Navigation Links
The NHS and the cost-benefit dilemma
Date:1/25/2010

New research by health economists at the University of York has raised concerns over any move to broaden the range of costs and economic benefits considered in the analysis of new NHS treatments.

A study by the University's Centre for Health Economics suggests that widening the perspective used by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) to assess the cost-effectiveness of new technologies may not benefit either the NHS or the wider economy.

The research examined a range of possible policies and a number of case studies from past NICE appraisals.

The new study suggested that taking into account effects outside the NHS would require trade-offs to be made between the overall impact on the health of NHS patients, other social concerns and wider costs and economic benefits

Extending the NICE perspective for drug assessment beyond the NHS raises questions of how to measure and value a range of wider economic effects, requiring controversial judgments about social values.

The research found that maintaining an NHS perspective would, in many circumstances, reflect overall economic effects because technologies which are regarded as cost-effective and offer overall health improvement for patients would also be expected to result in overall net economic benefits.

In addition, extending the perspective for all technologies appraised by NICE would impose additional costs on NICE's appraisal process and introduce the possibility of a biased assessment if the economic benefits associated with other NHS care which may be displaced are more difficult to identify.

Consideration could be restricted to exceptional cases where the external economic benefits are likely to be substantially greater or less than current NHS activities which may be displaced.

This more focused approach would require greater clarity on how wider effects will be considered by NICE, as well as criteria to identify exceptional cases, possibly based on the nature of the technology, the type of disease and the patient population. But the researchers warn that repeated application of this policy will ultimately lead to significant impacts on the NHS and a positive bias in favour of new technologies.

Lead researchers Professor Karl Claxton and Professor Mark Sculpher conclude: "Adopting a wider perspective without taking proper account of the implications of an NHS budget, which is fixed by government and beyond the remit of a body like NICE, has little to commend it. "

The independent study, which was commissioned through the Department of Health's Policy Research Programme, will be discussed at a workshop this Spring.


'/>"/>

Contact: David Garner
dcg501@york.ac.uk
44-019-044-32153
University of York
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Study quantifies cost-benefit of hospital-based program to keep youth out of prison
2. IQWiG presents a concept for cost-benefit assessment methods in the German health care system
3. Homeowners Admit to Dust Bunny Dilemma
4. Diabetes dilemma: older people with diabetes face a heavy burden from co-existing health conditions
5. The forever war on terror: Dilemmas and choices
6. Florida Dentist Launches Revolutionary Solution to National Dental Specialist/Patient Care Dilemma
7. Medical Marketing Expert Offers Dentists Tips for Thriving Down Economy After the Wall Street Dilemma
8. Lights Out For Bed Bugs as "BEST YET" Cedar Oil Solution Solves International Bed Bug Dilemma
9. PALNET Solves the Pallet Buyers Dilemma
10. Do the Swiss Have the Answer to Americas Health Care Dilemma?
11. Study examines ethical dilemmas of medical tourism
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/22/2017)... ... September 22, 2017 , ... The freshly released app Smart ... to Smart Mart, customers can now order vegetable, fruit, snacks, dairy, or any ... find clothing at discounted prices. Apart from this, Smart Mart has emphasized upon ...
(Date:9/22/2017)... Greenwich, Connecticut (PRWEB) , ... September 22, 2017 ... ... to conquering Lyme and other tick-borne diseases through research, education and awareness, today ... , A noted immunologist and microbiologist, Dr. Sellati has more than 20 ...
(Date:9/21/2017)... ... 2017 , ... 38-Year-Old Plastic Surgeon Gill at Aesthetic Surgery Center is Saluted ... announce that Plastic Surgeon Kiranjeet Gill has been awarded as one of the 15th ... award that was started in 2003 to salute young achievers in Southwest Florida who ...
(Date:9/21/2017)... ... September 21, 2017 , ... SABRE is raising awareness ... September 11 to the end of November. , The Chicago, Illinois, based self-defense brand ... and teach them about the ease of taking their personal safety into their own ...
(Date:9/21/2017)... ... September 21, 2017 , ... ... Management Report**, http://www.fdanews.com/products/54818-promotional-communication      , In the competitive world of drug and ... while staying in compliance with FDA rules. , The FDA has issued two ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:9/9/2017)... -- Eli Lilly and Company (NYSE: LLY ) ... lasmiditan, an investigational, oral, first-in-class molecule for the acute ... to placebo in the Phase 3 SPARTAN study. Detailed ... of the International Headache Society (IHC) in ... demonstrate lasmiditan,s potential to reduce pain and provide freedom ...
(Date:9/7/2017)... RANCHO MIRAGE, Calif. , Sept. 7, 2017  For nearly two ... and service in the Assisted Reproduction Insurance industry. Today, New Life Agency ... expensive fertility medications. ... http://pharmacarecard.com/ (PRNewsfoto/PharmaCareCard) ... ...
(Date:9/7/2017)... , Sept. 7, 2017 NuvoAir ... Smart Spirometer, announced today a partnership with Novartis Pharma AG ... solidifies NuvoAir,s position as the leading mobile spirometry platform and ... patients. ... test ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: