Navigation Links
Trial Data on Anti-Seizure Drug Might Have Been Manipulated: Report
Date:11/11/2009

Study found outcome measures differed between company documents, published reports

WEDNESDAY, Nov. 11 (HealthDay News) -- An unusual look at internal documents from a pharmaceutical company suggests that clinical data was manipulated to make a popular anti-seizure drug, gabapentin (Neurontin), look more effective than it actually was, thereby increasing possibilities for its off-label usage, according to a new report.

"This means we're not seeing the full picture, and the picture we are seeing is suspect because perhaps there was selective reporting of outcomes so that only the positive outcomes were reported," said Kay Dickersin, senior author of a paper reporting the alleged deception in the Nov. 12 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.

But this revelation may just be the tip of the iceberg, especially given that internal company research protocols are rarely available to outsiders, stated another expert.

"The reality is that a deliberate fraud is extremely difficult to unearth. If scientists and companies agree to report results in a way that wasn't initially intended, unless you have access to original documents, it is extremely difficult to actually figure out what happened and how it happened," said Dr. Steven Nissen, chairman of cardiovascular medicine at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation in Ohio. "How many other examples like this are there out there that we simply don't know about? That's what's frightening."

Dickersin, a professor of epidemiology at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health in Baltimore, gained access to internal company documents when she was asked to testify for the plaintiff in a lawsuit alleging that Pfizer and Parke-Davis (now a division of Pfizer as a result of its Warner-Lambert acquisition) illegally tried to market the drug for off-label uses.

Neurontin is approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to treat seizures and shingles, but is also widely used off-label to fight migraines, bipolar disorder and pain.

Dickersin compared internal company documents to 20 trials funded by Pfizer and Parke-Davis, 12 of which were published.

Typically, clinical trials are set up to track both primary and secondary outcomes. These initial decisions then dictate other aspects of the trial, such as how many participants will be included. And that feeds back into how valid the final results are for that specific trial design and that specific primary outcome.

But here, Dickersin and her colleagues discovered that the primary outcomes specified in the early company protocols were not always the same as those appearing in later reports.

"What appears to be happening is that outcomes are changing between what was planned and what was published," Dickersin said.

Sometimes researchers changed what the primary outcome was (if a different outcome cast the drug in a more positive light), neglected to report the primary outcome at all, turned a secondary outcome into the primary outcome or simply added new outcomes, the report said.

"This distorts the scientific evidence that's available on the benefits and risks of therapies," Nissen said.

On Tuesday, Pfizer issued a statement in response to the study, part of which read: "The suggestion that Pfizer attempted to mislead the medical community about the effectiveness of gabapentin [Neurontin] for certain off-label conditions is untrue. The review recently published in the New England Journal of Medicine, regarding the reporting of industry-sponsored trials for gabapentin for off-label use, was derived from a report created for litigation and coauthored by plaintiffs' expert witness, who was hired to produce opinions to support plaintiffs' arguments. We believe the review suffers from significant bias, insufficient data, poor methodology, and cannot pass the threshold of credible scientific research."

"The safety and efficacy of gabapentin has been widely published, both by Warner-Lambert/Pfizer as well as independent researchers, and Pfizer has supported the dissemination of the results of these studies, regardless of outcome. At Pfizer, science and medical integrity come first and foremost," the statement concluded.

Although regulations require that all clinical trials be registered at some point, the study authors feel that's not enough.

"We need to actually have the protocol itself available for people to look at so there aren't opportunities for people to fiddle around with what they submit," Dickersin said.

One possibility would be to register the protocol itself. "This doesn't necessarily fix it, but it does mean that it's transparent, that the public has access to what people say they're going to do before they do it," she added.

"The peer-reviewed scientific literature is how we write our guidelines and how we make decisions about what therapies to give patients," Nissen said. "If the material available to us is severely distorted by commercial influences, then the evidence we use to take care of patients is flawed. That is too high a price to pay."

More information

The U.S. National Institutes of Health has a registry of current clinical trials.



SOURCES; Kay Dickersin, Ph.D., professor, epidemiology, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, director, Center for Clinical Trials, Johns Hopkins; Steven E. Nissen, chairman, department of cardiovascular medicine, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Ohio; Nov. 10, 2009, statement, Pfizer Inc.; Nov. 12, 2009, New England Journal of Medicine


'/>"/>
Copyright©2009 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. St. Jude and UF Proton Therapy Institute to begin proton therapy clinical trial
2. St. Jude Childrens Research Hospital and UF Proton Therapy Institute to Begin Proton Therapy Clinical Trial
3. Tyco International to Present at the Citi Industrial Manufacturing & Transportation Conference
4. Robbins & Myers to Present at Bairds 2009 Industrial Conference November 11, 2009
5. Cardiome And Astellas Announce Initiation Of Patient Enrolment In ACT 5 Trial
6. Winner Medicals Subsidiary Won Contribution in Chinese Nonwovens and Industrial Textiles Industry Award
7. Positive Data from Arena Pharmaceuticals Pivotal BLOOM Trial Demonstrate that Lorcaserin Significantly Improved Markers of Cardiovascular Risk and Glycemic Parameters and was not Associated with Depression or Suicidal Ideation
8. Full Results of AIDS Vaccine Trial Confirm Modest Benefit
9. Detailed Results from RV 144 HIV Vaccine Trial Published Today in The New England Journal of Medicine and Presented at the AIDS Vaccine 2009 Conference Provide Insight for Future Research
10. Teen smoking-cessation trial first to achieve significant quit rates
11. Industrial and Laboratory Equipment Distributor Tovatech LLC Launches Redesigned Interactive Website
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/17/2017)... ... February 17, 2017 , ... For ... assistance management solution to the exhibit floor for the 2017 HIMSS Conference ... , From Feb. 19–23, 2017, more than 40,000 healthcare industry professionals are expected ...
(Date:2/17/2017)... Seattle, WA (PRWEB) , ... February 17, 2017 ... ... health management organizations, has been named a finalist in the 8th Annual DecisionHealth ... impacting America's healthcare delivery system. Qualis Health’s work is recognized across multiple award ...
(Date:2/17/2017)... ... 2017 , ... Pharmica Consulting attended CHI's 8th Annual SCOPE ... trial planning and management. Pharmica discussed the importance of effective project management, data ... by Pharmica’s booth were able to demo its cloud-based Resource Management Tool, ...
(Date:2/17/2017)... ... February 17, 2017 , ... Top neuroendocrine cancer doctors, nurses and specialists from ... February 21 - 23 in Beaver Creek, CO. It was announced today by Cindy ... year in Beaver Creek, hosting over 60 faculty members and addressing unmet needs of ...
(Date:2/16/2017)... ... 17, 2017 , ... For some cancer survivors, the memories ... Physician researchers at The Marcus Institute of Integrative Health at Thomas Jefferson ... reducing symptoms of traumatic stress in cancer patients and published their results ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/17/2017)... 17, 2017  Noble Capital Markets announced today that ... (Nasdaq: EPIX ). The report was issued ... , PhD. ESSA Pharmaceuticals is a clinical ... cancer (CRPC). Its lead compound EPI-506, is a small ... of the androgen receptor, thereby has potential to overcome ...
(Date:2/16/2017)... Quest Diagnostics (NYSE: DGX ), ... announced that it has been named one of the ... The annual survey designated Quest Diagnostics as ... Pharmacy and Other Services" industry to attain Most Admired ... attain the designation. This is the second consecutive year ...
(Date:2/16/2017)... Feb. 16, 2017  Aralez Pharmaceuticals Inc. (NASDAQ: ... company, today announced that executive management will participate in ... held February 22-23, 2017. Adrian Adams , Chief ... at 1:35 p.m. local time on Wednesday, February 22, ... for the event may be accessed from the Investors ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: