Navigation Links
Treating drug-addicted doctors is good medicine
Date:2/24/2009

GAINESVILLE, Fla. --- Doctors who become addicted to alcohol and other drugs can be treated successfully and returned to medical practice with the help of special programs that couple referral to treatment and monitoring with rapid responses to noncompliance, University of Florida researchers report.

The study is the first national-level analysis of such Physician Health Programs, and confirms they are effective alternatives to simply punishing drug-addicted doctors. The findings are published in the March issue of the Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment.

More than three-quarters of doctors enrolled in state programs stayed drug-free over a five-year monitoring period. The results were the same regardless of whether the doctor's drug of choice was alcohol, crack cocaine, prescription drugs or other substances.

"Treatment works," said Dr. Mark Gold, psychiatry chairman at the UF College of Medicine and the McKnight Brain Institute. "It has been shown now to be safe and effective and cost-effective."

But it's not just for doctors, said Gold, who with UF colleagues pioneered evaluation and treatment for drug-addicted doctors. "It should be a model for treatment of anyone with these diagnoses."

In general, rates of illicit drug use are lower among physicians than the general public, but rates of prescription misuse are five times higher among physicians, according to a 2008 review Gold co-authored in the Harvard Review of Psychiatry.

Gold and others conclude that drug problems in doctors are related to medical specialties that put them in regular contact with drugs of addiction, ease of access to drugs, stress and lack of early detection. Addiction also appears linked to physician-suicide.

Physician Health Programs are not addiction treatment programs, however. Instead, they provide intensive, long-term case management and monitoring. Fifty-five percent of doctors enrolled are mandated formally by a licensing board, hospital, malpractice insurance or other agency. The rest are informally "mandated" by others such as employers, families and colleagues. Doctors sign contracts agreeing to abstain from drugs or face intensified treatment, being reported to their medical licensing boards or losing their license.

The programs aim to save the lives and careers of addicted physicians, and to protect the public by addressing substance use among doctors. They are also are an effective way to remove noncompliant doctors from the practice of medicine.

"This isn't to cover it up, it's quite the opposite," said Temple University psychiatry chairman Dr. David Baron, who oversees Pennsylvania's program. "It allows for quality treatment and to make sure that we're still ensuring the safety of the public." Baron was not involved in the current study.

Program measures include group and individual therapy, residential and outpatient programs, surprise workplace visits from monitors, and links to 12-step programs of Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous. Doctor-patients get care not just for drug problems, but also for accompanying medical or psychiatric disorders. They pay for their treatment, drug tests and follow-up care.

The research, funded by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, evaluated 904 physicians admitted to 16 state-run Physician Health Programs from 1995 to 2001. Collaborators included founding National Institute of Drug Abuse Director and former drug czar Dr. Robert Dupont, A. Thomas McLellan, of the University of Pennsylvania, and Lisa Merlo, of UF.

Previous studies have shown that in individual states, and on a small scale, the programs are effective. The current study, first reported at the Betty Ford Institute, has the largest sample of physicians ever followed, and over the longest period.

Doctors in the programs had to abstain from alcohol or other drugs, and were tested frequently at random for five or more years. If tests revealed they had returned to substance abuse, swift action was taken -- doctors were reported to the medical board, which could lead to loss of their licenses.

"It's the idea of a carrot and a stick," said Dr. Scott Teitelbaum, director of the UF-run Florida Recovery Center, which treats addicted physicians referred from around the country. "There's always a level of resistance -- people never feel they need the level of care that's recommended. Someone might not agree with you, but if they want to practice medicine they have to comply."

Often, with the support of peers and growing realization that treatment is working, physician-patients' motivations change from simply wanting to obey the rules to wanting to change their lives, Teitelbaum said.

One-fifth of doctors were reported to their board during treatment and monitoring -- some more than once with multiple disciplinary actions taken.

But 78 percent of doctors in the programs had no positive drug tests during five years of intensive monitoring. And five to seven years after starting treatment, 72 percent were actively practicing medicine, without drug abuse or malpractice.

Eighteen percent left medical practice, while others relapsed into drug use. Three percent of those who didn't complete their programs had substance-related deaths or committed suicide.

Although the programs employed a variety of approaches, the researchers found that success was not related to specific therapists or modes of therapy, but rather to the long-term nature of the treatment.

Still, there are some "essential ingredients" that successful programs have in common, Gold said. Those include treatment extended over years -- not weeks or months -- and unambiguous success markers such as urine testing and return to work and normal family activities.


'/>"/>

Contact: Czerne M. Reid
czerne@ufl.edu
352-273-5814
University of Florida
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. HPV vaccine does not appear to be effective for treating pre-existing HPV infection
2. Is 4 agents decoction (Si Wu Tang) efficacious in treating primary dysmenorrhea?
3. Treating diabetes during pregnancy can break link to childhood obesity
4. Jefferson specialists studying innovative surgery for effectively treating sleep apnea
5. Treating Diabetes During Pregnancy Could Lead to Thinner Kids
6. Family-based treatment more effective than supportive psychotherapy in treating bulimia
7. Treating depression may improve recovery of heart rate variability following coronary syndromes
8. Antidepressant shows early promise in treating agitation and psychotic symptoms of dementia
9. Hospitals Improve Survival Rates While Treating Sicker Patients Thomson Healthcare Study Shows
10. Stem cells show promise for treating Huntingtons disease
11. Treating obstructive sleep apnea, preventing heart attacks and strokes
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:1/24/2017)... ... January 24, 2017 , ... ... of a new report from the Frank Hawkins Kenan Institute of Private ... business leaders, academics and policy makers identified concrete solutions at the “What’s Next, ...
(Date:1/24/2017)... ... January 24, 2017 , ... The results from the ... and particularly good news for prostate cancer patients: incidents of cancer is down as ... the report the cancer death rate has dropped from its peak of 215.1 in ...
(Date:1/24/2017)... ... January 24, 2017 , ... American Family Care (AFC) has opened a new ... care for residents in the area. The Bedford clinic will be the nineteenth location ... years by Dave Adams and Dr. Kristina Orio. Adams and Orio also independently own ...
(Date:1/24/2017)... Overland Park, KS (PRWEB) , ... January 24, ... ... rating to Premensa, a leading natural supplement for relieving premenstrual syndrome, or ... premenstrual syndrome at some point. These symptoms can include cramps, constipation, irritability, headaches, ...
(Date:1/24/2017)... ... 2017 , ... “Who Would Have Dreamed: A Novel of Miracles”: a beautiful and poignant ... understand its purpose in her life. “Who Would Have Dreamed: A Novel of Miracles” is ... love of writing. , Sharon shares that she started her spiritual journey later ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/24/2017)... Market Research Future has a half cooked research report on Global Wound ... and expected to continue its growth by the end of 2022. ... Wound Closure ... 2019 and reaching a value of 13 billion by 2019 and 21 ... Wound Closure Device Market has been growing rapidly and is expected to ...
(Date:1/24/2017)... , Jan. 24, 2017 Market Research Future has a ... Market. The global market for Plastic Surgery & Integumentary System is ... end of the forecasted period. Market Highlights ... Global Plastic Surgery & Integumentary ... predicted that the market will reach high growth figures and thriving ...
(Date:1/24/2017)... 2017 Research and Markets has announced the ... - Product, Material - Forecast to 2025" report to their ... The ... CAGR of around 5.4% over the next decade to reach approximately ... that the market is witnessing include 3D medical printing is expected ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: