Navigation Links
Study finds expensive procedure no more effective than medical therapy to prevent strokes

CLEVELAND -- A catheter procedure that closes a hole in patients' hearts was no more effective than medical therapy in preventing recurrent strokes, according to a new study published in the March 15 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine.

In the CLOSURE I trial, clinical researchers compared a catheter procedure plus medical therapy with medications alone to prevent new strokes or transient ischemic attacks (TIAs) in patients between 18 and 60 years old with an unexplained ("cryptogenic") stroke or TIA and a patent foremen ovale (PFO) a hole between the heart's two upper chambers.

In the ground-breaking, international multi-site study led by University Hospitals (UH) Case Medical Center and Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, researchers sought to demonstrate the superiority of the STARFlex Septal Closure System over medical therapies (aspirin or warfarin) alone. Instead, results showed no statistically significant differences between the two therapies.

"These important findings will serve as a guidepost in the prevention of stroke in patients with PFO," said Anthony J. Furlan, MD, lead investigator of the study and Chairman of the Department of Neurology at UH Case Medical Center and Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine.

In an accompanying editorial, S. Claiborne Johnston, MD, PhD, from the University of California, San Francisco, wrote, "CLOSURE I provides the best evidence available regarding the role of closure in stroke prevention and should not be ignored. The results of the trial do not support closure of a patent foramen ovale to prevent stroke in patients who have had a stroke or a TIA of unclear etiology."

The editorial also notes that it took nine years for the results of this trial to be reported and during that time, approximately 80,000 patients have had a PFO closed with the use of a device at an average cost of $10,000 per procedure. "Even if only half these patients were treated by this method for the purpose of preventing stroke, it would suggest that during that period of time $400 million was spent on a procedure that had no apparent benefit, to say nothing of the potential clinical risks involved," wrote Dr. Johnston.

Strokes of unknown origin cryptogenic strokes have several causes, including PFO, a hole that is vital to fetal survival between the heart's two upper chambers if it doesn't close completely after birth. If a blood clot arises in a vein and passes through the hole and reaches the brain (called "paradoxical embolism"), a stroke results. In roughly 20 percent of adults, remnants of the hole persist.

CLOSURE I is the first completed prospective, randomized, two-arm superiority trial of percutaneous PFO device closure versus medical therapy alone in cryptogenic stroke patients using the STARFlex Septal Closure System. The device, attached to a catheter and threaded into the upper heart, applies a "clamshell" patch on both sides of the hole.

The trial's primary endpoint was the difference in the stroke and TIA rates between the two patient groups at two years, death from all causes in the first 30 days, and death from neurological causes at 30 days or more.

Dr. Furlan and colleagues enrolled 909 patients at 87 United States and Canadian sites during 64 months ending October 2008. Researchers randomized patients to either medical therapy (325 mg of aspirin or the appropriate warfarin dose, or a combination of both) or PFO closure and medical therapy (75 mg of clopidogrel for six months and 325 mg of aspirin for two years).

"Based on the trial results, even though a patient had a PFO and a recurrent stroke, the hole may be totally coincidental to the second stroke," Dr. Furlan said. "The undeniable message here is that too many of these holes are being closed with an off-label procedure, but partly that is because we've never had a randomized trial to guide us. Furthermore, our criteria for diagnosing paradoxical embolism and the potential efficacy of PFO closure in patient subgroups require further study. Until then we would advise initial secondary stroke prevention with medical therapy in most patients with unexplained stroke or TIA and a PFO. "


Contact: George Stamatis
University Hospitals Case Medical Center

Related medicine news :

1. Anti-Smoking Efforts Saved 795,000 Lives Over 25 Years: Study
2. New Gel Treats Precancerous Skin Condition in Days: Study
3. Study: US tobacco-control efforts prevented nearly 800,000 cancer deaths between 1975 and 2000
4. Personalized immune mouse offers new tool for studying autoimmune diseases
5. Inflammation Might Play Role in Heart Disease: Study
6. Study suggests link between H. pylori bacteria and blood sugar control in adult Type 2 diabetes
7. Broader screening for hepatitis C would be cost effective, study suggests
8. New study shows promise for developing new treatments for breast cancer
9. Groundbreaking, long-term study of head injuries among athletes kicks off with NCAA grant
10. Drug Reduces Complications in Surgical Abortions: Study
11. NEJM study shows combination treatments benefit melanoma patient
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/30/2015)... DE (PRWEB) , ... November 30, 2015 , ... ... guest lecturer at a University of Delaware Accounting and Management of Information Systems ... software solutions for mid-market businesses. Sommer will speak at before student in the ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... Cycling, running, and walking are regular Sunday activities ... morning of February 28, 2016. , That’s when the 7th annual ANF Group ... to help children and families at Joe DiMaggio Children’s Hospital. , The ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... HemoTreat™ has announced that the ... ointment to its website. , “Our goal is simple:” says Michael Blasco, HemoTreat’s ... the comparison chart and ingredient list allows our customers to quickly see why, ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... , ... At Grand Dental PC, their priority is to deliver quality care ... problems, you need to turn to a dentist who listens and responds; an experienced ... friendly dentist who counsels you on the best ways to maintain and improve your ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... November 30, 2015 , ... Dr. Seth ... three office locations, patients can visit Dr. Margulies to experience the best available orthodontic ... hold the title of "NJ Top Dentist"! , Orthodontics is the branch of dentistry ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... , November 30, 2015 North America ... is expected to grow at a CAGR of 7.6% from 2015 ... valued at USD 135.6 million in 2014, and is expected to ... --> According to the new Market Research Report "North America ... By End User (Hospitals, ambulatory care, others) - Analysis And Forecast ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... , November 30, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... --> adds a ... for 2010 - 2015 with comprehensive ... a range of deal types, such ... strategic alliances. ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... Nov. 30, 2015  Kevin Smith has been ... a global pioneer in wireless monitoring of vital ... MA , Mr. Smith will be responsible ... commercial strategy.  He will also directly oversee partnering ... clinical evidence for SensiumVitals, the first early warning ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: