4. Abused Children at Risk for Obesity as Adults: Study
5. A pan-European study: Signs of motor disorders can appear years before disease manifestation
6. Study details genes that control whether tumors adapt or die when faced with p53 activating drugs
7. Overeating learned in infancy, study suggests
8. Study finds new pneumococcal vaccine appears to be as safe as previously used vaccine
9. Antidepressants May Be Helpful for Some Heart Patients: Study
10. Study finds COPD is over-diagnosed among uninsured patients
11. Parker Waichman LLP Comments on New Study Showing that MRI is Useful for Predicting Failure of Metal-on-Metal Hip Implants
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/21/2017)... ... ... Chris Cornell, 52, was found dead on the night of Wednesday, May 17, 2017. It ... in the rock industry would take his own life, but the extremely talented and ... played a role in the death of Chris Cornell . , Depression and Drug ...
(Date:5/21/2017)... ... May 20, 2017 , ... Pot. Reefer. Grass. Mary Jane. No matter ... share its attributes like never before. More than a map, new social marketplace ... stores, strains, products – and for the first time – each other. A social ...
(Date:5/21/2017)... , ... May 21, 2017 , ... Following the tragic ... York became the first state to require that hospitals follow a protocol to quickly ... the medical community as to whether such steps would have saved Rory or anyone ...
(Date:5/19/2017)... ... May 19, 2017 , ... DMG Productions is proud to ... with Ed Begley, Jr., airing fourth quarter 2017 on FOX Business. , Based ... dietary supplement made from naturally occurring ingredients. Innovations will enlighten viewers on RawTrition’s ...
(Date:5/19/2017)... FL (PRWEB) , ... May 19, 2017 , ... ... asset protection services and retirement planning assistance to families and business owners in ... Sclerosis Society to advocate for MS sufferers and their families. , Multiple sclerosis ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/10/2017)... 2017 Hologic, Inc. (Nasdaq: HOLX ... fiscal second quarter ended April 1, 2017 .   ... 666.7% compared to the prior year period as the ... significant gain, while non-GAAP diluted EPS of $0.50 increased ... in constant currency terms.  Excluding the effects of blood ...
(Date:5/10/2017)... -- Radiology has become the number one diagnostic tool ... to the number one ranking as a result.  More ... as the most complete and reliable method for clinical ... pain an MRI may confirm a suspected herniated disc ... entirely different treatment protocols.  In these circumstances, patients need ...
(Date:5/9/2017)... May 9, 2017  Demonstrating its commitment to ... directors for the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of ... Biopharmaceutical companies will now have to meet new ... be eligible to join PhRMA. "By ... is sending a clear message that being a ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: