Navigation Links
Rhetoric, framing efforts have little influence in same-sex marriage debate
Date:8/16/2010

ATLANTA -- A study by Indiana University researchers found that terminology and efforts to frame an issue -- often effective in influencing public opinion -- have no effect on public opinion concerning the ongoing debate in the U.S. over legalizing same-sex marriage.

Using an experimental approach involving a nationally representative sample, the researchers found that beliefs and values held sway, not rhetoric, such as the use of 'same-sex couple' instead of 'homosexual couple' or using the term 'civil rights' instead of 'gay rights.'

"Framing, wording doesn't matter," said Oren Pizmony-Levy, a doctoral student in IU's Department of Sociology. He discussed the study on Monday at the American Sociological Association 2010 Annual Meeting. "We need to stop trying to change the rhetoric and focus on the important issues, such as the benefits that children in same-sex families gain from the legalization of same-sex marriage."

About the study: The researchers embedded their unique experiment -- the first of its kind -- in the 2009 Survey of American Social Policy Attitudes, designed by IU sociology professor Clem Brooks. The survey, which involved more than 1,400 respondents, included one of six versions of the question: "Should homosexual couples have the right to marry one another?" To test for framing effects, they manipulated the question by using different words to describe supporters of legalized same-sex marriage, using 'civil rights activist,' 'gay rights activist' or 'some people.' They also varied the term used for describing the social category of those who are subject of the debate, using 'homosexual couples' and 'same-sex couples.' Different versions of the question were randomly assigned to participants in the survey. A counter statement, "Family values activists argue that only heterosexual couples should have the right to marry," appeared before the question. Pizmony-Levy said this is the first academic study with a national representative sample that tests whether frames and terminology used by interest groups on both sides of the debate really influence public opinion on this issue. The results apply to the same-sex marriage debate, however, and cannot be generalized to other issues involving sexual minorities. In the debate about whether gays and lesbians should be able to serve in the military, for example, terminology and framing have been shown to be influential.

Co-author Aaron Ponce, also a doctoral student in the Department of Sociology, said the findings are particularly interesting in light of the recent Proposition 8 decision in California. While certain frames don't matter when it comes to public opinion about same-sex marriage, because beliefs and values tend to be strong, framing might matter when used in courts of law.

"Justice Walker framed the same-sex marriage issue as a failure of due process, that is, as the abridgment of a fundamental right for same-sex partners to marry," Ponce said. "The way this issue has been framed may have repercussions for how the case is heard on appeal in higher courts. The question then becomes whether same-sex marriage frames function differently in the context of law and justice than they do with public opinion."


'/>"/>

Contact: Daniel Fowler
fowler@asanet.org
202-527-7885
American Sociological Association
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Secretary Clintons Approach to Development: Good Rhetoric, Little Action?
2. Framingham Public School District Selects Aerohive for its Next Generation Wireless Network
3. The Framingham Heart Study -- global impact, ongoing influence
4. Actor and Humanitarian Harrison Ford Assists Operation Smiles Relief Efforts in Haiti
5. Reliv Foundation Donates $450,000 In Nutritional Supplements to Haitian Relief Efforts
6. Businesses Rally Big Efforts to Benefit the Susan G. Komen Phoenix Affiliates Fight Against Breast Cancer
7. Lighthouse To Help Relief Efforts In Haiti
8. JPMA Supports CPSC Chairman Tenenbaum's Continued Safety Efforts
9. ChildCare Education Institute Supports the First Ladys Efforts to Reduce Childhood Obesity
10. Buildium Announces Fundraising Campaign to Benefit Haiti Relief Efforts
11. Having Prediabetes May Not Kick-Start Prevention Efforts
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:1/21/2017)... ... 21, 2017 , ... Salveo for life, a company that distributes an effervescent ... United States as part of its presence to expand its market reach. , Using ... the productions of nasty toxins as a result of drinking alcohol, eliminating those toxins ...
(Date:1/21/2017)... ... 21, 2017 , ... Northern California Medical Associates (NCMA) is ... multi-specialty medical group. The dermatology practice provides general dermatologic treatment, outpatient surgery, clinical ... this excellent dermatology practice to our group’s medical services,” explains NCMA CEO, Ruth ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... ... ... A new partnership between Goodwill® and Roadie, Inc. aims to make it easier ... couches to dressers and bicycles. Roadie — the national on-the-way delivery network — will ... through February 28th. , “January is an exciting time when resolutions are made ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... ... , ... Lice Troopers, the lice removal company based in South Florida, has ... holiday season. , “It happens every year around this time,” says owner, Arie ... which is the head-to-head gateway that lice need to spread.” , As children return ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... ... January 20, 2017 , ... Vitamin Well ... VW+ 002. The drinks have been produced in collaboration with Zlatan Ibrahimovic and ... your workout. , After a successful launch in Sweden last year, the next ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/19/2017)... , Jan. 19, 2017 Conference Call and Webcast ... VNDA ) today announced it will release results for the fourth ... closes. ... will host a conference call at 4:30 PM ET on Wednesday, ... and full year 2016 financial results and other corporate activities. To ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... LONDON , January 19, 2017 Incretin ... Sympathomimetics and Others The global anti-obesity drugs ... the first half of the forecast period and CAGR of 38.7% ... expected to grow at a CAGR of 32.8% from 2016 to ... million in 2021, and $24,063 million in 2027. ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... BOCA RATON, Fla. , Jan. 19, 2017 ... ), a medical device company specializing in the ... conditions, such as keloids, with superficial radiation therapy, ... quarter and full year 2016 financial results on Thursday, ... The Company will hold a conference call ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: