Navigation Links
Second Brain Death Exam Unnecessary, Study Finds
Date:12/15/2010

out 12 percent of patients declared brain dead had a cardiac arrest while waiting for the second exam or after the second exam, making them ineligible for organ donation, Lustbader added.

"We wanted to determine the accuracy of the first exam and determine if the second exam adds anything. The answer to that is an emphatic 'No,'" Lustbader said. "The second exam does not add anything and in fact, has several negatives or harmful effects, including prolonged anguish for families who are waiting to find out if their loved one is dead or alive."

The study is published in the Dec. 15 online issue of Neurology.

Though New York's health department requires two exams, elsewhere, neurologists are already moving away from two exams. The American Academy of Neurology's 2010 guidelines call for one, comprehensive exam done by an experienced and qualified physician. The exam includes a step-by-step checklist of some 25 tests and criteria that must be met before a person can be considered brain dead.

Dr. Gary Gronseth, a professor of neurology at the University of Kansas, said this is the right strategy.

More important than doing two exams is the waiting period between the time the person suffered the catastrophic injury that caused the brain death, determining the person is unlikely to ever regain consciousness and doing the first exam to make the official diagnosis.

"This insistence on the second exam has been a distraction from the main issue, which is selecting an appropriate observation period from the time of the catastrophic brain injury to the first exam," Gronseth said.

For example, the waiting period might be relatively shorter for someone who has devastating structural injury to the brain itself such as from a hemorrhage than the waiting time for someone who is brain dead due to other causes that aren't as obvious.

According to the study, lengthy waiting periods for the exam are also costly, with the extra day o
'/>"/>

Copyright©2010 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Secondhand Smoke May Put Kids at Risk for Diseases
2. New Drug, Pradaxa, May Prevent Second Stroke in Certain Heart Patients
3. Denser Breasts Raise Odds of Second Breast Cancer, Study Finds
4. Better marker for breast cancer may reduce need for second surgeries
5. Urgent steps needed to tackle inadequate support for women with secondary breast cancer
6. Radiation exposure poses similar risk of first and second cancers in atomic bomb survivors
7. Vitamin B May Not Guard Against Second Stroke, Heart Attack
8. Vanishing bile duct syndrome secondary to anti-retroviral therapy in HIV
9. Cambridge Healthtech Institute Announces its Second Annual "The Bioprocessing Summit"
10. TB Claims One Life Every 17 Seconds; Almost Two Million People Each Year
11. Second Ohio State cancer drug begins clinical trials testing
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Second Brain Death Exam Unnecessary, Study Finds
(Date:6/30/2015)... ... June 30, 2015 , ... Independence Day weekend is more than just fireworks ... kick off of July as National Hot Dog Month. Americans are expected to eat ... time of the year and enough to stretch from Washington D.C. to Los Angeles ...
(Date:6/30/2015)... ... June 30, 2015 , ... After more than ... Food and Drug Administration, GlobalSun (TM) — sunscreen specifically formulated for the unique skin ... rating of 35, hits the market just in time to help protect the skin ...
(Date:6/30/2015)... ... June 30, 2015 , ... ... ready-to-drink sponsor of two leading organizations dedicated to raising worldwide awareness of the ... I AM ADAPTIVE™ is now the official charity of FitAID. I AM ADAPTIVE ...
(Date:6/30/2015)... ... 2015 , ... The United Nations Foundation’s Universal Access Project, in partnership with ... Care Youth contest today. Why We Care Youth serves as a platform for young ... has personally meant to them, and why U.S. policymakers should care about expanding access ...
(Date:6/30/2015)... ... June 30, 2015 , ... iData Research ( ... a new reimbursement insurance policy tracking and analysis service. Reimbursement Tracker ™ ... and rate updates in real-time from hundreds of insurance companies covering over 60,000 ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Biggest Hot Dog Weekend of the Year to Kick Off National Hot Dog Month 2Health News:GlobalSun – The First Sunscreen Developed for All People of Color – Hits The Market 2Health News:LifeAID Beverage Company Partners With The Adaptive Movement 2Health News:LifeAID Beverage Company Partners With The Adaptive Movement 3Health News:UN Foundation, Planned Parenthood Federation of America & Sierra Club Launch Why We Care Youth to Amplify Young Voices on Critical Importance of International Reproductive Health and Contraception 2Health News:UN Foundation, Planned Parenthood Federation of America & Sierra Club Launch Why We Care Youth to Amplify Young Voices on Critical Importance of International Reproductive Health and Contraception 3Health News:UN Foundation, Planned Parenthood Federation of America & Sierra Club Launch Why We Care Youth to Amplify Young Voices on Critical Importance of International Reproductive Health and Contraception 4Health News:iData Research Introduces New Medical Insurance Reimbursement Policy & Rate Tracker Subscription Service 2
... Pain,Solutions, LLC (IPS), a wholly-owned subsidiary of ... announced that it has signed a national ... access to IPS, proprietary,provider network of pain ... call center will process patient appointments, originating,from ...
... Cardiovascular disease accounts,for 40 percent of all deaths ... combined. The best way to avoid cardiovascular diseases such ... leading cause of death in,America -- is to maintain ... http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20071025/NYTHFNS3 ) "The higher your blood ...
... Ala. Providing HIV combination antiretroviral drug therapy is key ... disease. , Letting nurses and other trained health care workers ... in short supply, is just as important to saving lives, ... at Birmingham (UAB). , Data for the study was gathered ...
... following statement was issued,today by the law firm of Schiffrin ... that a class action lawsuit was filed in the,United States ... all securities purchasers of Aetna Inc. (NYSE: AET ) ... 2006, inclusive (the,"Class Period"). If you wish to discuss ...
... Outcomes, Safety Concerns and,Interference with Doctors, Expertise as ... Leading oncologists from,across the country gathered in ... the new National Coverage Decision (NCD) for the ... for Medicare,patients. The meeting, which brought together approximately ...
... CARMEL, Ind., Oct. 24 Less complicated ... product, will come,as a welcome relief to Type ... over the complications of caring for the,disease and ... A recent study, conducted by researchers at University ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:IPS Secures National Contract to Deliver FOCUS Healthcare Provider Network Access to Pain Management Specialists 2Health News:IPS Secures National Contract to Deliver FOCUS Healthcare Provider Network Access to Pain Management Specialists 3Health News:IPS Secures National Contract to Deliver FOCUS Healthcare Provider Network Access to Pain Management Specialists 4Health News:Figure Skater Peggy Fleming Teams with HealthSaver: Heart Healthy Living 2Health News:Figure Skater Peggy Fleming Teams with HealthSaver: Heart Healthy Living 3Health News:Figure Skater Peggy Fleming Teams with HealthSaver: Heart Healthy Living 4Health News:Figure Skater Peggy Fleming Teams with HealthSaver: Heart Healthy Living 5Health News:JAMA study shows what works in treating HIV-infected African children 2Health News:Shareholder Class Action Filed Against Aetna Inc. by the Law Firm of Schiffrin Barroway Topaz & Kessler, LLP 2Health News:Shareholder Class Action Filed Against Aetna Inc. by the Law Firm of Schiffrin Barroway Topaz & Kessler, LLP 3Health News:Leading Oncologists from Across the Country Hold Emergency Meeting on New Government Reimbursement Policy for Medicare Patients with Cancer 2Health News:Leading Oncologists from Across the Country Hold Emergency Meeting on New Government Reimbursement Policy for Medicare Patients with Cancer 3Health News:New Nutraceutical Supplement Provides Simplified Approach to Diabetes Management Programs 2Health News:New Nutraceutical Supplement Provides Simplified Approach to Diabetes Management Programs 3
(Date:6/30/2015)... -- Today, UBM China, a wholly owned subsidiary of ... Exhibition Co., Ltd. to jointly run the Health Expo ... concurrently with CWMEE 2016. This cooperation ... MEDTEC China and DENTECH China, and fills its blank ... also another concrete cooperative project in Chengdu ...
(Date:6/30/2015)...  July 4 th is this weekend, a time ... and people behind it. To help honor our current nation,s ... USA Medical Card, a leading provider of free ... empower independence for our disabled military veterans, police, firemen, and ... their prescriptions. "Due to USA ...
(Date:6/30/2015)... TRIANGLE PARK, N.C. , June 30, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... and services to the life sciences industry, has been ... direct to patient shipment of clinical drug product in ... South Korea to continue receiving ... East Respiratory System (MERS). The emergency was ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:UBM Joins Chengdu Tianyi to Hold CWMEE 2016 2UBM Joins Chengdu Tianyi to Hold CWMEE 2016 3Hope For Heroes and USA Medical Card Make a Difference for Our Nation's Heroes 2Marken Delivers Direct To Patients During MERS Outbreak 2Marken Delivers Direct To Patients During MERS Outbreak 3
... July 12 Diplomat Specialty Pharmacy, the ... that Robert Fleckenstein has joined the ... the Company,s Vice President of Operations overseeing the ... Service Operations, Call Center, Oncology Department and other ...
... According to leading global business media company UBM International ... for CPhI South America 2010, the company,s world leading pharmaceutical ... at La Rural – Hall Ocre in Buenos ... first time by the ICSE pavilion, a dedicated area within ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Diplomat Specialty Pharmacy Hires Vice President of Operations 2Diplomat Specialty Pharmacy Hires Vice President of Operations 3Buenos Aires Welcomes CPhI South America 2010 2Buenos Aires Welcomes CPhI South America 2010 3
... D-Type can combine a number of ... microplates on a simple to use ... is a multifunctional stand-alone device but ... robotic systems. Custom and standard add-on ...
Grab one and go, One of the smallest handheld oximeters available, Datex-Ohmeda s TuffSat is the ideal spot-check solution for hospital, home care, transport, and EMS. TuffSat comes fully loaded wi...
Smith & Nephew's CDS System is developed exclusively for discography., Developed exclusively for discography, it is the first system designed to measure true disc pressure and record real-time proce...
The Maxi-Therm® lite hyper-hypothermia water blankets from Cincinnati Sub-Zero take conductive warming and cooling therapy to a new, softer level. These blankets are soft, lightweight, and remai...
Medicine Products: