Navigation Links
Tragic choices: Is it better for doctors or patient families to decide?
Date:4/20/2009

In the medical realm, people sometimes need to make very difficult choices, such as deciding to end life-support for a terminally ill patient. A new study in the Journal of Consumer Research delves into the question of whether it is preferable for patients' families or doctors to make those "tragic choices."

Authors Simona Botti (London Business School), Kristina Orfali, and Sheena S. Iyengar (both Columbia University) say that from the time of Hippocrates until the 1980s the "paternalistic model" dominated the field of bioethics. According to this model, doctors made decisions in their patients' best interest. A newer "autonomous model" assumes that patients should be informed of the pros and cons of various medical treatments and make decisions for themselves or family members. When it comes to tragic choices, how do these two models play out?

The researchers conducted in-depth analysis of nineteen interviews with American and French parents who had infants in Neonatal Intensive Care Units. "The experiences of these parents were similar because they were all confronted by the choice of whether to continue or interrupt their babies' life-support therapy, the decision to interrupt the treatment was made, and the baby died. Crucially, however, the decision model in neonatology varies across the two countries: In the U.S., the autonomous model is used, so the decision to interrupt life-support therapy was made by the parents themselves; on the contrary, in France, the paternalistic model still dominates, so the same decision was made by the physicians on behalf of the parents."

In that study and subsequent laboratory experiments, the researchers found that people who made the choices were more confident that the best decisions were made. But in spite of this higher confidence, they expressed more negative emotion that those who did not choose. "In addition, both choosers and non-choosers were ambivalent towards decision autonomy," the authors write. "On the one hand, they did not like deciding by themselves, but on the other they also did not like having the physicians choose for them."

The authors did find, in a final study, that when physicians framed the withdrawal decision as "the only thing to do," people making tragic choices were able to distance themselves from the choice and experience improved emotions.


'/>"/>

Contact: Mary-Ann Twist
JCR@bus.wisc.edu
608-255-5582
University of Chicago Press Journals
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. WuXi PharmaTech (NYSE: WX) Mourns the Tragic Loss of Its Independent Director Shawn Wang
2. Putting the Medical Profession on Notice!: Widow Tells Tragic Story of How Her Husband Died Due to Misdiagnosis and Mistreatment
3. November: National Epilepsy Awareness Month Actress Hunter Tylo Turns Tragic Loss Into Hope
4. Dr. Payman Simoni Comments on the Alleged Tragic Complications Stemming From Ushers Wifes Plastic Surgery
5. Conventional prognostic factors fail to explain better prostate cancer survival in most Asian men
6. Waist-to-hip ratio may better predict cardiovascular risk than body mass index
7. Informational handout key to giving parents a better understanding of CT radiation risks
8. Children of depressed moms do better when dad is involved, SLU researcher finds
9. Struggling male readers respond better to female teachers
10. Physician Skin Care Specialist Says Proposed New Rules for Sunscreen Products Will Better Protect the Public
11. Mothers Know Best: NFL Moms Team With Eddie George to Showcase a Better Way to a Healthier Lifestyle
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/27/2017)... ... May 26, 2017 , ... A May 8 article ... for colds or respiratory issues that are not responsive to antibiotics nevertheless obtain prescriptions ... may be largely responsible for the problem both in Canada and the United States. ...
(Date:5/26/2017)... ... May 26, 2017 , ... Mediaplanet is proud to ... campaign in USA Today, which will educate readers on how to take care of ... a large focus is placed on melanoma. Dancing with the Stars professional, Witney Carson, ...
(Date:5/26/2017)... ... May 26, 2017 , ... ... the CareFusion NOX-T3 portable sleep monitor with its Somnoware Sleep Device Interface (SDI). ... interface for diagnostic device operations. With this platform, initializing devices and importing studies ...
(Date:5/26/2017)... ... May 26, 2017 , ... After raising nearly $30,000 on ... will continue to be available at a discounted crowdfunding price on Indiegogo . ... they are, I also wanted to bring a fidget toy to the market that ...
(Date:5/26/2017)... ... May 26, 2017 , ... “When the Stars Lead Home”: a ... creation of published author Laura Weigel Douglas, an avid reader who lives in the ... that sometimes feels like Green Hills Adventure Camp. She couldn’t be more grateful. , ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/26/2017)... , May 25, 2017  In response to ... , Direct Relief is working with Pfizer to ... available at no cost to community health centers, free ... providers nationwide. "Pfizer has a long-standing ... medicines and ensuring patient safety through educational activities," said ...
(Date:5/18/2017)... 2017  Two Bayer U.S. Pharmaceutical leaders received top ... recent 28 th Woman of the Year ... HBA,s longstanding mission of furthering the advancement and impact ... Cindy Powell-Steffen , senior director of brand activation ... Libby Howe , a regional business manager for ...
(Date:5/11/2017)... May 11, 2017  Thornhill Research Inc. ( ... awarded an $8,049,024 USD five-year, firm-fixed-priced, indefinite-quantity/indefinite-delivery contract ... Canadian Commercial Corporation (CCC) ( Ottawa, Ontario, ... to administer general anesthesia to patients requiring emergency ... "The US Marine Corps have been a longtime ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: