Navigation Links
Tracing the Paralympic movement's 'freak show' roots
Date:8/29/2012

(Edmonton) Danielle Peers has lived the thrill and pressure, revelled in competition and brought home hardware from the Paralympic Games. But beneath the cheers, the University of Alberta researcher questions whether the Paralympic movement is as empowering as its benevolent image.

The former Paralympian bronze medallist and women's wheelchair basketball world champion says the history of the Paralympic movement dates to the freak shows of the 19th centuryand even today's modern games are a spectacle of curiosity that reinforces disability.

"The Paralympics is one of those very few times where we actually have disabilities visible in our culture, where people take notice, but we're not taking full advantage of the opportunity," said Peers, a PhD candidate and Trudeau Scholar in the Faculty of Physical Education and Recreation.

Peers comes to the issue with experience playing stand-up and wheelchair basketball at high levels. She played wheelchair basketball for four years before being diagnosed with muscular dystrophy, which allowed her to play in the 2004 Athens Paralympic Games.

"The ways in which we often talk about and show the Paralympics reproduces this idea that disability is a tragic problem in people's bodies, not a structural problem in our communities. My life and the lives of others I know with disabilities are full of structural difficultiesyou can't find housing, it's hard to find a jobbut our lives are also full of pleasure and joy."

Peers' historical analysis of the power relationship between disability sport organizers and athletes, Patients, Athletes, Freaks: Paralympism and the Reproduction of Disability, was published in the August issue of Journal of Sport & Social Issues in the lead-up to the 2012 London Paralympics.

Peers contends the movement avoids criticism and celebrates its able-bodied leaders in the most favourable light, often erasing contributions from athletes.

British neurosurgeon Sir Ludwig Guttmann is often hailed as the "father of the Paralympic movement" for his work at the end of the Second World War, in which he used sport as therapy for veterans with spinal injuries. In fact, his therapies were compulsory, regimented and institutionalized to "rescue these men, women and children from the scrapheap," as Guttmann put it, and return them to "a life worth living."

Freak show

Early competitions were spectacles, with athletes showcased alongside other marvels of science in the tradition of 19th-century freak shows. Later, as competition was co-ordinated by formalized organizing bodies, athletes were differentiated and sorted into classes such as blind or paraplegic under the guise of fairness, which Peers notes further objectified disabilities and impairments and led to a rise in disability sport expertsfurthering paternalistic relationships with athletes.

"If you look at books about the Paralympics, they have all these pictures of athletes and don't name any of them," Peers said, noting the information is all about organizers. "You can't imagine that existing in the Olympic context, but in the context of the histories they tell about the Paralympics, it's irrelevant who athletes are."

In the 1980s, disability sports such as wheelchair racing were incorporated into the Olympic Games as demonstration sports, but more for curiosity value. Peers pointed to Atlanta in 1996 as evidence of the stark differences in the treatment of athletes.

"After the Olympics closed, the media left, they took down all the signs, the cafeteria did not have enough food, there was no toilet paper for the athletes to usethey just gutted the space and left the Paralympic athletes to fend for themselves."

When Paralympians threatened to boycott the closing ceremonies, athlete leaders were removed to quell trouble.

"There was a real paternalism and real quashing of any kind of revolt or resistance that the athletes have done to try and improve the games for themselvesthe games that they love."

As the games have grown in size and scope, athletes are not treated as second-class citizens to the same extent as before, said Peers. But in terms of silencing dissent and involving athletes in the direction of their sports, "it's stayed the same or got worse."

"It's only through writing and thinking critically that we have a hope of making changes for the better."


'/>"/>
Contact: Bryan Alary
bryan.alary@ualberta.ca
780-492-0436
University of Alberta
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Canadian researcher is on a mission to create an equal playing field at the Paralympic Games
2. Molecule movements that make us think
3. NIHs PEERx for teens to be showcased at Rx Drug Abuse Summit
4. Wellesley study shows income inequality a key factor in high US teen births
5. Invasive heart test being dramatically overused, Stanford study shows
6. Novel compound demonstrates anti-leukemic effect in zebrafish, shows promise for human treatment
7. Lung Cancer Screening Might Pay Off, Analysis Shows
8. Nonsurgical Method to Measure Brain Pressure Shows Promise
9. BMC study shows diverting passengers to elevators could help reduce falls at Logan Airport
10. Study Shows New Option for Kids With Tough-to-Treat Leukemia
11. Politics May Get in the Way of Empathy, Research Shows
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/31/2016)... ... May 31, 2016 , ... When MetLoop ... knew it was something that contractors should have at their disposal on a ... says Butch, CertainTeed’s Director of Contractor Programs. , As a result, Metloop ...
(Date:5/31/2016)... ... May 31, 2016 , ... The successful implementation of “lean manufacturing” in ... well. However, laboratories have different challenges compared to manufacturing environments. , In order ... lab, METTLER TOLEDO has developed the Lean Lab Checklist . This checklist will ...
(Date:5/31/2016)... , ... May 31, 2016 , ... Spectrum Aquatics has ... new lift has been designed and built with the user in mind. , “Over ... consultants have informed us that an ADA 400 lbs lift is a necessary requirement ...
(Date:5/31/2016)... ... ... a recent interview on The Greenburgh Report radio show hosted by Greenburgh, NY Town ... leading medical insurance advocate Adria Goldman Gross discussed several eye-opening issues that have combined ... the interview with Mr. Feiner that aired on May 7, 2016, Ms. Gross, the ...
(Date:5/31/2016)... ... May 31, 2016 , ... ... on patients with cancer, has added Cancer and Careers to its ... more timely content on continuing successful careers while fighting cancer. , As partners, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/27/2016)... Kitov Pharmaceuticals ... late-stage drug development, today announced the completion of ... batches required for registration of KIT-302 with the ... Kitov,s announcement in December 2015, that ... primary efficacy endpoint. "We are fortunate ...
(Date:5/26/2016)... India , May 26, 2016 ... drugs market growth is the emergence of new treatments. ... astaxanthin therapies for osteoarthritis treatment. The therapy is expected ... Moreover, Arthritis Research UK is conducting studies to develop ... arcOGEN study, where the genes involved in osteoarthritis are ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... May 25,2016 FDA 510(k) ... Cellvizio platform for urological and surgical applications ... inventor of Cellvizio®, the multidisciplinary confocal laser endomicroscopy ... in the US with the 12 th ... Administration (FDA). This new FDA clearance covers Confocal ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: