Navigation Links
Returning genetic incidental findings without patient consent violates basic rights
Date:5/17/2013

MINNEAPOLIS/ST. PAUL (05/15/2012)Informed consent is the backbone of patient care. Genetic testing has long required patient consent and patients have had a "right not to know" the results. However, as 21st century medicine now begins to use the tools of genome sequencing, an enormous debate has erupted over whether patients' rights will continue in an era of medical genomics.

Recent recommendations from the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) suggest no. On March 22, the ACMG released recommendations stating that when clinical sequencing is undertaken for any medical reason, laboratories must examine 57 other specific genes to look for incidental findings. These findings must then be reported to the clinician and the patient. In an April 25 "clarification," ACMG said that failure to report these findings would be considered "unethical." The patient has no opportunity to opt-out of the testing of the 57 genes, except to decline all sequencing. The recommendations also apply to children.

In a paper to be published in 'Science 'May 16 online ahead of print, authors Susan M. Wolf, J.D. (University of Minnesota), George J. Annas, J.D., M.P.H. (Boston University), and Sherman Elias, M.D. (Northwestern University) push back against these recommendations, and offer compelling reasons why patient autonomy must remain firmly in place as science advances. Their article on Patient Autonomy and Incidental Findings in Clinical Genomics urges ACMG to reconsider their recommendations. This article is published with a reply by Amy McGuire, J.D., Ph.D. (Baylor College of Medicine) and colleagues.

Wolf, Annas, and Elias argue that, "The ACMG's 'minimum list [of 57 genes]' includes mutations in genes that patients have long been able to refuse testing for, including cancer risk mutations (such as BRCA1) and cardiovascular risk mutations." They point out that "There are many circumstances in which a patient may decline su
'/>"/>

Contact: Martha Coventry
coven002@umn.edu
612-625-2948
University of Minnesota
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Coffee may help prevent breast cancer returning, study finds
2. AuDNet Pushes for Professional Hearing Tests for All Troops Returning from the Middle East.
3. XRMD: Beyond AREDS2: Vision Improvement using Hormones, Genetics, Methylation, Nutrition and Anti-Oxidative Therapy
4. The developmental genetics of space and time
5. GB HealthWatch Links Genetic Makeup, Omega-6 and Nuts
6. Scientists Discover More Genetic Clues to Testicular Cancer
7. UCLA stem cell researchers move toward treatment for rare genetic nerve disease
8. Champion of Genetics funding to Ottawa researcher
9. Ottawa researcher named 2013 Champion of Genetics
10. Genetic variations associated with susceptibility to bacteria linked to stomach disorders
11. Research Suggests that Lack of Exercise Drive is Genetic, Making Energy Enhancing Supplements Like Prescopodene Beneficial For Sticking to Your Exercise Routine
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/17/2014)... 2014 (HealthDay News) -- Social networking sites can help ... For people who are obese, sites like Twitter and ... support from doctors as well as peers, researchers found. ... methods is that it offers the potential to be ... when compared to traditional approaches," the study,s lead author, ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... September 17, 2014 The Oliver Law ... infections allegedly caused by Non-Sterile Other-Sonic Ultrasound Transmission ... about their options for legal recourse. Other-Sonic ultrasound gel ... (FDA) in March 2012, after the product was linked ... William Beaumont Hospital in Royal Oak, Michigan . While ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... 2014 Catalent Pharma Solutions, the ... development solutions for drugs, biologics and consumer health ... integrated service and technology offer based on the ... the company’s 450,000 sq. ft. Kansas City, MO ... integrate optimal formulation, development, analytical expertise, scale up ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... -- A blood test that measures DNA from a ... assessment of the state of a man,s disease, a ... blood test could reveal when treatment for advanced ... growth, the researchers suggested. "Our study showed that ... cancer and often initially very effective started to activate ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... R.I. [Brown University] As Congress adjourns this month ... senators will step over on their way out the ... Repeal and Medicare Provider Payment Modernization Act of 2014. ... Surgery , Dr. Eli Adashi recounts what he and ... bipartisan bill. The perennial trouble with how Medicare pays ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Social Networking Sites Can Help Obese Lose Weight: Study 2Health News:Victims of Pseudomonas Infections Allegedly Caused by Other-Sonic Ultrasound Transmission Gel Face Statute of Limitations, Reports The Oliver Law Group P.C. 2Health News:Victims of Pseudomonas Infections Allegedly Caused by Other-Sonic Ultrasound Transmission Gel Face Statute of Limitations, Reports The Oliver Law Group P.C. 3Health News:Victims of Pseudomonas Infections Allegedly Caused by Other-Sonic Ultrasound Transmission Gel Face Statute of Limitations, Reports The Oliver Law Group P.C. 4Health News:New OptiPact™ Technology Introduced by Catalent 2Health News:DNA Blood Test Might Identify Status of Prostate Cancer 2Health News:Failed Medicare payments law remains relevant 2Health News:Failed Medicare payments law remains relevant 3
... ... Enter Three Year GPO Agreement , ... Wichita, KS (PRWEB) October 26, 2009 -- MedAppz, a leading provider ... Chain Systems, today announced a multiyear agreement to offer EHR software as a service ...
... Disproportionate impact ... is ticking for tens of thousands of heart patients in rural America as a looming ... cardiac care. , ... MI (PRWEB) October 26, 2009 -- The clock is ticking for tens of thousands of ...
... 26, 2009 A discovery by scientists at the Oklahoma ... injuries like those sustained in car crashes or on the ... diseases and diabetes. In a paper published online today ... Medicine , OMRF researcher Charles Esmon, Ph.D., with co-authors Florea ...
... are of particular note in today,s Scientific Program ... of Ophthalmology (AAO) and the Pan-American Association of Ophthalmology ... exam clues that should make ophthalmologists suspect an atypical ... Singapore National Eye Center study that diabetics who are ...
... suggests they,re more susceptible to dangers of tobacco , SUNDAY, ... than men to the carcinogens and other noxious substances in ... one study of nearly 700 people with lung cancer, Swiss ... received the diagnosis, even though they smoked less than the ...
... Oct. 24, 2009 Born with a retinal disease that ... sightless, the nine-year-old boy used to sit in the back ... electronic screen and assisted by teacher aides. Now, after a ... back of his eye, he sits in front with classmates ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:MedAppz Signs Agreement with MedAssets to Offer SAAS-based Electronic Health Record to MedAssets' Non-acute Customers 2Health News:Cardiac Patients Across Rural America Risk Losing Access to Nearby Care as Federal Agency Considers Cuts this Week 2Health News:Cardiac Patients Across Rural America Risk Losing Access to Nearby Care as Federal Agency Considers Cuts this Week 3Health News:Oklahoma scientists discover promising new path for treating traumas 2Health News:Clues to visual variant Alzheimer's; myopia and diabetic retinopathy risk 2Health News:Clues to visual variant Alzheimer's; myopia and diabetic retinopathy risk 3Health News:Is Smoking Tougher on Women? 2Health News:Is Smoking Tougher on Women? 3Health News:1 shot of gene therapy and children with congenital blindness can now see 2Health News:1 shot of gene therapy and children with congenital blindness can now see 3Health News:1 shot of gene therapy and children with congenital blindness can now see 4Health News:1 shot of gene therapy and children with congenital blindness can now see 5
(Date:9/17/2014)... Brazil Gynecological Devices Market ... GlobalData,s new report, "Brazil Gynecological Devices Market ... the Brazil Gynecological Devices market. The report provides ... units) and average prices (in US dollars) within ... Devices (Micro-inserts) and Mechanical Sterilization Devices (Tubal Clips ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... , Sept. 17, 2014 The ... the last decade due to the recession, ... and technological advancements. This BCC Research report ... segments of the ambulance and emergency medical ... blood and hemorrhage control devices, equipment used ...
(Date:9/17/2014)... MONICA, Calif. , Sept. 17, 2014  Dr. ... is at the White House today for National Recovery ... 46 that consumer advocates released today. Consumer advocates were ... woman who spoke out after losing her fiancée ... discovering that the doctor had a history of crack ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Brazil Gynecological Devices Market Outlook to 2020 2Brazil Gynecological Devices Market Outlook to 2020 3Ambulance and Emergency Equipment: Global Markets 2Ambulance and Emergency Equipment: Global Markets 3Ambulance and Emergency Equipment: Global Markets 4Doctor Recovering From 100-Pill-A-Day Addiction Stars In New Ad Supporting Prop 46; Appears At White House for National Recovery Month, Says Consumer Watchdog Campaign 2Doctor Recovering From 100-Pill-A-Day Addiction Stars In New Ad Supporting Prop 46; Appears At White House for National Recovery Month, Says Consumer Watchdog Campaign 3
... 26, 2011 Idenix Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (NASDAQ: IDIX ... overview at the Jefferies 2011 Global Healthcare Conference on June ... The live and archived webcast of the company ... Idenix Investor Center at www.idenix.com . Please log in ...
... A new prostate cancer study published ... treatment to "watchful waiting" revealed important findings for ... debating their treatment options. (Photo:   http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20110526/NY09899 ... clinical options for early prostate cancer treatment today ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Robotic Prostatectomy Expert Dr. David Samadi on a High Impact Study Advocating Aggressive Early-Stage Prostate Cancer Treatment 2Robotic Prostatectomy Expert Dr. David Samadi on a High Impact Study Advocating Aggressive Early-Stage Prostate Cancer Treatment 3
EPS 3501 : 3500 V, 150 mA, 100 W maximum. Constant voltage, constant current, or constant power modes. Stores and recalls three protocols. Excellent for manual DNA sequencing and IEF applications....
... power supply, with temperature probe, 100-120 and 220-240 ... 500 mA, and 400 W. The temperature probe ... and 90 degrees C during electrophoresis. Built-in infrared ... and instructions are provided. Dimensions are 27.5 x ...
... SPECIFICATIONS Form: Granular, free flowing powder EEO(-m r ): ... (3%): less than or equal to 31C Remelt ... Gel Strength (3%): greater than or equal to 500 ... equal to 1000 gm/cm 2 Moisture: less than ...
... chloride (Cl) ≤ 500 mg/kg sulfate (SO 4 ) ... Cd ≤ 5 mg/kg Co ≤ 5 mg/kg Cr ... 10 mg/kg K ≤ 50 mg/kg Mg ≤ 50 ... Ni ≤ 5 mg/kg Pb ≤ 5 mg/kg Zn ...
Medicine Products: