Navigation Links
Survey finds widespread dissatisfaction with current health care payment system

New York, N.Y., November 3, 2008Leaders in health care and health care policy feel strongly that the way we pay for health care in the U.S. must be fundamentally reformed. The latest Commonwealth Fund/Modern Healthcare Health Care Opinion Leaders Survey reports that more than two-thirds (69%) of respondents expressed strong dissatisfaction with the current system, which is generally based on "fee-for-service" payment, saying the current system is not effective in encouraging high quality and efficient care.

The current fee-for-service system reimburses individual serviceshospital stays, physician visits, and proceduresrather than paying for the most appropriate care for the patient over the course of an illness or a time period. In doing so, it creates incentives to provide more technical and more expensive services, rather than encouraging more effective, higher-value care. Only 1 percent of health care leaders surveyed said they preferred the current fee-for-service payment system to alternative approaches.

The survey asked respondents their opinions about various policy strategies for improving U.S. health system performance. Eighty-five percent of respondents believe fundamental provider payment reform with incentives to provide high-quality and efficient care over time is an effective strategy. Similarly, a majority of leaders deemed bonus payments for high-quality providers (55%) and public reporting of information on provider quality and efficiency (53%) as effective or very effective strategies for improving performance.

There was strong support for a move away from fee-for-service payment toward bundled approachesthat is, making a single payment for all services provided to a patient during the course of an episode or time period. When asked about preferred options for payment reform, 53 percent of opinion leaders chose a blend of modified fee-for-service and bundled per-patient payment, while another 23 percent chose bundled per-patient payment alone.

Overall, leaders expressed an unequivocal call for change. "The current financial crisis has changed the nature of the debate over health reform," said Commonwealth Fund President Karen Davis, "More than ever, it will be essential to craft a plan that will give more Americans health security while simultaneously controlling costs. These results show that most leaders favor rethinking the way we pay health care providers, in order to attain better value and lower costs for the nation."

Other findings from the survey include:

  • An overwhelming proportion of opinion leaders (85%) reported they support or strongly support revising the Medicare fee schedule (i.e., the resource-based-relative value schedule) to increase payments for primary care.

  • Respondents voiced strong support for realigning the system to pay for transitional care services (77%), paying physician practices a monthly per patient fee for serving as a medical home (74%), and eliminating payments resulting for "never events," like avoidable infections or complications in hospitals (67%).

  • Nearly three of four opinion leaders are in favor of Medicare negotiating pharmaceutical prices and engaging in competitive bidding for durable medical equipment as strategies to reduce the growth of health care costs.

  • Nearly three of five (57%) health care opinion leaders said shared accountability for resource useholding health care organizations, including hospitals and physicians, accountable for the resources used in caring for patients over time and sharing a portion of costs savedis an effective strategy.

  • Slightly more than a third (37%) believe paying for performanceproviding bonus payments to providers for high performancewould be effective or very effective in improving health care efficiency.

In addition, more than half (56%) of health care opinion leaders support or strongly support the creation of a Medicare Health Board, which would be established by Congress and empowered to make Medicare payment and benefit decisions, within congressional guidelines.

The survey is the 16th in a series from The Commonwealth Fund, and the eighth conducted in partnership with the publication Modern Healthcare. Commentaries on the survey results by J. James Rohack, M.D., president-elect of the American Medical Association, and Glenn Hackbarth, J.D., M.A., chair of the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission, as well as a member of The Commonwealth Fund Board of Directors and Commission on a High Performance Health System, appear in the November 3 issue of Modern Healthcare. The commentaries are also posted on the Fund's Web site, along with a Commission data brief discussing the survey findings.


Contact: Mary Mahon
Commonwealth Fund

Related medicine news :

1. Survey Reveals Consumer Interest in New Media Formats for Health Information From Hospitals
2. National Breast Cancer Coalition Survey Reveals That Lack of Commitment and Funding Impede the Fight Against Breast Cancer
3. Large-Scale Survey Reveals Low Sexual Desire Most Common Distressing Female Sexual Problem, Affecting Up to One in 10 Women
4. Pre-election surveys show deep concern about state of health care
5. Results From Pre-Election Surveys Published in NEJM Show Deep Concerns About State of Health Care With McCain and Obama Supporters Differing Sharply on Directions for New Administration
6. Survey Reveals Heartburn Sufferers Experience More Heartburn During the Holidays
7. AllMed Announces Annual Hospital Peer Review Survey Results
8. New National Patient and Surgeon Surveys Show Post-Surgical Care Critical to Optimal Weight Loss After Bariatric Surgery
9. Guardian Survey: More Than Half of Small Business Employers Who Offer Benefits Encounter Challenges During Open Enrollment Season
10. New State Public Health Department Survey Results Highlight Available Resources for Men and Women
11. Survey Reveals Long Term Care Key Issue for Voters in Presidential Election
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/24/2015)... , ... November 24, 2015 , ... ... the United States to support their local poison centers through donations on Tuesday, ... #GivingTuesday: calls it “a day that inspires people to collaborate in improving ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... ... November 24, 2015 , ... Cold Shoulder , LLC launched their Pro Vest, the latest ... hit their goal of $20,000 in under 10 hours. , The campaign, ... PRO Weight Loss Vest to the market. , The PRO Vest provides consumers with a ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... , ... November 24, 2015 , ... ... Exercise and Healthy Aging Program have announced their endorsement of the ... “American Specialty Health Fitness is proud to have the MFN as one of ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... Geneva, IL (PRWEB) , ... November 24, 2015 , ... All her life, Don Peck’s ... Even her obituary said she might have been. After a 25-year search for ... Mayflower voyager with whom she shared a last name. Turns out, it was Don’s ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... ... ... “I am so thrilled, as a newbie here, to leave a mark for the entire ... Lounge Makeover® from California Casualty . Stephanie is in her fifth year teaching at ... tenure. , “This is such an amazing school and we deserve a space where we ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/24/2015)... DALLAS , Nov. 24, 2015  Ascendant Solutions, Inc. ... announced that its Board of Directors has declared a special ... The stock dividend is payable December 14, 2015, to shareholders ... in the form of additional shares of common stock. ... by the Board is a strong endorsement of our confidence ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... iRhythm Technologies, Inc. , a leading digital health care solutions company ... in the 27th Annual Piper Jaffray Healthcare Conference at The New ... . Kevin King , Chief Executive Officer of iRhythm, is ... --> --> About iRhythm ... . --> iRhythm is a privately held digital healthcare ...
(Date:11/24/2015)... , Nov. 24, 2015  Boston Scientific Corporation (NYSE: ... Oppenheimer 26th Annual Healthcare Conference on December 8, in ... Susie Lisa , vice president, Investor Relations, will participate ... beginning at approximately 8:35 a.m. ET. --> ... in a 30-minute question-and-answer session with the host analyst ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: