Navigation Links
Small increases in vaccine cost can cause large gaps in protection
Date:7/29/2010

CAMBRIDGE, Mass., July 29, 2010 -- Public immunization efforts may be much more sensitive than previously realized to small changes in the perceived costs or risks of vaccination, scientists at Harvard University report this week. In some cases, the spread of vaccine avoidance via social networks can make the difference between a minor, localized outbreak and an epidemic four times as large.

The finding, published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, comes amidst one of the worst pertussis outbreaks in 50 years, in which 1,500 Californians have contracted whooping cough. Public health officials have cited reduced vigilance in vaccinating against the disease, which sickens 90 percent of those exposed to it.

"People sometimes say that voluntary vaccination is doomed to fail because of the 'free-rider' problem, in which people assume they will be protected by other people's immunity," says co-author Daniel I. Rosenbloom, a graduate student in Harvard's Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, led by Martin A. Nowak. "We find that's not true, as a population of self-interested people can defeat an epidemic. But the trouble is, success is sensitive to small changes in perception of a vaccine's costs -- in terms of money, time, inconvenience, or perceived side effects."

Together with lead author Feng Fu, Rosenbloom and Nowak are the first researchers to incorporate epidemiological data into modeling of how vaccination spreads by imitation in a social network. They found that increasing vaccination cost prompts more free-riding and leads to larger epidemics.

"Herd immunity in a social network is fragile," says Fu, a postdoctoral researcher in mathematical biology at Harvard. "As public perceptions of vaccine side effects change, a population can rapidly switch from high vaccination and herd immunity to low vaccination and a larger epidemic."

The good news, the authors say, is that the sensitivity of vaccination to perceived costs cuts both ways, meaning it's easy to get a population back on track with voluntary immunizations in the wake of an outbreak.

The Harvard team found epidemics are amplified when individuals mimic others in their social network, such as by avoiding immunizations during vaccine scares. Behavior driven by "strong imitation" -- reliance on anecdotal information from social contacts in deciding whether or not to immunize -- could cause up to a 14 percent decline in vaccination rates, and a four-fold increase in the size of a flulike epidemic.

"It's possible to be too clever for your own good in dealing with risk," Fu says. "These 'strong imitators' chase unwise risks, and their behavior exacerbates the fragility of herd immunity, causing it to break down more easily. Those in our model who ignored friends' outcomes and stuck with their own decision ended up better off, on average."

Fu, Rosenbloom, and Nowak's modeling also showed that in an epidemic, individuals who are hubs in a social network are likelier to choose vaccination than their less connected peers. However, this outcome emerges primarily from self-interested behavior -- the desire to avoid sickness -- rather than altruistic behavior to protect friends and family.

"Altruistic behavior could certainly lead to increased vaccination of hubs, but we find that it's not required -- self-interested behavior suffices," Rosenbloom says.

This work builds upon the tradition of evolutionary game theory, where researchers construct simple mathematical models to explore human behavior in social dilemmas and scenarios where people can cooperate for the common good. While this study specifically modeled influenza, the results apply to a wide variety of diseases, and are consistent with data from past epidemics.


'/>"/>

Contact: Steve Bradt
steve_bradt@harvard.edu
617-496-8070
Harvard University
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Smaller hospitals can provide safe and high-quality surgical care comparable to larger counterparts
2. Small investment could save 11 million African lives
3. Sam's Club Tests Online Small Business Loan Program for Main Street
4. Sex With Recent Smallpox Vaccine Recipient Can Lead to Illness
5. Triad Web Design Ranked #23 on the Top 100 Small Businesses List by Business Leader Magazine
6. X-ISS Launches Free Online Disaster Recovery Planning Assessment Tools for Small Businesses
7. Small Supplement And Vitamin Manufacturers Must Meet FDA cGMP Requirements By The End Of The Month
8. Organic Clothing – Is Your Clothing Delivering Death in Small Doses?
9. A prognostic and predictive biomarker for nonsmall cell lung cancer
10. Dog Sniffs Out Prostate Cancer in Small Study
11. Comparision of overall survival for non-small cell lung cancer patients
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:3/27/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... March 27, 2017 , ... ... the organization behind the New England Journal of Medicine and NEJM Journal Watch, ... Knowledge+ Pediatrics Board Review was created by a panel of pediatricians from leading ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... ... 27, 2017 , ... Osteitis pubis may be commonplace and ... it occurs when the muscles around the pelvis become inflamed. Over time, untreated ... torso, as well as accompanying tenderness and weakness. Without proper intervention, it can ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... March 27, 2017 , ... ... announce that for a second year in a row; they are the recipient ... designers in the industry voted on the award at Design Connections 2017. Top ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... ... , ... The Anaheim Hills office accelerates and supports FNCC’s growth and further ... sales professionals over the past 6 months and is continuing to recruit new talent ... course of 2017. , “This new office is a direct result of our ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... ... 27, 2017 , ... Golden Triangle Emergency Center will be ... 3rd to commemorate the two-year anniversary of the facility. The event will feature ... great years while also familiarizing themselves with the facility. , In the two ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:3/27/2017)... 2017   Pulmatrix, Inc . (NASDAQ: PULM), a clinical ... pulmonary diseases, today announced that it has added two experts ... asthma to its Scientific Advisory Board . ... B. Moss , MD, former chief of the Pediatric Pulmonary ... Center at Stanford University, and David ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... YORK , March 27, 2017 ... colors as the NASDAQ Composite closed the trading session ... lower; and the S&P 500 was down 0.08%. US ... nine sectors finishing the day in green. Pre-market today, ... Wright Medical Group N.V. (NASDAQ: WMGI), Amedica Corporation (NASDAQ: ...
(Date:3/27/2017)... 2017  Impax Laboratories, Inc. (NASDAQ: IPXL)today announced that ... Bisaro as Impax,s President and Chief Executive Officer ... 27, 2017. Mr. Bisaro will succeed J. Kevin ... Chief Executive Officer since December of 2016. ... experience, Mr. Bisaro, 56, is an accomplished global business ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: