Navigation Links
Structured reporting software creates less complete and accurate radiology reports than free text
Date:11/16/2009

WINSTON-SALEM, N.C. As many software companies work to create programs that will give uniform structure to the way radiological test results are reported, a new study by researchers at Wake Forest University School of Medicine shows that such a system does not improve, but rather decreases the completeness and accuracy of the reports.

The study, published recently in Radiology, compared the accuracy and completeness of reporting test results in a free text, narrative format versus using standardized words and phrases from a pull-down menu (structured reporting).

"This research is our attempt to evaluate a new technology that is a pretty hot topic in medicine right now and has been for a few years," said Annette J. Johnson, M.D., M.S., an associate professor of radiology and lead investigator on the study. "Since radiology began, we have been creating our reports in a free text, narrative format. The rationale behind efforts to change this format is that all of the reports that we create could potentially be a very useful data base for clinical care and research if they were standardized."

Standardization would mean that key content could be accessed through automated means, by computer systems, rather than requiring a human being to read the report and manually sift through narrative comments to try to find and categorize key content, Johnson said.

"This type of standardization is a very appealing idea, but we did not have data regarding what effect structured systems like this might have on individual report quality until now," she added. "It turns out that a structured reporting system actually decreases the accuracy and especially the completeness of reports, which is the opposite of what we expected."

This study provides the only known data about the proposed program's effect on the quality of radiological reports, Johnson said.

Currently, she explained, a physician might send a patient who is experiencing weakness in his arm, for example, for a head computed tomography (CT) scan to rule out concerns about a stroke. A radiologist then reads the CT scan and reports what she sees.

"I might say, 'There's no evidence of hemorrhage,' or any other variety of wording to convey that idea. I could say, 'no bleeding' or 'no hematoma' or 'no hyperdensity,' all of which mean the same thing," Johnson said. "In a structured system, I would choose from a list of standardized phrases with certain specific terms available in a dropdown menu, such as 'No presence of acute stroke.' Standardization seems simple, but it's not always easy or what we commonly do in medicine. The theory is that structured reporting would make the reports intrinsically better because we'd all be using the same ideas recorded in the same verbiage instead of using numerous different ways to say 'blood.' Right now, several people reading a scan may all agree that they see the same thing, but each individual will say it in a different way."

For the study, the researchers tested such a structured reporting system on two groups of residents. Each individual in both groups was given the same set of 25 brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans along with a video of a staff physician's interpretation of the MRI scans, and was asked to report the interpretation using the free text narrative they were familiar with using. Four months later, the same set of MRIs was given separately to each individual again. Half of the residents were asked to report their observations in the free text narrative form as they had the first time. The other half were asked to create their reports using the structured reporting software, which listed standardized sentences and phrases describing different findings to choose from.

"We thought that the structured reporting group would make better reports," Johnson said. "However, the reports created using structured reporting software were actually substantially less complete and a little less accurate compared to the reports made by the same residents in free text four months earlier and with the other group of residents who used free text both times."

The company that made the specific structured reporting software used for the study is no longer in existence, Johnson said, but there are still many more software companies very focused on creating these programs and finding ways to structure reports. These companies, and the physicians who choose to use structured reporting systems, should strongly consider how the software is going to affect the quality of real patient records, and all software should be specifically tested for quality effects before being implemented, she said.


'/>"/>

Contact: Jessica Guenzel
jguenzel@wfubmc.edu
336-716-3487
Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. DATATRAK Announces Restructured Senior Management Team
2. DCL Extends Structured Product Labeling (SPL) Services to Meet New FDA Requirements; Support Now Offered for CDER, CBER, CDRH, CVM and ONP Products
3. Structured Cabling Solutions Provider ICC Announces Rewards Program for Installers and Contractors
4. New Analysis Underscores Legality of Physician Ranking and Public Reporting Systems When Used by Health Insurers to Improve Health Care Quality
5. Substantial costs and underreporting of dengue fever, concerns about blood supply face US
6. Alarming MRSA Infection Rates Underscore Need for Public Reporting of Hospital-Acquired Infections
7. Consumers, Health Care Purchasers Applaud Agreement On Physician Performance Reporting
8. Womens Health Leader Lauds Agreement on Physician Performance Reporting in New York State
9. New Global Health Video Footage Available Rights-Free on GlobalHealthReporting.org
10. Health care opinion leaders support public reporting of health care quality, prices
11. Vermont Requires Reporting of NQF Serious Reportable Events
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/24/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... May 24, 2017 , ... Dr. Alan ... surgery in New York City. He is known for his distinguished expertise and ... vascular surgery, Dr. Benvenisty holds sub-specialty training in treating renovascular disease and aortic ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... ... May 24, 2017 , ... Drs. Nicholas Rallis and Chris ... spent 10 years as clinical instructors for the reputable Full Mouth Rehabilitation continuing ... the program, private practitioners receive cutting-edge clinical training and learn how to perform ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... ... May 24, 2017 , ... STATEMENT OPPOSING PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP’S ... Donald Trump’s budget, “A New Foundation for American Greatness—President's Budget FY 2018,” because ... marginalizes underserved populations, undermines productivity, and destroys the social safety net needed by ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... May 24, ... ... affecting the female reproductive tract in which the endometrial lining of the ... causing inflammation and pain. Patients experiencing painful intercourse, painful periods, pelvic pain, ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... ... ... If you are thinking of a visit to San Francisco , fall is a ... time to visit. , Business Architecture Associates is pleased to offer 5 days of training ... 4-½ day package for individuals, and as 4-½ day corporate package for up to 3 ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/10/2017)... , May 10, 2017 Radiology has become ... its costs have also spiraled to the number one ... to radiology than ever before as the most complete ... a patient with lower back pain an MRI may ... reason for pain, resulting in entirely different treatment protocols.  ...
(Date:5/9/2017)...  Semler Scientific, Inc. (OTCQB: SMLR), an emerging ... the clinical effectiveness and efficiency of healthcare providers, ... ended March 31, 2017. "We ... identify when preventive care options are appropriate, which ... attacks or strokes occur," said Doug Murphy-Chutorian ...
(Date:5/6/2017)...  Hill-Rom Holdings, Inc. (NYSE: HRC), has begun a ... to its Welch Allyn campus. The ... more than 100 new jobs to Central ... a significant presence for more than 100 years. Hill-Rom,s ... large portion of which will be R&D and engineering ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: