Navigation Links
Psychiatry's main method to prevent mistaken diagnoses of depression doesn't work: NYU study
Date:2/24/2010

CSC was added to the symptom and duration criteria in the DSM's fourth edition in 1994 (DSM-IV) in the wake of criticism that too many of the listed symptoms loss of appetite, say, or sadness, insomnia, or fatigue were being identified as evidence of major depressive disorder even when they were mild and possibly normal responses to distress arising from such events as the loss of a job, the dissolution of a marriage, or other triggers for sadness, and that such errors might be contributing to the very high reported rates of untreated depression in the American population drawn from epidemiological surveys. Under the 1994 DSM revision, in addition to the two weeks of sadness and other depressive symptoms, a specified minimal "clinically significant" threshold in the form of harm due to distress or role impairment (in occupational, family, or interpersonal contexts) must have resulted from the symptoms in evidence before they could be considered signs of depression. Researchers have subsequently assumed without definitive evidence that the CSC eliminates substantial numbers of false positives.

In a 1999 article in American Journal of Psychiatry, Wakefield and co-author Robert Spitzer, the originator of the modern DSM symptom-based approach to diagnosis, argued that the CSC would not eliminate false-positive diagnoses of major depression because anyone having the specified symptoms even an individual experiencing a normal intense reaction to loss would be likely to experience distress or role impairment. Thus, they asserted, the CSC was redundant with the symptom criteria and could not distinguish normal from disordered symptomsa claim that has come to be known as the "redundancy hypothesis." The researchers' argument was purely conceptual, and largely ignored.

The issue of whether the redundancy hypothesis is correct became suddenly more important after Wakefield senior-authored a much-discussed 2007 article in Archives of General Psych
'/>"/>

Contact: robert polner
robert.polner@nyu.edu
212-998-2337
New York University
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. Stanford study highlights cost-effective method of lowering heart disease risks
2. Different method of evaluating the urinary tract system reduces radiation dose
3. Report on patients access to cancer drugs uses flawed methods to reached flawed conclusions
4. A classic method for modeling skin cancer is featured in Cold Spring Harbor Protocols
5. Researcher developing new method for hearing loss assessment
6. Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit, Nonprofit Hospitals, Ambulatory Surgery Centers, Statistical Methods, and Pay-For-Performance Highlighted In the Latest INQUIRY Journal
7. GPS-like technology helps pinpoint best methods for moving injured players
8. New Seminar Series from Activator Methods Teaches Doctors a Unique Approach to Improving Nations Chiropractic Care: Focus on the Patients
9. Less invasive lymph node biopsy method could spare thousands unnecessary operations
10. 454 Sequencing(TM): Science Paper Describes a Novel, Highly Efficient Method of Sequencing Ancient DNA; Sequences the Mitochondria of 10 Individual Mammoths to Prove It
11. Manchester researchers announce new methods of beating breast cancer
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:7/14/2014)... "Medical devices, tests, and treatments are ... Tri-Valley is a star when it comes to innovations ... are working on amazing products and ideas that are ... according to Dale Kaye CEO of the Innovation ... the brilliant minds and businesses that are leading society ...
(Date:7/14/2014)... 14, 2014 Doctor Mike Hamilton from ... of their new company website. The Inception website is ... on chiropractic marketing. It's also a place for potential ... to offer. , When contacted at his office, Doctor ... of our main website. Our site is obviously a ...
(Date:7/14/2014)... 2014 Summer is the best season of ... the beach, swimming and other outdoor adventures. The promotional product ... happy and healthy all summer long. The promo product gurus ... three must-have custom imprinted products everyone must have on hand ... course sunblock. Sunscreen helps protect skin from harmful ...
(Date:7/13/2014)... (PRWEB) July 14, 2014 Save the Date ... Children’s Hospital in Jacksonville, FL , BOXWOODS & BowTies “A ... 2014 , Who: The Women’s Board of Wolfson Children’s ... Antiques Show to continue their ongoing commitment to raising ... region’s children. , What: The 2014 Art & Antiques ...
(Date:7/13/2014)... MED-Ed Facilities is seeking proposals from qualified ... 7+8 in Boston at the Seaport Hotel. Case ... Presentations by individuals or teams are welcome. Please submit ... of sessions that were presented last year, go to ... , Conference Director, The successful planning and design ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Believing in the Possible – Innovation Tri-Valley’s Sixth Innovation Forum Examines the Tri-Valley’s Wealth of Innovators 2Health News:Believing in the Possible – Innovation Tri-Valley’s Sixth Innovation Forum Examines the Tri-Valley’s Wealth of Innovators 3Health News:Believing in the Possible – Innovation Tri-Valley’s Sixth Innovation Forum Examines the Tri-Valley’s Wealth of Innovators 4Health News:Doctor Mike Hamilton From Inception Chiropractic Websites Announces the Launch of Their New Website 2Health News:Why These Three Summer Essentials from 4AllPromos Can Improve Summer 2Health News:Save the Date for the 2014 Art & Antiques Show benefiting Wolfson Children's Hospital in Jacksonville, FL 2Health News:Save the Date for the 2014 Art & Antiques Show benefiting Wolfson Children's Hospital in Jacksonville, FL 3Health News:Save the Date for the 2014 Art & Antiques Show benefiting Wolfson Children's Hospital in Jacksonville, FL 4Health News:Save the Date for the 2014 Art & Antiques Show benefiting Wolfson Children's Hospital in Jacksonville, FL 5Health News:Save the Date for the 2014 Art & Antiques Show benefiting Wolfson Children's Hospital in Jacksonville, FL 6Health News:Save the Date for the 2014 Art & Antiques Show benefiting Wolfson Children's Hospital in Jacksonville, FL 7Health News:Save the Date for the 2014 Art & Antiques Show benefiting Wolfson Children's Hospital in Jacksonville, FL 8Health News:Save the Date for the 2014 Art & Antiques Show benefiting Wolfson Children's Hospital in Jacksonville, FL 9Health News:MED-Ed Facilities Conference Call for Speakers Open 2
... 13 September, 2007 - The 14th World Congress on In ... Vitro Maturation (IVM) will be held in Montreal from September ... main experts in these fields for a five-day meeting in ... impacts. , Researchers from the McGill University Health Centre (MUHC) ...
... Florida Partner to Bring, Interactive Exhibit Tampa Bay to Educate ... ... BAY, Fla., Sept. 13 University of South Florida,and WE MOVE(TM) have ... Experience Center, to Tampa Bay to help,educate the public about movement disorders ...
... A person,s level,of education, income and the cost of ... to health care, according to the results of the,Department ... Factor Surveillance System survey queried more than,16,000 Pennsylvanians about ... screenings and other factors. "The survey can tell ...
... CIGNA HealthCare has,been recognized for call ... year under the J.D. Power and Associates ... strong commitment by,CIGNA call center operations to ... http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20050527/LAF028LOGO-a ) Located in Bourbonnais, ...
... Assorted Colors for Kids, CONCORD, Mass., Sept. ... &,Veggies-More Matters(TM) public health initiative, which encourages,Americans to ... has become "Fruits & Veggies-More Matters Month." To ... 24-28, 2007,P.A.C.K. Week: Pack Assorted Colors for Kids ...
... Names Thomas C. Novelli as MDMA,s Director of ... Medical Device,Manufacturers Association (MDMA) is pleased to announce ... Director of Federal Affairs., (Photo: http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20041004/MDMALOGO ... on the US Senate Committee on Finance,for Senator ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:MUHC in the spotlight at the 14th World Congress on In Vitro Fertilization 2Health News:National Movement Disorders Interactive Experience Center Comes to Tampa Bay for First Time 2Health News:National Movement Disorders Interactive Experience Center Comes to Tampa Bay for First Time 3Health News:National Movement Disorders Interactive Experience Center Comes to Tampa Bay for First Time 4Health News:National Movement Disorders Interactive Experience Center Comes to Tampa Bay for First Time 5Health News:National Movement Disorders Interactive Experience Center Comes to Tampa Bay for First Time 6Health News:PA Health Department Survey Shows Impact of Income, Gender, Other Factors on Health and Access to Health Care 2Health News:J.D. Power and Associates Reports: CIGNA HealthCare Recognized for Call Center Customer Satisfaction Excellence For a Second Consecutive Year 2Health News:J.D. Power and Associates Reports: CIGNA HealthCare Recognized for Call Center Customer Satisfaction Excellence For a Second Consecutive Year 3Health News:P.A.C.K. Week Declared in Support of Fruits & Veggies-More Matters Month 2Health News:P.A.C.K. Week Declared in Support of Fruits & Veggies-More Matters Month 3Health News:MDMA Names New Director of Federal Affairs 2
(Date:7/11/2014)... LONDON , July 11, 2014 /PRNewswire/ ... of visitors to Safety & Health Expo ... by the move to London ... senior management attending exhibition.     ... (Photo: http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20140711/696892-a ) ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... NEWPORT NEWS, Virginia , 11. ... führender Hersteller von Kameras für die ... Brust (MBI/BSGI), hat heute die CE-Zulassung ... Mit dem CE-Zeichen kann Dilon das ... seinen Vertriebsbereich auf den Großteil der ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... Calif. , July 10, 2014 Integrated ... leader in advanced memory and analog IC solutions, today ... on Thursday, July 24, 2014, at 7:00 a.m. Pacific ... financial results for the fiscal 2014 third quarter ended ... call via telephone, dial 1-888-556-4997 before 6:50 a.m. Pacific ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:UK's Flagship Health & Safety Event Has Successful Inaugural Year in London 2UK's Flagship Health & Safety Event Has Successful Inaugural Year in London 3UK's Flagship Health & Safety Event Has Successful Inaugural Year in London 4Dilon erhält CE-Zulassung für sein Navigator-Gamma-Sondensystem 2
... complete line of enteric disease ... and monoclonal/polyclonal antibody-based ELISA tests ... pathogens in fecal specimens. Our ... difficile, Entamoeba histolytica, Giardia, Cryptosporidium ...
... II test is also available with Inverness ... greatly reduces the hands-on time required to ... testing. The Fecal-Quik-Prep device is a unique ... amount of hands-on time required to prepare ...
... for autoimmune testing feature single-well ANA screen ... specific reflex tests including dsDNA, and 6 ... SS-B (La), Scl-70 and Jo-1. In addition, ... line of products for Cardiolipins (IgA, IgG, ...
... Our ELISA products for autoimmune testing ... ELISAs, as well as specific reflex tests ... Sm, Sm/RNP, SS-A (Ro), SS-B (La), Scl-70 ... family includes a full line of products ...
Medicine Products: