Navigation Links
Survey finds surgical residents view duty hour regulations as a hindrance to training

CHICAGO (July 14, 2009) Results of a survey published in the July issue of the Journal of the American College of Surgeons show that a large subset of surgical residents consider duty hour regulations (DHR) a significant barrier to their surgical education and express a desire for flexibility to work longer hours than current restrictions allow.

The implementation of DHR in 2003 was intended to address resident fatigue and improve patient safety. Prior to implementation, residents often worked 100 hours or more weekly; currently, residents are limited to an 80-hour work week. Although studies have shown that residents are getting more sleep and their personal lives are improved, the effect of DHR on case load, academic performance, and board examination performance is still poorly understood. The effect of DHR on patient care also remains uncertain, and there is evidence to suggest that there has been an increase in communication errors as a result of frequent patient handoffs.

"We were surprised to find that nearly half of surgical residents believe work-hour restrictions are actually an impediment to their training," said Jacob Moalem, MD, Department of Surgery, University of Rochester (NY) Medical Center. "Our current system limits educational opportunities for surgeons who are expressing a desire and a need to learn more in a compact time frame. Senior surgery residents should be given the chance to control their own schedules as they continue to refine their technical skills and transition into independent practice."

An Internet-based survey was electronically distributed to all resident and associate members of the American College of Surgeons. The first question asked respondents to rate the impact of DHR on their education as "no barrier," "minimal barrier," "moderate barrier" and "significant barrier." For analysis, the first two choices were grouped and retitled "no barrier," and the latter two choices were grouped and called "barrier." The second question asked respondents how many hours they considered ideal for their postgraduate year in their program. Choices provided were <60 hours, 60 to 80 hours, 80 to 100 hours, and >100 hours per week.

Of 599 respondents, 41 percent believed that DHR were a considerable or moderate barrier to their education. Less than one-third of residents reported that their education was not hindered by DHR. Another 27 percent stated that DHR were a minimal barrier to their education.

A small majority of residents (52 percent) reported that the ideal number of hours for their training was 60 to 80, in line with the current DHR. Forty-three percent believed that 80 to 100 hours per week would be ideal.

The belief that DHR represented a substantial or moderate barrier to education was correlated with the belief that the ideal DHR should be greater than 80 hours per week (p< 0.0001). Furthermore, the likelihood that residents and fellows considered DHR a barrier to their education was highly related to their level of training (p=0.03). First- and second-year residents were more than twice as likely to believe that DHR were not a barrier to education (p=0.0003 and p=0.006, respectively). Conversely, the proportion of residents who believed that DHR substantially interfered with their education peaked as they approached graduation. Compared with only 7 percent of junior residents, 32 percent of residents in or beyond their seventh postgraduate year reported that DHR were an important barrier to their education (p = 0.006).


Contact: Sally Garneski
Weber Shandwick Worldwide

Related medicine news :

1. New Survey Highlights Emotional, Financial Toll Multi-Generational Tobacco Use Takes on Parents Sandwiched In Between
2. Kaiser Permanente Survey Shows Seniors Embrace Internet to Manage Their Health
3. Survey: Speech Therapy Helps, But People Who Stutter Suffer Discrimination
4. For Treatment of Dyslipidemia, Surveyed Physicians are Increasingly Switching Patients to a More Potent Statin Following the ENHANCE and SEAS Trials
5. National Survey: Americans Fear Paying for Cancer Treatment As Much As Dying of the Disease
6. New Survey Reveals High Expectations for Popular Aesthetic Injections
7. NEUTROGENA(R) and BabyCenter Sun Survey Finds While Mom Knows Best She Can Learn Even More When it Comes to Sun Protection
8. National Survey Shows 70% of Women Have Experienced a Sexual Health Issue
9. CED/Zogby Release Survey of Business Perspectives on Healthcare Reform
10. Availability in Both Intravenous and Oral Formulation is a Leading Drug Attribute Surveyed Physicians Prefer for the Treatment of Urinary Tract Infections in the Hospital Setting
11. SouthWest Benefits Association Survey Finds Employers Continue to Focus on Health and Wellness during Economic Downturn
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/13/2015)... , ... October 13, 2015 , ... ... communities, and the Florida Apartment Association (FAA) has partnered with the Florida Department ... meet the demand. , The FAA Smoke-Free Multifamily Housing Program launched last ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... , ... Just under three months ago, eMarketing Concepts forever changed ... effectively offering all of their services for just a buck in the first month. ... phone calls from interested buyers. As a genuine one-stop-shop for internet marketing, EMC has ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... CA (PRWEB) , ... October 13, 2015 , ... ... announced the release of a new PDF automation tool to batch conversions ... and business mandates with 100% document fidelity. , CADConverter eliminates the complexity requirement ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... The Bill Howe Family of Companies ... offering expert reconstruction and flood remediation services. Family-owned and operated for 35 years, they ... the Best San Diego plumber two years in a row from the Union Tribune ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... Somerset, N.J. (PRWEB) , ... October 13, 2015 ... ... advanced delivery technologies and development solutions for drugs, biologics, consumer health and animal ... Science and Technology, and will lead a new, dedicated global team of drug ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/12/2015)... Oct. 12, 2015 CorVascular Diagnostics, ... medical technology company that designs and distributes ... it has entered into a collaboration and ... dedicated to producing devices, software and services ... PAD-IQ®, developed and produced by Vasamed, provides ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... St. Paul, Minn. , Oct. 12, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... with it, a need to help integrate these devices ... global leader of ergonomic healthcare mounting and mobility solutions, ... Carts, its lightest cart yet, for a wide array ... StyleView S-Tablet Cart SV10 was developed exclusively for Microsoft ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... 12, 2015 Beginning October 1, 2015 All ... the fastest growing practice management system for therapists, psychologists, ... converts all patient diagnostic codes from the former DSM-4/ICD-9, ... --> --> Therapy Partner has also ... health practitioners to easily understand the conversion to ICD-10 ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: