Navigation Links
Psychiatry's main method to prevent mistaken diagnoses of depression doesn't work: NYU study
Date:2/24/2010

CSC was added to the symptom and duration criteria in the DSM's fourth edition in 1994 (DSM-IV) in the wake of criticism that too many of the listed symptoms loss of appetite, say, or sadness, insomnia, or fatigue were being identified as evidence of major depressive disorder even when they were mild and possibly normal responses to distress arising from such events as the loss of a job, the dissolution of a marriage, or other triggers for sadness, and that such errors might be contributing to the very high reported rates of untreated depression in the American population drawn from epidemiological surveys. Under the 1994 DSM revision, in addition to the two weeks of sadness and other depressive symptoms, a specified minimal "clinically significant" threshold in the form of harm due to distress or role impairment (in occupational, family, or interpersonal contexts) must have resulted from the symptoms in evidence before they could be considered signs of depression. Researchers have subsequently assumed without definitive evidence that the CSC eliminates substantial numbers of false positives.

In a 1999 article in American Journal of Psychiatry, Wakefield and co-author Robert Spitzer, the originator of the modern DSM symptom-based approach to diagnosis, argued that the CSC would not eliminate false-positive diagnoses of major depression because anyone having the specified symptoms even an individual experiencing a normal intense reaction to loss would be likely to experience distress or role impairment. Thus, they asserted, the CSC was redundant with the symptom criteria and could not distinguish normal from disordered symptomsa claim that has come to be known as the "redundancy hypothesis." The researchers' argument was purely conceptual, and largely ignored.

The issue of whether the redundancy hypothesis is correct became suddenly more important after Wakefield senior-authored a much-discussed 2007 article in Archives of General Psych
'/>"/>

Contact: robert polner
robert.polner@nyu.edu
212-998-2337
New York University
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. Stanford study highlights cost-effective method of lowering heart disease risks
2. Different method of evaluating the urinary tract system reduces radiation dose
3. Report on patients access to cancer drugs uses flawed methods to reached flawed conclusions
4. A classic method for modeling skin cancer is featured in Cold Spring Harbor Protocols
5. Researcher developing new method for hearing loss assessment
6. Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit, Nonprofit Hospitals, Ambulatory Surgery Centers, Statistical Methods, and Pay-For-Performance Highlighted In the Latest INQUIRY Journal
7. GPS-like technology helps pinpoint best methods for moving injured players
8. New Seminar Series from Activator Methods Teaches Doctors a Unique Approach to Improving Nations Chiropractic Care: Focus on the Patients
9. Less invasive lymph node biopsy method could spare thousands unnecessary operations
10. 454 Sequencing(TM): Science Paper Describes a Novel, Highly Efficient Method of Sequencing Ancient DNA; Sequences the Mitochondria of 10 Individual Mammoths to Prove It
11. Manchester researchers announce new methods of beating breast cancer
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:12/20/2014)... 2014 The aftermath of the November 24th ... not only in Hollywood, but worldwide. As reported ... ripples of that attack are starting a finger-pointing game which ... But they are not the only ones affected, regular ... for some embarrassing times ahead, agents and lawyers could be ...
(Date:12/20/2014)... 2014 Parker & Sons, Inc. a ... of experience in contractor services announces reaching a milestone ... the homeowners of Arizona. Parker and Sons is comprised ... technicians that make customer service the number one priority. ... and started with one service vehicle and has since ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... Sarasota, Florida (PRWEB) December 19, 2014 Sub ... Bank to sponsor a blood drive Sunday the 28th from ... Clark Road & Sawyer Road in Sarasota, FL. , Inquiries ... special thank you for participating in the donating process, Sub ... a free flash frozen, custom ice cream. , About Sub ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... 2014 Eufaula, Oklahoma, located just 9 ... the state’s largest lake with more than 600 miles ... to a little more than 3,000 residents, hosted its ... the 6th of December. , Featuring Santa, Christmas lights ... Eufaula on Main Street. Narconon Arrowhead’s parade float ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... (HealthDay News) -- New research warns parents that buying an older ... Nearly half of teen drivers killed in the United States ... 11 years old and often lacked important safety features that are ... teen drivers killed in crashes were in cars at least six ... old, 31 percent were in cars 11 to 15 years old, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Sony Pictures Hack Perfect Example of the Reach a Single Cyber Attack Can Have 2Health News:Sony Pictures Hack Perfect Example of the Reach a Single Cyber Attack Can Have 3Health News:Sony Pictures Hack Perfect Example of the Reach a Single Cyber Attack Can Have 4Health News:Sony Pictures Hack Perfect Example of the Reach a Single Cyber Attack Can Have 5Health News:Parker & Sons Announces Reaching A Milestone By Providing 40 Years Of Dedicated Contractor Services For Homeowners Of Arizona 2Health News:Parker & Sons Announces Reaching A Milestone By Providing 40 Years Of Dedicated Contractor Services For Homeowners Of Arizona 3Health News:Shark Tank’s Sub Zero Ice Cream Sponsors Blood Drive 2Health News:Narconon Arrowhead Debuts Float at Checotah and Eufaula Christmas Parades 2Health News:Narconon Arrowhead Debuts Float at Checotah and Eufaula Christmas Parades 3Health News:Older Cars a Bad Choice for Younger Drivers 2
... new study shows patients who undergo chemotherapy or radiation expect ... from // chemotherapy or radiation can diminish the quality ... side effect, such as nausea, he or she is more ... gender, educational background, and the type of cancer influence how ...
... Patients with rheumatoid arthritis who receive a more intensive ... remission of their disease, finds a new study.// ... patients with similar levels of disease to one of ... drugs to fight rheumatoid arthritis, along with steroid injections. ...
... vertigo affects about 64 people in every 100,000. It is ... as often in women.// Simple exercises performed at home may ... a new study. ,Researchers studied 70 patients who had ... the inner ear canal. Participants reported experiencing episodes of nausea ...
... recent survey by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ... above the 85th percentile,// and 15 percent of children have ... the last 20 years and the National Institutes of Health ... overweight adults, which keeps them at high risk for heart ...
... done to activate the cells to destroy tumors. Researchers say ... may be due to different cell priming or suppressing mechanisms. ... method to activate the anti-cancer cells in mice. For the ... separated the anti-cancer cells. The cells were stimulated to become ...
... study shows soy protein with isoflavones does not have ... or cholesterol in postmenopausal women.// ,Researchers say ... related to a decrease in bone mineral density and ... women have taken hormone therapy to offset these effects ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:12/19/2014)... -- Decision Resources Group finds that the laparoscopic device market ... increase to a value of over $4.3 billion by ... the large direct energy device market. In particular, premium-priced ... to the advantages they offer and as new products ... Resources Group,s coverage of the U.S. laparoscopic device market: ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... Dec. 18, 2014   Aratana Therapeutics, Inc ... company focused on the licensing, development and commercialization ... positive results from its pivotal field study of ... pain in dogs with osteoarthritis.  In the study, ... scores that were statistically significant compared to placebo ...
(Date:12/17/2014)... 2014 Revenue and earnings above the ... and development In the past 2013/14 fiscal year ... percent to EUR 4.287 billion (last year: EUR 4.190 billion) ... to EUR 360 million. "Overall, 2013/14 was a successful fiscal ... , President and CEO of Carl Zeiss AG. "Thanks to ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:U.S. Laparoscopic Device Market Will Reach Over $4.3 Billion by 2023 2U.S. Laparoscopic Device Market Will Reach Over $4.3 Billion by 2023 3Aratana Therapeutics Announces Positive Top-Line Results from AT-001 Pivotal Field Study in Client-Owned Dogs with Osteoarthritis 2Aratana Therapeutics Announces Positive Top-Line Results from AT-001 Pivotal Field Study in Client-Owned Dogs with Osteoarthritis 3Aratana Therapeutics Announces Positive Top-Line Results from AT-001 Pivotal Field Study in Client-Owned Dogs with Osteoarthritis 4Aratana Therapeutics Announces Positive Top-Line Results from AT-001 Pivotal Field Study in Client-Owned Dogs with Osteoarthritis 5ZEISS Asserts its Position in Difficult Environment 2
All Day Comfort for the Upper Body...
All Purpose, General Procedure Apron...
Designed to fit the body and priced to fit the budget! The Economy Tie apron has a belt that wraps around the body and ties in the front. Don't let the price fool you.... this apron provides the same...
This aron protects at 0.5 mm Pb equivalency and is 20% lighter than our Standard Back-Aid Apron - yet it contains no lead products that can be harmful to the environment!...
Medicine Products: