Navigation Links
Risk assessment tool not reliable predictor for some women at high risk of breast cancer
Date:11/5/2008

ROCHESTER, Minn. -- A statistical model commonly used to predict the risk of breast cancer in women was not accurate when used to evaluate women with atypical hyperplasia, according to a new Mayo Clinic study published in the Oct. 14, 2008, issue of the Journal of Clinical Oncology. Atypical hyperplasia (atypia) describes breast tissue with an increased growth of abnormal cells that might become cancerous.

The Gail model calculates probabilities that a woman will develop invasive breast cancer during the next five years, and by age 90. The model has come to be called by the name of its developer, National Cancer Institute researcher Mitchell Gail, M.D., Ph.D. Its original purpose was to identify groups of high-risk women for participation in breast cancer chemoprevention studies. But the model has since been used in clinical settings to counsel individuals about their risk of developing breast cancer. Predicting risk at an individual level is much more challenging than when risks can be averaged across groups.

"The assumption has always been that this model works well in women with atypia, but this had never been validated," says Shane Pankratz, Ph.D., Mayo Clinic statistician and a lead investigator in the study. "We found that, for the group of women with atypia, the model predicted significantly fewer invasive breast cancers than were actually observed, and we also observed that the model was not able to reliably identify the women who were actually at higher risk of developing breast cancer."

The Gail model considers the woman's family history of breast cancer, her age, and her ages at the onset of menstruation and at first live birth, as well as the number of breast biopsies undergone and presence of atypical hyperplasia found in biopsies. About 5 percent of women who undergo biopsies for suspicious lumps or other breast concerns have atypia. About 25 percent of those with atypia will develop cancer within 25 years.

Mayo Clinic researchers tested the Gail model in 331 women with atypia who had benign breast biopsies at Mayo Clinic between 1967 and 1991. Of these women, 58 developed cancer during an average of 13.7 years of follow-up. In contrast, the model predicted that 34.9 women would develop breast cancer in that period.

Using these and other data, researchers also calculated the model's performance for individuals using the concordance statistic (c-statistic), which reflects how closely the actual timing of breast cancer events aligned with model predictions. A c-statistic of 0.5 is observed if the predictions are no better than random chance; a c-statistic of 1.0 is observed if the predictions are perfectly concordant with the actual outcomes. In this study, the c-statistic was 0.5, reflecting that the Gail model worked no better than a coin flip in predicting which of the women with atypia would develop invasive breast cancer.

When assessed across other groups of women without respect to the presence of atypia, the Gail model typically performs better. In that setting, it has been shown to predict approximately the same number of breast cancers that later occur.

Lynn Hartmann, M.D., Mayo Clinic oncologist and co-investigator on the study, says that there is strong interest in predicting breast cancer risk. For example, the Gail model, posted on the National Cancer Institute's Web site (http://www.cancer.gov/bcrisktool/), attracts 25,000 viewers each month.

"Doctors counsel women at high risk to have more frequent or intensive surveillance or to consider chemoprevention strategies such as tamoxifen or raloxifene," says Dr. Hartmann. "When making such decisions, women and their physicians must have highly reliable risk estimates."

Researchers are pursuing other avenues to better predict individual risk. Previously, Mayo Clinic researchers found that women with multiple sites of cellular atypia in a breast biopsy have significantly increased risk of developing breast cancer. In a study published earlier this year, Mayo researchers found that women whose atypia tissues express COX-2 enzymes were more likely to develop breast cancer, and the higher the COX-2 levels, the higher the risk.


'/>"/>

Contact: Karl Oestreich
newsbureau@mayo.edu
507-284-5005
Mayo Clinic
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. BioMarin Announces Initiation of Clinical Assessment Program for Morquio A Syndrome
2. Personality can hamper a physicians assessment of depression
3. Simple, inexpensive and objective tools for the assessment of mucosal inflammation: fecal markers
4. California Dental Association Foundation Launches New Dental Risk Assessment Campaign
5. Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on U.S. Department of Labors Risk Assessment Procedures Published in Federal Register
6. DIA Conference to Provide New Paradigms in Evidence-Based Medicine and Health Technology Assessment
7. Risk assessment plays key role in long-term treatment of breast cancer
8. InfoLogix Launches Strategic Mobility Assessment Service for Hospitals
9. The Supports Intensity Scale Assessment Can be Used to Build Robust Funding Methods for Developmental Disability Services, New Research Reveals
10. Fox Learning Systems Selects Prymaks Discovery-180(TM) Technology Assessment to Guide Search for New LMS
11. Combined Insurance Provides Needs Assessment Checklist to Help Consumers Evaluate Their Current Supplemental Health Insurance Coverage
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/11/2016)... ... February 11, 2016 , ... Student-doctors from Western University of ... Program Tuesday, February 9, taking one of the final steps in their medical ... positions across the country. Of the 103 student-doctors who comprise the College of ...
(Date:2/11/2016)... , ... February 11, 2016 , ... Florida Hospital presents ... take on the St. Louis Blues at the Amalie Arena. The puck drops at ... walk-through heart exhibit, the MEGA Heart, prior to the game. The MEGA Heart will ...
(Date:2/11/2016)... ... February 11, 2016 , ... The president released a ... Health System but would shift more of the cost burden to military beneficiaries. ... laid out in the defense budget as including limited quantifiable benefit fixes mixed with ...
(Date:2/11/2016)... Petersburg, FL (PRWEB) , ... February 11, 2016 ... ... providers and advocates will discuss how to improve care by making data on ... pediatric heart disease. The Summit on Transparency and Public Reporting of Pediatric and ...
(Date:2/11/2016)... ... February 11, 2016 , ... Atlantic Information Services, ... Benefit Model: A Case Study for Plans and Purchasers.” Executives from Intel Corp. ... with Intel on value-based health benefits program Connected Care, will discuss the challenges ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/11/2016)...  Community pharmacists can help improve medication adherence and ... a custom-built medication synchronization program, Cardinal Health MedSync Advantage™. ... Schieber Family Pharmacy in Circleville, ... patients enrolled in this medication synchronization program, which is ... the patient, and it,s a win for us because ...
(Date:2/11/2016)... , Feb. 11, 2016  Delcath Systems, Inc. ... medical device company focused on oncology with an ... liver cancers, announces the engagement of Lars ... Global Medical Consultant. Dr. Birgerson will provide strategic ... clinical operations team to help ensure timely facilitation ...
(Date:2/11/2016)... Scientists from Silicon Biosystems Menarini today ... door to genetic analysis of previously preserved tumor ... isolate with 100 percent purity. Utilizing the com­pany,s ... various stages of development, the researchers were able ... are clinically relevant, and may change the way ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: