Navigation Links
Spinal Fusion Surgery May Leave Some Back Pain Patients Worse Off: Study
Date:2/23/2011

By Maureen Salamon
HealthDay Reporter

WEDNESDAY, Feb. 23 (HealthDay News) -- Spinal fusion surgery for chronic low back pain -- an increasingly controversial treatment that has exploded in use over the last 20 years -- leads to higher rates of permanent disability for worker's compensation patients compared to those treated non-surgically, a new study finds.

Researchers randomly selected 725 people with low back pain treated with fusion surgery and 725 whose more conservative treatment included exercise and physical therapy. Participants were chosen from a pool of worker's compensation patients in Ohio whose on-the-job injuries between 1999 and 2001 resulted in chronic low back pain.

When the study ended in 2006, nearly all outcome categories were worse in the surgical group. Only about a quarter had returned to work after two years, compared with two-thirds of non-surgical patients. Eleven percent were permanently disabled compared with 2 percent of those without surgery.

And nearly 85 percent of the spinal fusion patients continued using opioid painkillers vs. 49 percent of non-surgical patients, with those who had had the surgery upping their daily opioid use by 41 percent.

In addition, 36 percent of the spinal fusion group had complications from the surgery, including meningitis, kidney failure and death. The re-operation rate was also 27 percent in the surgery group, and included three people who underwent four re-operations. And total days off work was also greater in the spinal fusion group (1140 days vs. 316 days).

"I'm not saying don't have lumbar fusion surgery . . . but it should be carefully evaluated before it's done," said lead study author Dr. Trang H. Nguyen, who practices occupational medicine in Cincinnati and conducted the research while a doctoral candidate at the University of Cincinnati College of Medicine. "The chances are it will have a poor outcome."

The study was published in the Feb. 15 issue of Spine.

Spinal fusion surgery, which fuses adjacent vertebrae together to treat degenerative back conditions, has increased 220 percent since 1990, the study authors said.

Research published in the Journal of American Medical Association in April 2010, for example, indicated that the use of complex surgical procedures such as spinal fusion to treat back pain had risen 15-fold over the prior six years despite the fact that the operations are riskier and not necessarily more effective.

Few studies, however, have focused solely on spinal fusion outcomes in worker's compensation patients, Nguyen said.

The findings, Nguyen added, are "very consistent with previous studies. The result we've provided is nothing new."

Most of the patients in Nguyen's study had degenerative disc disease, herniated discs or nerve root disease.

But the surgery may work well for those with other conditions, such as unstable spines, severe vertebral fractures, cancer or extremely herniated discs, Nguyen said.

Dr. Leah Y. Carreon, clinical research director of the Norton Leatherman Spine Center in Louisville, Ky., questioned whether the surgical group could be compared fairly to the non-surgical group since certain back conditions are more likely to respond to surgery than others.

"They're looking at the nebulous diagnosis of chronic low back pain, which is what we're trying to veer away from," Carreon said.

Carreon said she doesn't believe the two worker's compensation groups in the study are comparable.

"I'm not sure the amount of disability is the same for the non-surgical group as the surgical group," she said. "Despite the numbers [of participants], you'd think they would come up with a homogenous group, but I don't have any proof of that. They still did not come up with an apples-to-apples comparison."

Dr. E. Kano Mayer, a staff physician and physiatrist (rehabilitation physician) at the Cleveland Clinic for Spine Health, said he agrees with the study's conclusions and doesn't think the surgical patients had worse underlying disease or any other factors that led to their poorer outcomes.

The best treatment, he noted, would focus on physical therapy to increase flexibility and strength.

"Just like an injured athlete, the goal is to get them back to where they can do their job," Mayer said. "It's bad advice to rest afterward, so early activity and doing normal things seems to be how you get started and not let people go off the rails."

More information

Learn more about spinal fusion surgery from the U.S. National Library of Health.

SOURCES: Trang H. Nguyen, M.D., Ph.D., occupational medicine specialist, Cincinnati, Ohio; E. Kano Mayer, M.D., staff physician and physiatrist, Cleveland Clinic for Spine Health; Leah Y. Carreon, M.D., clinical research director, Norton Leatherman Spine Center, Louisville, Ky.; Feb. 15, 2011, Spine.


'/>"/>
Copyright©2010 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Chiropractor Springfield, VA - Dr. Todd P. Sullivan Announces The Addition of Spinal Decompression Therapy
2. Abington Surgeon First in Pennsylvania to Implant Investigative Device to Treat Leg Pain Caused by Spinal Stenosis
3. Womens Height Loss May Indicate Spinal Fracture
4. Height loss in postmenopausal women may indicate spinal fracture
5. Rhausler Announces Record Growth of Nearly 700% for its Spinal Implant Devices
6. Next decade offers promise for treatment of spinal cord injuries
7. Complex Spinal Operations Soar Despite Drawbacks
8. CT technique eliminates the need for X-rays in trauma patients with possible spinal fractures
9. Singapore Embraces Minimally Invasive Spinal Surgery
10. Spinal Surgery a Risk for Tiger
11. Dive Safely -- Or Risk Spinal Cord Damage
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:6/25/2016)... ... June 25, 2016 , ... Conventional wisdom preaches the ... In terms of the latter, setting the bar too high can result in disappointment, ... just slow progress toward their goal. , Research from PsychTests.com reveals ...
(Date:6/24/2016)... ... June 24, 2016 , ... Marcy was in a crisis. Her son James, eight, ... at his family verbally and physically. , “When something upset him, he couldn’t control his ... it. He would throw rocks at my other children and say he was going to ...
(Date:6/24/2016)... Diego, CA (PRWEB) , ... June 24, 2016 , ... ... with the American Cancer Society and the Road To Recovery® program to drive cancer ... to seniors and other adults to ensure the highest quality of life and ongoing ...
(Date:6/24/2016)... ... June 24, 2016 , ... ... to recognize Dr. Barry M. Weintraub as a prominent plastic surgeon and the ... in the world, and the most handsome men, look naturally attractive. Plastic surgery ...
(Date:6/24/2016)... ... ... Venture Construction Group (VCG) sponsors Luke’s Wings 5th Annual ... Country Club at 1201 Rockville Pike, Rockville, Maryland, 20852. The event raised funds ... been wounded in battle and their families. Venture Construction Group is a 2016 Silver ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:6/24/2016)... CLEMENTE, Calif. , June 24, 2016  American Respiratory Labs ... company, is now able to perform sophisticated lung assessments in patients, ... Technologies , Inc. Patients are no longer limited ... ndd,s EasyOne PRO ® , ARL patients like Jeanne R. of ... done in the comfort of her own home. ...
(Date:6/24/2016)... LEXINGTON, Mass. , June 24, 2016   ... specialty pharmaceutical company developing innovative inhaled drugs, announced today ... when Russell Investments reconstituted its comprehensive set ... 2016. "This is an important milestone for ... "It will increase shareholder awareness of our progress in ...
(Date:6/23/2016)... -- MedSource announced today that it has selected Datatrial,s ... choice.  This latest decision demonstrates MedSource,s commitment to ... by offering a state-of-the-art electronic data capture (EDC) ... the EDC platform of choice in exchange for ... long been a preferred EDC platform by our ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: