Navigation Links
Returning genetic incidental findings without patient consent violates basic rights
Date:5/17/2013

MINNEAPOLIS/ST. PAUL (05/15/2012)Informed consent is the backbone of patient care. Genetic testing has long required patient consent and patients have had a "right not to know" the results. However, as 21st century medicine now begins to use the tools of genome sequencing, an enormous debate has erupted over whether patients' rights will continue in an era of medical genomics.

Recent recommendations from the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) suggest no. On March 22, the ACMG released recommendations stating that when clinical sequencing is undertaken for any medical reason, laboratories must examine 57 other specific genes to look for incidental findings. These findings must then be reported to the clinician and the patient. In an April 25 "clarification," ACMG said that failure to report these findings would be considered "unethical." The patient has no opportunity to opt-out of the testing of the 57 genes, except to decline all sequencing. The recommendations also apply to children.

In a paper to be published in 'Science 'May 16 online ahead of print, authors Susan M. Wolf, J.D. (University of Minnesota), George J. Annas, J.D., M.P.H. (Boston University), and Sherman Elias, M.D. (Northwestern University) push back against these recommendations, and offer compelling reasons why patient autonomy must remain firmly in place as science advances. Their article on Patient Autonomy and Incidental Findings in Clinical Genomics urges ACMG to reconsider their recommendations. This article is published with a reply by Amy McGuire, J.D., Ph.D. (Baylor College of Medicine) and colleagues.

Wolf, Annas, and Elias argue that, "The ACMG's 'minimum list [of 57 genes]' includes mutations in genes that patients have long been able to refuse testing for, including cancer risk mutations (such as BRCA1) and cardiovascular risk mutations." They point out that "There are many circumstances in which a patient may decline such testing and information, even if the results could open avenues for intervention. The patient may already be battling another disease, such as advanced cancer, or be late in life and see more burden than benefit in added genetic information. The patient may also fear that 'extra' results in their medical record will invite risk of discrimination."

ACMG says that applying these recommendations to children may help adult family members understand their own health risks. However, Wolf et al. point out that "this is exactly what past recommendations have rightly rejected, in limiting genetic testing and disclosure of genetic information to what is medically necessary during childhood." The authors cite long-standing policy discouraging childhood testing for adult-onset conditions. "Delaying testing and return of genetic information not medically useful in childhood allows the child to reach adulthood and then make a choice based on his or her own values."

The ACMG indicates that their list of genes to test without consent will grow. Their report says that laboratories may look for variants in other genes, "as deemed appropriate," and that ACMG will review the roster of 57 genes annually. Wolf et al. voice concern that "As the list expands, so will the scope of testing without consent." The authors urge the importance of patients' rights, especially in an era of genome sequencing when extensive genetic information can be generated on any patient.


'/>"/>

Contact: Martha Coventry
coven002@umn.edu
612-625-2948
University of Minnesota
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Coffee may help prevent breast cancer returning, study finds
2. AuDNet Pushes for Professional Hearing Tests for All Troops Returning from the Middle East.
3. XRMD: Beyond AREDS2: Vision Improvement using Hormones, Genetics, Methylation, Nutrition and Anti-Oxidative Therapy
4. The developmental genetics of space and time
5. GB HealthWatch Links Genetic Makeup, Omega-6 and Nuts
6. Scientists Discover More Genetic Clues to Testicular Cancer
7. UCLA stem cell researchers move toward treatment for rare genetic nerve disease
8. Champion of Genetics funding to Ottawa researcher
9. Ottawa researcher named 2013 Champion of Genetics
10. Genetic variations associated with susceptibility to bacteria linked to stomach disorders
11. Research Suggests that Lack of Exercise Drive is Genetic, Making Energy Enhancing Supplements Like Prescopodene Beneficial For Sticking to Your Exercise Routine
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/23/2017)... ... August 23, 2017 , ... TSC Advantage has been ... Risk Management Solution Innovations and Security Solution for Government Innovations. Both gold awards ... and its DHS SAFETY Act-designated enterprise security assessment approach. , The ninth annual ...
(Date:8/23/2017)... ... August 23, 2017 , ... The non-profit ... holding an inaugural State of the Science Symposium in partnership with the Global ... 2017. , This symposium provides a forum for global leaders in human nutrition ...
(Date:8/22/2017)... ... August 22, 2017 , ... The Women’s Choice Award, a ... Migraine Relief with the 2017 Women’s Choice Award. The identification by women of an ... out of 4 migraine sufferers are women. In a survey taken by the Women’s ...
(Date:8/22/2017)... ... August 22, 2017 , ... Western ... spoke at a popular international aesthetics conference for medical professionals about the positive ... patients’ health and his growing practice. , Dr. George K. Ibrahim ...
(Date:8/22/2017)... ... August 22, 2017 , ... Each of the past six years, Lightning Labels has sent ... these labels and stickers, demonstrating the variety and creativity of their designs. Submissions this year ... came in. Now, it's time to announce the winners of the sixth annual Photo Contest, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:8/7/2017)... Diplomat Pharmacy, Inc. (NYSE: DPLO ) ... president, effective Aug. 7, 2017. ... other interests and will serve as president emeritus during a ... us in multiple leadership roles since he joined Diplomat with ... has provided decisive, strategic leadership which continues to benefit our ...
(Date:8/7/2017)... , Aug. 7, 2017  Endo International plc (NASDAQ: ... agreements to resolve virtually all known U.S. mesh product ... to resolve the known remaining U.S. claims at reasonable ... beginning in the fourth quarter of 2017 and continuing ... its second quarter 2017 results, the Company intends to ...
(Date:8/4/2017)... 3, 2017  Agragen, LLC, a ... the biopharmaceutical, nutraceutical, and aquacultural feed sectors, announces ... lead drug candidates, AGR131.  This drug is designed ... the blood of patients suffering from inflammatory conditions ... disease. Biological ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: