Navigation Links
Trying to Decide? Forget the Facts and Phone a Friend

Others' opinions prove better in predicting satisfaction with a choice, study finds

THURSDAY, March 19 (HealthDay News) -- Imagine you're going to a movie. What would better predict whether you'll like the film: the opinion of a friend who's seen it or the details you know about the cast and plot?

Researchers say you'd be best to rely on your pal.

"If you are trying to figure out whether to become a lawyer or vacation in Bermuda, our research suggests you would do much better to ask people who are lawyers or have been to Bermuda about their experience than to gather factual information about each of these decisions," said Matthew Killingsworth, a Harvard graduate student and an author of the research, published in the March 20 issue of Science.

In essence, "if you want to know how happy something will make you, ask someone who's been there or done that," he said.

What does it matter? The study suggests that people are prone to make poor predictions when relying on what they know about something instead of on the opinions of others. Making matters more complicated, "people do not believe this," the study authors wrote.

In the study, researchers set up "speed dates" between heterosexual female and male undergraduates. The women met men for five minutes and then told researchers what they thought of them. The experiment involved 33 women and eight men.

Women did a better job of predicting whether they'd enjoy a date with a man if they'd previously read another woman's opinion about him based on a speed date. They did worse at predicting whether they'd like a man if they simply had a photo and basic information about him before the date.

In fact, the women were 50 percent less likely to wrongly predict whether they would enjoy the date if they had heard about the man from another woman, Killingsworth said.

Still, he said, "women think they will make better predictions based on the guy's profile."

Killingsworth said people simply overvalue the worth of "factual information."

For instance, someone thinking about becoming a lawyer or traveling to Bermuda "might become overly focused on the lawyer's salary or the crime level in Bermuda and run the risk of vastly undervaluing the information provided by people who've actually had the experience you're contemplating," he said.

Dr. Peter A. Ubel, professor of medicine and psychology at the University of Michigan, said the study is well done but would be of limited use in the everyday world. "I'd like to see [similar research] in more realistic domains of life," he said.

Still, Ubel said, the findings suggest that "the things we think should influence our decisions -- like, 'Tell me more about the situation' -- don't always help us."

And in general, he said, "we often do a rotten job of making predictions."

More information

The University of Waterloo, in Ontario, Canada, has more on making decisions.

SOURCES: Matt Killingsworth, graduate student, Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass.; Peter A. Ubel, M.D., professor, medicine and psychology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Mich.; March 20, 2009, Science

Copyright©2009 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Autism Speaks Applauds Supreme Court Decision Upholding Families Right to Challenge IEPs Without First Trying Out School District Proposed Placement
2. Is fear of gaining weight keeping many women from trying to quit smoking?
3. Fear is stronger than hope for worriers trying to get fit, says research
4. Trying to stay on a strict diet? Focus on the details
5. Fertility Experts: Winter Waistlines a Swelling Problem for Indianians Trying to Get Pregnant
6. Are You Trying to Clean Your Home ... or Kill It?
7. Carlyle-ManorCare Facing New Federal Charges for Breaking the Law: Interrogating, Threatening, Retaliating Against Nursing Home Workers for Trying to Form a Union
8. The SCOOTER Store Gives Power Wheelchair to Good Samaritan Critically Injured Trying to Save Others
9. The memories you want to forget are the hardest ones to lose
10. Parents Shouldnt Forget Scoliosis Checks as School Starts
11. FORGET THE JONESES, This is All About Keeping up With the Walkers as the Los Angeles Jewish Home Sends Out an Invite to Everyone Named Walker in the United States
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Trying to Decide? Forget the Facts and Phone a Friend
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... 2015 , ... Third Molar SEO , one of ... launched a sleek, mobile-ready and user-centric redesigned website. , Vivek Srivastava, founder and ... the benefits that its SEO services provide to dentists and why Third Molar ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... 01, 2015 , ... The National Association of Professional Women (NAPW) ... the Year Circle. She is recognized with this prestigious distinction for leadership in estate ... boasting more than 850,000 members and over 200 operating Local Chapters. , “I’m pleased ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... Until now, the St. Louis Fetal ... MOMS (Management of Myelomeningocele Study) trial. One of these exclusion criteria was a BMI ... of 18.5 to 24.9 is considered normal, 25 - 29.9 is overweight and above ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... An extensive ... is specialized and only includes chiropractic clinics in the US. , The team ... alternative health practitioner when back pain sets in. When people are experiencing back ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... On Saturday, October 24th, 2015, at the ... annual fundraising event, a 5K walk known as “Making Strides Against Breast Cancer”. Patients ... which is also located in Battle Creek, joined in for this campaign that sought ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... 30, 2015  QT Vascular Ltd., together with its ... its subsidiaries, TriReme Medical LLC and Quattro Vascular Pte. ... the design, assembly and distribution of advanced therapeutic solutions ... pleased to announce that a three-judge panel of ... for the Federal Circuit ("Federal Circuit") has unanimously granted ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... 30, 2015   Royal Philips  (NYSE: ... of Radiology Solutions, a fully integrated, consultative approach ... customized, data-driven practice management approaches that combine imaging ... practices improve care delivery and reduce costs. Making ... of North America Annual Meeting (RSNA) in ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... Nautilus Medical Inc. today announced worldwide availability of MatrixRay, ... The release of MatrixRay to the entire medical healthcare ... America) in Chicago - the ... --> --> MatrixRay is the first ... worldwide via a peer-to-peer exchange network of physicians and ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: