Navigation Links
Study examines relationship of a commercial ACO contract with medical spending

Payment incentives implemented with a commercial accountable care organization (ACO) initiative in Massachusetts Blue Cross Blue Shield's Alternative Quality Contract (AQC) were associated with lower spending for Medicare enrollees served by the provider groups participating in the AQC, findings that suggest that evaluations of ACO programs may need to consider the implications for other patient populations to assess their full clinical and economic benefits, according to a study in the August 28 issue of JAMA.

"In response to mounting pressures to deliver more cost-effective care, provider organizations have exhibited increasing willingness to assume financial risk for the quality and costs of the care they provide. More than 250 provider groups have contracted with Medicare as ACOs, and many similar payment arrangements have been reached with commercial insurers by these and other groups," according to background information in the article. "In a multipayer system, new payment incentives implemented by one insurer for an ACO may also affect spending and quality of care for another insurer's enrollees served by the ACO. Such spillover effects reflect the extent of organizational efforts to reform care delivery and can contribute to the net impact of ACOs."

J. Michael McWilliams, M.D., Ph.D., of Harvard Medical School, Boston, and colleagues conducted a study to examine whether the Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) of Massachusetts' Alternative Quality Contract (AQC), an early commercial ACO initiative associated with reduced spending and improved quality for BCBS enrollees, was also associated with changes in spending and quality for Medicare beneficiaries, who were not covered by the AQC. The study included comparisons from 2007-2010 of elderly fee-for-service Medicare beneficiaries in Massachusetts served by 11 provider organizations entering the AQC in 2009 or 2010 (intervention group) vs. beneficiaries served by other providers (control group). The researchers estimated changes in spending and quality for the intervention group in the first and second years of exposure to the AQC relative to concurrent changes for the control group. The primary outcome was total quarterly medical spending per beneficiary. Secondary outcomes included spending by setting and type of service, 5 process measures of quality, potentially avoidable hospitalizations, and 30-day readmissions.

The researchers found that differential changes in sociodemographic and clinical characteristics were small for the intervention group relative to the control group, and none was statistically significant, suggesting that the findings were not due to changes in patient case mix. Adjusted total quarterly spending was $150 higher for the intervention group than for the control group, and spending trends were similar before AQC incentives were implemented for participating organizations. "In year 2 of the intervention group's exposure to the AQC, the spending difference between the intervention and control groups was reduced to $51, constituting a significant differential change of -$99 or a 3.4 percent savings relative to an expected quarterly mean of $2,895. Savings in year 1 were not statistically significant."

Savings in year 2 were explained largely by differential changes in outpatient care (-$73) and included significant differential changes in spending on office visits, emergency department visits, minor procedures, imaging, and laboratory tests. Estimated savings in year 2 spending on outpatient care for the intervention group were greater among beneficiaries with 5 or more conditions (-$125) than among those with fewer conditions (-$61).

"Annual rates of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol testing differentially improved for beneficiaries with diabetes in the intervention group by 3.1 percentage points and for those with cardiovascular disease by 2.5 percentage points, but performance on other quality measures did not differentially change," the authors write.

"Our findings have several implications for payment and delivery system reforms. In general, cost-reducing spillover effects of ACO contracts with one insurer on care for other insurers' enrollees should signal a willingness among provider organizations generating the spillovers to enter similar contracts with additional insurers; they could be rewarded for the savings and quality improvements achieved for the other insurers' enrollees. Broad organizational responses to early ACO initiatives, like those suggested by our findings, might support a rapid transition among ACOs to global payment arrangements with multiple payers. Conversely, cost-reducing spillovers present a free-riding problem to commercial insurers engaged in ACO contracts, since competing insurers with similar provider networks could offer lower premiums without incurring the costs of managing an ACO. Additional efforts to foster multipayer participation in global payment systems, such as recent state initiatives and provisions in Pioneer Medicare ACO contracts, may be important."

" our study suggests that organizations in Massachusetts willing to assume greater financial risk were capable of achieving modest reductions in spending for Medicare beneficiaries without compromising quality of care. Although effects of commercial and Medicare ACO initiatives similar to the AQC may differ in other markets, these findings suggest potential for these payment models to foster systemic change in care delivery. Evaluations of ACO programs may need to consider spillover effects on other patient populations to assess their full clinical and economic benefits," the researchers conclude.


Contact: David Cameron
The JAMA Network Journals

Related medicine news :

1. Europe Small Bone & Joint Orthopedic Device Market to See Positive Growth to 2019, According to iData Research Study Available at
2. Study Finds GanedenBC30 Probiotic Supports Digestive and Immune Health in Healthy Seniors
3. World Antibiotic Resistance Market Saw Big Changes in Last Five Years, According to Biopharm Reports Study Available at
4. Study finds tumor suppressor may actually fuel aggressive leukemia
5. African-American women less likely to receive HPV vaccine than whites, Pitt study finds
6. Kwiksure and MSIG Comment on Recent Study on the Use of Mobile Phones While Driving
7. Language can reveal the invisible, study shows
8. UCI, UCLA study reveals new approach to remedying childhood visual disorders
9. New Case Study From Orriant Demonstrates the Wellness Incentives That Come From a Healthy Lifestyle
10. Preschoolers who stutter do just fine emotionally and socially, study finds
11. Study supports intracerebral stem cell injections to prevent/reduce post-stroke cognitive deficits
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... 2015 , ... The Foundation for Breast and Prostate Health ... forces with the award-winning creator and writer of Downton Abbey Julian Fellowes to ... the Union League of Philadelphia. , The benefit, titled “An Evening with ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... California-based i2i Systems, a pioneer ... that Michigan-based Family Health Center (FHC) has selected i2iTracks as their population health ... awarded the largest Affordable Care Act grant for Federally Qualified Health Centers in ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... , ... In an interview with Andy Mitchell of Peconic Bay Medical Center, ... east end. During the broadcast, entitled “Eyes: the Window to the Soul,” Dr. Buono ... and how a visit with his grandmother to her physician put him on a ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... ... Kreithen”), one of the leading plastic surgery practices in Florida, is proud to ... to consult for surgical innovations giant Ethicon Inc., a Johnson & Johnson Company. ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... Vasont Systems, a top component ... (VUI) extension unites with Syncro Soft’s latest software update, oXygen XML editor Version ... with the latest release of oXygen® XML editor and the Vasont® CCMS. ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... Medical Systems (NYSE: VAR ) has signed a Memorandum of ... the largest hospital chain in India , to ... country. The MoU was signed by Dr. K. Prabakar , ... Varian,s India managing director, in ... intends to deploy its Access to Care program by leveraging the ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... NAMUR , Belgium , Nov. 30, ... life sciences company focused on developing blood-based diagnostic tests for ... announced the Company will present at the LD Micro Conference, ... Los Angeles, CA. Attending from VolitionRx will ... and Scott Powell , Vice President of Investor Relations. ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... Mexico Healthcare and Life Sciences Report 2015 . --> ... Pharmaboardroom releases its new 98-page Mexico Healthcare and Life Sciences ... country of over 122 million people. --> Latin ... --> It offers companies, investors, policymakers, and stakeholders with an ... largest pharma and healthcare market in Latin America ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: