Navigation Links
Research: NCAA football exploits players in 'invisible labor market'
Date:8/23/2012

CHAMPAIGN, Ill. College football exploits players in an "invisible labor market," and the only plausible way for student-athletes to address their interests is the credible threat of unionization, according to research from a University of Illinois expert in labor relations and collective bargaining in athletics.

Since traditional collective bargaining is impractical for student-athletes, an "invisible union," derived from what labor scholars call the "union substitution effect," could be a viable way to circumnavigate the amateur-professional boundary that has become increasingly blurry in the multi-billion-dollar sport, says Michael LeRoy, a professor of law and of labor and employment relations at Illinois.

"College football players participate in an invisible labor market, meaning that the NCAA monopolizes their services by strictly limiting and allocating the labor force needed to play competitive games," he said. "So without a credible threat of unionization by student-athletes, the NCAA has no reason to confront the fact that it is professionalizing college football."

Although the NCAA's contractual relationship with student-athletes provide grant-in-aid scholarships, it's also a model premised on the belief that players are amateurs a view that's hard to square with the heavy commercialization of NCAA football, including a new championship series that will generate a new and immense revenue stream, LeRoy says.

"While schools reap billions of dollars from TV and licensing agreements, championship tournaments, bowl games and ticket sales, players rarely receive enough aid to pay in full the cost of attending school," he said. "And when TV deals coordinate NCAA and NFL schedules from August through January to minimize competition and maximize revenues, it is also hard not to conclude that Division I college football players are in the same product market as their professional counterparts."

While the NCAA recently attempted to adopt reforms that would address some of the problems identified in LeRoy's study, its board of trustees ultimately quashed any efforts to implement change.

"What that means is that players have no voice in their welfare," LeRoy said. "These Saturday heroes are solely dependent on a monopoly to enact regulations for their welfare. This is the impetus for proposing collective bargaining for college football players."

According to the study, college football players have a right to collective bargaining because they function like employees.

"Student-athletes generate great wealth for institutions but share in very little of it," LeRoy said. "Additionally, they are subject to non-negotiable, one-sided agreements imposed by a monopoly. They receive less than a four-year scholarship; pay out-of-pocket or borrow money for scholarship shortfalls; and are penalized for transferring to other schools. They also happen to play in a violent sport that causes serious injury on rare occasions, death but are usually disqualified from worker's compensation and are uninsured for long-term medical disabilities. And, of course, many student-athletes exhaust their eligibility without earning a degree."

LeRoy's study proposes a unique and limited form of collective bargaining customized for college football, one that does not involve wage negotiations or strikes, but draws from existing labor laws for public safety employees that prohibit strikes but allow final offer arbitration on a limited range of bargaining subjects.

"My concept stems from the fact that NCAA football differs significantly from the NFL model because college football players are bona fide student-athletes who must adhere to the tenets of amateurism," he said.

According to the study, the mere threat of college football player unionizing would produce a "union substitution effect," whereby employers respond to credible threats of collective action by providing participants with more of a say in their interests and better financial treatment.

"The status quo is ripe for change because the NCAA is an immense monopoly that generates new revenue quickly but reforms itself slowly," he said. "An invisible union is a plausible middle-ground approach to address the interests of student-athletes. Without a credible threat of unionization, schools have little incentive to concede that they are essentially professionalizing college football."


'/>"/>

Contact: Phil Ciciora
pciciora@illinois.edu
217-333-2177
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Source:Eurekalert  

Related medicine news :

1. Breast stem-cell research: Receptor teamwork is required and a new pathway may be involved
2. BioMed Central presents Challenges in Malaria Research: Progress Towards Elimination
3. Football-related catastrophic brain injuries on the rise
4. Football helmet sensors help researchers demystify concussion in young athletes
5. Catastrophic Head Injuries to High School Football Players Rising
6. Surge Seen in Concussions Among College Football Players
7. Therapy exploits addiction of leukemia cells
8. Ex-Players Sue NFL Over Brain Injuries
9. Study of Retired NFL Players Finds Evidence of Brain Damage
10. Concussions affect college players at high rates too, study says
11. Teaching Young Hockey Players to Body Check Doesnt Cut Injury Risk
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Research: NCAA football exploits players in 'invisible labor market'
(Date:5/24/2017)... ... ... Dr. Manju R. Kejriwal, a leading Ohio dentist, is now welcoming new ... Dr. Kejriwal understands the emotional and financial toll traditional orthodontics can take on patients’ ... longer need to feel the esthetic effects of wires and brackets when they can ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... ... May 24, 2017 , ... ... female reproductive tract in which the endometrial lining of the uterus spreads ... and pain. Patients experiencing painful intercourse, painful periods, pelvic pain, or irregular ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... , ... May 24, 2017 , ... Rob Lowe is ... “Informed,” developed for Public Television. “Informed” brings the public important topics from all aspects ... treatment of the feet and issues surrounding feet and ankles. , Podiatry is essential ...
(Date:5/23/2017)... ... May 23, 2017 , ... MDLand International (MDLand), a leading ... that its iClinic V12.2 solution has achieved approval from National Center for Quality ... 2017 standards which emphasize team-based care with a significant focus on the care ...
(Date:5/23/2017)... ... , ... New England Journal Of Medicine Confirms Viability of Rory’s Regulations and ... Staunton Foundation Calls on Health & Human Services, Tom Price to Adopt Rory’s Regulations ... today reported on a new study released on May 21, 2017 in the New ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/22/2017)... MAITLAND, Fla. , May 22, 2017 /PRNewswire/ ... industry as a whole continue to make the ... evidence becomes increasingly important for ensuring positive patient ... Key industry stakeholders are shifting focus away from ... results and effects of long-term specialty drug therapy ...
(Date:5/15/2017)... May 15, 2017  Amy Baxter MD, chief executive ... in noninvasive pain relief, was awarded a 2017 Top ... Baxter was recognized at the MM&M Top 40 Healthcare ... City on May 10, 2017. The dinner ... industry go "beyond the pill."  "Innovation goes ...
(Date:5/11/2017)... , May 11, 2017  Thornhill Research Inc. ... been awarded an $8,049,024 USD five-year, firm-fixed-priced, indefinite-quantity/indefinite-delivery ... the Canadian Commercial Corporation (CCC) ( Ottawa, ... Systems to administer general anesthesia to patients requiring ... "The US Marine Corps have been a ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: