Navigation Links
Study Questions Screening Heart Attack Patients for Depression
Date:11/11/2008

International experts say there isn't enough evidence to prove its value

TUESDAY, Nov. 11 (HealthDay News) -- There's not enough evidence to support a recent American Heart Association (AHA) call to automatically screen heart patients for depression, according to international experts who contend the "premature" recommendation would consume a vast amount of resources without any proof it would improve patient care.

About 80 million Americans have some form of heart disease. The AHA believes there's an important link between depression and cardiac care, and estimates that 25 percent of heart attack patients experience feelings of sadness and develop a gloomy outlook due to their heart troubles. Some studies suggest that depression more than doubles the risk of death.

Screening heart patients for depression would involve use of a questionnaire and other tests to try to identify those who may be depressed, even though they may have no history or clinical indications of depression.

However, researchers from Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, McGill University in Montreal, and six other institutions from around the world analyzed the findings of 1,500 clinical trials (including 17 selected for detailed review) and concluded there was no scientific proof for the AHA's "massive, expensive and labor-intensive" proposal.

The researchers' conclusions are published in the Nov. 12 special edition of the Journal of the American Medical Association, which coincides with the AHA's annual scientific sessions in New Orleans.

"It's a very appealing idea that non-mental health professionals can administer a quick, easy-to-use depression screening test, and that would somehow benefit patients. Unfortunately, the reality is that it would be an extremely difficult undertaking that wouldn't produce practical benefits for patients," study team leader Brett Thombs, a psychologist and assistant professor in th
'/>"/>

Copyright©2008 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Study: Smoking Ban Would Help Reduce Heart Attack Admissions
2. Pivotal Emory study focuses on teens at risk for psychosis
3. New study: A Common Class of GI Medications Reduce Protection Against Heart Attack in Patients Taking Widely Prescribed Cardiovascular Drug
4. Study Finds Folic Acid Not Cardioprotective, Though Safe
5. Study Finds Timing Is Everything For Some Heart Attack Patients
6. New technique to study the genetics of breast cancer
7. Intestinal Infection Afflicts 13 of 1,000 Hospital Patients, Infection Rates 6.5 - 20 Times Greater Than Previous Estimates, New Study Says
8. WomenHeart Urges Women to Talk With Doctors About New Study Showing Statins Prevent Heart Attacks, Deaths
9. High Temps Degrade Contact Lens Solution: Study
10. Study Upholds Stopping Plavix Use Before Surgery
11. Cornell researchers study showing evidence of a major environmental trigger for autism
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:10/20/2014)... 20, 2014 With a mere 19 ... Crist made a brief fundraising stop at the ... , Fresh from a debate last night with his ... stage for the first seven minutes because Crist had ... described the incident in one word: "weird." , Before ...
(Date:10/20/2014)... October 20, 2014 T.E.N., a ... firm, announced today that William H. Murray, renowned ... 2014 ISE® Luminary Leadership Award winner. Presented annually, ... of an outstanding leader and industry practitioner for ... in advancing the information security industry. , Formerly ...
(Date:10/20/2014)... Principle Business Enterprises, a family owned company ... absorbent products. The company has recently made efforts ... Tranquility® Premium Protection absorbent products. The company has ... packaging a new look, and is currently working on ... public. , The new website, developed with Thread Marketing ...
(Date:10/20/2014)... Collins, CO (PRWEB) October 20, 2014 ... dGH assays are the only imaging assays capable ... in a single test.  With these three dimensions ... their ability to detect the widest range of ... translocations—mutations usually missed by other genomic tools, including ...
(Date:10/20/2014)... York, NY (PRWEB) October 20, 2014 ... be introduced in the U.S., has a lot to celebrate ... when our country recognizes the achievements and contributions of Americans ... the anniversary for Punzoné, and today it shares its favorite ... take a trip to Italy - even if it is ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:At Crist Fundraiser, Dan Newlin Says, "No More Robert Germans," Will Seek Changes to Florida Missing Persons Law 2Health News:At Crist Fundraiser, Dan Newlin Says, "No More Robert Germans," Will Seek Changes to Florida Missing Persons Law 3Health News:Bill Murray named 2014 ISE® Luminary Leadership Award Winner 2Health News:Bill Murray named 2014 ISE® Luminary Leadership Award Winner 3Health News:Bill Murray named 2014 ISE® Luminary Leadership Award Winner 4Health News:Tranquility® Premium Protection Incontinence Products Releases New Logo and Website 2Health News:KromaTiD Launches Genome Screening and Discovery Services 2Health News:KromaTiD Launches Genome Screening and Discovery Services 3Health News:Celebrate Italian Heritage Month With Authentic Cocktails from Punzoné: The Only Ultra Premium Line of Organic Imported Italian Vodka 2Health News:Celebrate Italian Heritage Month With Authentic Cocktails from Punzoné: The Only Ultra Premium Line of Organic Imported Italian Vodka 3Health News:Celebrate Italian Heritage Month With Authentic Cocktails from Punzoné: The Only Ultra Premium Line of Organic Imported Italian Vodka 4
... Medical College at Dallas report that contact lenses, ... transmissible materials are expected to reduce the possibility ... are available now. Based in part on these ... approved hyper-oxygen transmissible contact lenses for 30-day continuous ...
... offers the hope of a less painful technique than traditional ... into an artery to bypass a blockage in the heart ... redirecting traffic. The blood is sent to the heart muscle ... ,Dr Stephen Oesterle, the author of a report into the ...
... has been experimented that can suppress menstruation for as long ... years.The tablet, which blocks the action of the hormone progesterone, ... the monthly menstrual cycle. Two versions of the new pill ... results published by American and German scientists in the latest ...
... for persons suffering from types of hereditary cancers.The Imperial ... allow doctors to identify people likely to suffer from ... ,By looking at skin warts, benign growths ... a history of HNPCC //- hereditary non-polyposis colorectal cancer ...
... detect cervical cancer,has been developed by Australians which may replace ... UK, Italy, Spain as well as Australia. ,Sydney-based Polartechnics ... CSIRO and claims that it offers instant results and greater ... probe to collect information directly from the cervix about the ...
... see couples who are HIV sero discordant but who would like ... and the wife is negative and they are planning to have ... in 500 risk of transmitting the virus to the female partner ... Sperm washing is a risk-reduction option in which ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:New contact lens materials 2Health News:Revolution in surgery 2Health News:Pause as you please 2Health News:Sperm washing helps couples 2
(Date:10/20/2014)... 20, 2014  Luoxis Diagnostics, Inc., a subsidiary ... announced that its academic collaborators will present several ... for its novel RedoxSYS Diagnostic System, a first-in-class ... body in response to injury or illness.  A ... a clinical marker will be presented by ...
(Date:10/20/2014)... , Oct. 20, 2014  AnaptysBio, Inc., a ... antibodies, today announced the appointment of Marco ... Londei will lead the preclinical and clinical development ... "We are pleased to welcome Dr. Londei to ... , President and Chief Executive Officer of AnaptysBio. ...
(Date:10/20/2014)... DENVER , Oct. 20, 2014   Mary,s ... Foundation for Caring, is a 4-Star Sponsor of ... providing Veterans with unique products, programs and services to ... our freedom. Key Facts: , ... marijuana is a safe and effective treatment for pain, ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Luoxis to Highlight RedoxSYS at Two Upcoming Scientific Conferences 2Luoxis to Highlight RedoxSYS at Two Upcoming Scientific Conferences 3Luoxis to Highlight RedoxSYS at Two Upcoming Scientific Conferences 4Luoxis to Highlight RedoxSYS at Two Upcoming Scientific Conferences 5AnaptysBio Appoints Dr. Marco Londei to Newly Created Chief Development Officer Position Clinical Immunologist to Lead AnaptysBio's Pipeline Advancement 2Mary's Medicinals Announces 4-Star Sponsorship of Operation Grow4Vets 2Mary's Medicinals Announces 4-Star Sponsorship of Operation Grow4Vets 3
... -Memory to Host Conference ... and BASEL, Switzerland, May 2 ,Memory Pharmaceuticals Corp. (Nasdaq: ... Roche has exercised its option to further develop and,commercialize ... for neurological and psychiatric disorders. Roche,s,exercise of its option ...
... for More Targeted Asthma Control, MENLO PARK, ... announced today that it has begun shipments of ... March 2008, the Insight eNO,System combines the accuracy, ... provide office-based measurements of exhaled,nitric oxide (eNO). Exhaled ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Roche Exercises its Option to Further Develop and Commercialize Memory Pharmaceuticals' Nicotinic Alpha-7 Agonist, MEM 3454 2Roche Exercises its Option to Further Develop and Commercialize Memory Pharmaceuticals' Nicotinic Alpha-7 Agonist, MEM 3454 3Roche Exercises its Option to Further Develop and Commercialize Memory Pharmaceuticals' Nicotinic Alpha-7 Agonist, MEM 3454 4Apieron, Inc. Begins Customer Shipments of the Insight(TM) eNO System 2
... Laboratories is a national reference laboratory and ... and development. ARUP offers an extensive test ... tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned ... clients include more than half of the ...
... is a national reference laboratory and a ... development. ARUP offers an extensive test menu ... in clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned by ... include more than half of the nation's ...
... a national reference laboratory and a worldwide ... ARUP offers an extensive test menu of ... clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned by the ... more than half of the nation's university ...
... reference laboratory and a worldwide leader in ... an extensive test menu of highly complex ... anatomic pathology. Owned by the University of ... half of the nation's university teaching hospitals ...
Medicine Products: