Navigation Links
Report Claims Clinical Trials Miss Many Populations

Women, elderly, minorities among those routinely excluded or under-represented, researchers say

TUESDAY, April 1 (HealthDay News) -- A new analysis of the American clinical trial process suggests that the system for testing new drugs has routinely excluded or under-represented women, older people, minorities, disabled individuals and rural populations for decades.

"We've got a big problem," said Daniel S. Goldberg, chief policy adviser for the report. "And it's extremely urgent that we fix it. Because we're trying to figure out how to streamline health care and make people healthy, of course. And the fact that we have under-representation in clinical trials undermines both of these goals and undermines the quality of the evidence we come up with."

The report was conducted by the Chronic Disease Prevention & Control Research Center at Baylor College of Medicine in conjunction with the Intercultural Cancer Council, both based in Houston.

Part of a team of more than 300 analysts led by Armin D. Weinberg, Goldberg and his colleagues spent four years conducting an in-depth review of policy positions held by public, private and nonprofit clinical trial sponsors in the United States. Their research was funded by what is described as an "unrestricted educational grant" provided by Genentech Inc.

The team noted that about 80,000 clinical trials are conducted in this country each year, and that less than 1 percent of the American population -- 2.3 million men and women -- participate in such trials.

Additional trial problems, such as the lack of adequate training for members of institutional review boards, who are legally obligated to assess the structure of a proposed trial, were cited.

The report also admonished against the wasting of limited resources that results when government institutions and private industry duplicate each other's efforts in conducting trials focused on the same disease or treatment.

However, it is the continuing absence of specific constituencies in many trial populations that gets the lion's share of the criticism.

The research looked at cancer clinical trials and found that only 25 percent of patients in such trials were over the age of 65. In addition, older people were often excluded from studies focused on Alzheimer's, arthritis and incontinence, the researchers noted.

As evidence of the problem, Weinberg and his colleagues honed in on a study of clinical trial composition that found that, between 1995 and 1999, blacks, Asian-Pacific Islanders, Hispanics and Native Americans together made up for less than 10 percent of patients included in new cancer drug trials.

Under-representation of this sort, they say, leads to results that do not account for a host of factors -- genetic, cultural, racial, religious, linguistic, as well as variables related to age and gender -- that could have a huge impact on how well new drugs do in the real world.

To address these shortcomings, the team proposed nine policy solutions:

  • government regulatory changes;
  • increased collaboration between government and private industry on clinical trial design;
  • increased community involvement in patient participation;
  • scientific journal oversight of patient breakdowns;
  • new, specialized training for review boards;
  • reallocation of research funding to avoid duplication and address disparities;
  • increased public education;
  • increased focus on easing the patient participation process;
  • guaranteeing insurance coverage for all related costs.

"The bottom line is there has been a lot of discussion and attention paid in recent years to how clinical trials are put together, and, in particular, the need to account for differences in study patient populations," said Weinberg. "And that's the good news. But the bad news is that as a practical matter, it has yet to have a real impact on studies themselves."

"And the problem is that many people, when they take a pill, don't realize that it didn't come out of thin air," added Weinberg. "So, we hope that our work will help people appreciate how the process works, and that what we're talking about is the next generation and how we improve the products and type of therapies that we will have in the future."

Adil Shamoo, a professor of biochemistry and bioethics at the University of Maryland School of Medicine in Baltimore, agreed that trials must ensure proper patient representation. And he stressed that the problem stems from a lack of structural focus, rather than from any lack of potential volunteers.

"We have an extremely willing volunteer population in this country, so there is no question that proper trial representation is doable," said Shamoo, who is also the co-founder of the nonprofit Citizens for Responsible Care and Research, based in Columbia, Md. "And medicine is going to be given to millions of different people, so you do need that representation. Otherwise, you can have risks that you won't know about."

Other reports released this week buttress the findings of the Baylor team.

On Monday, Duke University researchers reported at the American College of Cardiology meeting in Chicago that although more women are being included in clinical cardiology trials, their numbers are still so low that it's questionable whether the results can actually be applied to women. And a commentary in the April issue of The Lancet Oncology stressed that more teens and young adults need to be included in trials of new cancer drugs, because they are currently under-represented.

More information

For additional information on clinical trials, visit the U.S. National Institutes of Health.

SOURCES: Daniel S. Goldberg, chief policy adviser, Intercultural Cancer Council, and doctoral student, ethics and medical humanities, University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston, Texas; Armin D. Weinberg, Ph.D., director, Chronic Disease Prevention & Control Research Center, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston; Adil Shamoo, Ph.D., professor, biochemistry and bioethics, University of Maryland, School of Medicine, Baltimore, and co-founder, Citizens for Responsible Care and Research, Columbia, Md.

Copyright©2008 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. AHIP Endorses Patient Charter to Guide Physician Performance Measurement, Reporting
2. Consumers, Health Care Purchasers, Physicians, and Health Insurers Announce Agreement on Principles to Guide Physician Performance Reporting
3. SEISMIC study issues glum report on cell therapy
4. Data Dimensions Assists Clients With Compliance of Present on Admission (POA) Indicator Reporting Requirements as Part of the April 1, 2008 Timeline
5. AMDL Reports 2007 Financial Results and 2008 Operating Strategy
6. Natural Nutrition Subsidiary Reports Record Year-End Revenue and EBITDA
7. China Shenghuo Reports Full Year 2007 Financial Results
8. Conseco Reports Fourth Quarter and Year-End Results
9. Benda Pharmaceutical Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2007 Financial Results
10. AdCare Health Systems, Inc. Reports Financial Results for 2007
11. Greenway Medical Technologies Expands Support for Physician Quality Reporting Initiative and Pay for Performance Programs
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Report Claims Clinical Trials Miss Many Populations
(Date:11/29/2015)... ... November 29, 2015 , ... Doctors who missed a case ... recognize the signs of mesothelioma and push for a diagnosis, especially in people exposed ... Click here to read it now. , Researchers at Gifu Prefectural ...
(Date:11/29/2015)... CA (PRWEB) , ... November 29, 2015 , ... Key ... is proud to announce their December, 2015, featured apartment community: Epic. In showcasing this ... corporate housing in the tight Bay Area rental market to efficiently find housing suitable ...
(Date:11/28/2015)... ... ... Trying to relax on a couch can actually be uncomfortable, so an inventor ... to personal experience with a bad back," he said. , This easy-to-use, versatile invention ... increases support. It also makes it easier to eat, do other activities and charge ...
(Date:11/27/2015)... ... November 28, 2015 , ... There is only one ... our billings from last year? , This question has not been an easy question ... to the retirement age and the younger workforce don’t share the same discipline around ...
(Date:11/27/2015)... ... November 27, 2015 , ... According to an article published November ... they are handling security in light of the recent terrorist attacks in Paris, other ... to stop an attack from reaching U.S. soil. Especially around special events that may ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/29/2015)... Nov. 29, 2015  Strengthening its leadership in connected ... PHIA) today announced IntelliSpace Portal 8.0 , the ... visualization platform that helps radiologists detect, diagnose and follow-up ... Radiological Society of North America Annual Meeting (RSNA) ... 8.0 helps address the changing demands in radiology that ...
(Date:11/29/2015)... -- The GE Health Cloud 1 was unveiled today at ... North America (RSNA) meeting in Chicago ... cloud ecosystem and its applications will connect radiologists and clinicians ... teams – both inside and outside the hospital setting. ... "As the digital industrial leader, we are betting big on ...
(Date:11/27/2015)... November 27, 2015 Une ... photodynamique au Bremachlorin contre le cancer avancé. ... à combiner l,immunothérapie au traitement photodynamique au Bremachlorin ... Une nouvelle approche consistant à combiner ... cancer avancé.    Clinical Cancer ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: