Navigation Links
Psychiatry's main method to prevent mistaken diagnoses of depression doesn't work: NYU study
Date:2/24/2010

A study in the March edition of the American Journal of Psychiatry senior-authored by Jerome C. Wakefield, a professor at the Silver School of Social Work at New York University with Mark Schmitz of Temple University and Judith Baer of Rutgers University, empirically challenges the effectiveness of psychiatrists' official diagnostic manual in preventing mistaken, false-positive diagnoses of depression.

The findings concerning the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders' (DSM) criteria for diagnosing depression rebuts recent criticism of earlier research by Wakefield. That earlier research suggested that misdiagnoses of depression are widespread, and touched off considerable controversy.

According to the DSM, the diagnosis of major depression requires the presence for two weeks of at least five possible symptoms out of a list of nine, which include, for example, sadness, loss of interest in usual activities, lowered appetite, fatigue, and insomnia. However, these symptoms can also occur in normal responses to loss and stress. False positive diagnoses occur when someone reacting with intense normal sadness to life's stresses is misdiagnosed as having major depressive disorder. Recent studies suggest that a very large percentage of people have such symptoms for two weeks or longer at some point in their lives; therefore, how many of these individuals really are afflicted by a mental disorder or are responding within normal limits to loss or stress has been a matter of debate.

The journal article, entitled "Does the DSM-IV Clinical Significance Criterion for Major Depression Reduce False Positives? Evidence From the National Comorbidity Survey Replication," examines the primary method by which the official diagnostic criteria for depression the Clinical Significance Criterion (CSC) are supposed to distinguish normal from disordered cases and thereby prevent false positive diagnoses. The
'/>"/>

Contact: robert polner
robert.polner@nyu.edu
212-998-2337
New York University
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. Stanford study highlights cost-effective method of lowering heart disease risks
2. Different method of evaluating the urinary tract system reduces radiation dose
3. Report on patients access to cancer drugs uses flawed methods to reached flawed conclusions
4. A classic method for modeling skin cancer is featured in Cold Spring Harbor Protocols
5. Researcher developing new method for hearing loss assessment
6. Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit, Nonprofit Hospitals, Ambulatory Surgery Centers, Statistical Methods, and Pay-For-Performance Highlighted In the Latest INQUIRY Journal
7. GPS-like technology helps pinpoint best methods for moving injured players
8. New Seminar Series from Activator Methods Teaches Doctors a Unique Approach to Improving Nations Chiropractic Care: Focus on the Patients
9. Less invasive lymph node biopsy method could spare thousands unnecessary operations
10. 454 Sequencing(TM): Science Paper Describes a Novel, Highly Efficient Method of Sequencing Ancient DNA; Sequences the Mitochondria of 10 Individual Mammoths to Prove It
11. Manchester researchers announce new methods of beating breast cancer
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:7/9/2014)... A retrospective study conducted by researchers at Tufts University ... adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities, the likelihood of ... dental care increased. The findings, published in the July/August ... help improve interventions designed to address the oral health ... reviewed the dental records of 107 patients at one ...
(Date:7/9/2014)... , , , , , ... , , , , ... the microphone is 50m downrange from the firer and approximately 30cm from the bullet... , , ... , , , , , ... , , , , , , University ...
(Date:7/9/2014)... of Medicine of the University of Southern California ... component of the immune system are completely resistant ... The discovery suggests that blocking this immune system ... and hyper-inflammatory diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis and ... online on June 23 in The Journal ...
(Date:7/8/2014)... The Department of Defense,s Defense Advanced Research Projects ... up to $2.5 million to develop an implantable ... stimulate neurons within the brain to help restore ... research builds on the understanding that memory is ... of the brain encode information, store it and ...
(Date:7/8/2014)... In a study published yesterday in the scientific ... Jolla Institute (LJI) led by Pandurangan Vijayanand, Ph.D. identify new ... affects over 200 million people world wide. , An ... divided into small sections or ,neighborhoods., Scientists can determine ... for gene production, by looking for a marker on the ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Adults with special needs see gains, challenges with long term oral care 2Health News:Adults with special needs see gains, challenges with long term oral care 3Health News:Fit for the frontline? New study identifies the hearing requirements of British soldiers 2Health News:Fit for the frontline? New study identifies the hearing requirements of British soldiers 3Health News:Fit for the frontline? New study identifies the hearing requirements of British soldiers 4Health News:Fit for the frontline? New study identifies the hearing requirements of British soldiers 5Health News:Fit for the frontline? New study identifies the hearing requirements of British soldiers 6Health News:Fit for the frontline? New study identifies the hearing requirements of British soldiers 7Health News:DARPA selects Lawrence Livermore to develop world's first neural device to restore memory 2Health News:DARPA selects Lawrence Livermore to develop world's first neural device to restore memory 3Health News:LJI develops new approach to identify genes poised to respond in asthma patients 2
... TORRANCE, Calif., April 27 According to new ... , supplements of Lactobacillus casei strain Shirota may ... fatigue syndrome (CFS). Thirty-nine patients with CFS ... Shirota or placebo for two months. Compared ...
... Services Department declares a Public Health EmergencyHARRISBURG, Pa., April ... working with federal officials to contain the impact of ... in the declaration of a national public health emergency ... to educate the public and health care providers of ...
... toxins in the products we use for lifestyle convenience, ... toxic load on our bodies contributing to chronic illnesses, ... awareness of our environmental exposures, Metametrix Clinical Laboratory ( ... release of three new testing profiles in the Toxic ...
... 100 Exhibits, Forums on Health Care and Financial Security, ... Top Musicians***LOS LOBOS TO HEADLINE ENTERTAINMENT***SAN ANTONIO, April 27 ... for people age 50+, today announced it will bring ... San Antonio on May 15-16. The two-day, cross-generational ...
... screen at 40, but yearly PSA may not be necessary, ... guidelines on prostate cancer screening suggest that annual PSA blood ... same guidelines call for a "baseline" PSA test at the ... (PSA) test to detect early signs of prostate cancer should ...
... WHAT: , Media may now register to attend ... Symposium of the Cardiovascular Research Foundation. TCT gathers ... world to present and discuss the latest developments ... medicine. Now in its 21st year, TCT brings ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:New Study Shows Supplementing With Probiotics May Ease Anxiety 2Health News:Pennsylvania Working Closely With Federal Partners to Contain Impact of Swine Flu 2Health News:Pennsylvania Working Closely With Federal Partners to Contain Impact of Swine Flu 3Health News:Metametrix Announces New Toxic Effects Profiles to Help Combat Growing Concerns About Toxicity and Health 2Health News:AARP to Host Cross-Generational 'Life Festival' in San Antonio May 15-16 2Health News:AARP to Host Cross-Generational 'Life Festival' in San Antonio May 15-16 3Health News:Experts Back Away From Annual PSA Test 2Health News:Experts Back Away From Annual PSA Test 3Health News:Media registration now open for TCT 2009 2
(Date:1/15/2014)... Jan. 15, 2014 The Cadence Fitness & Health ... by the Medical Fitness Association, a non-profit organization assisting ... full potential. The Cadence Fitness & Health Center is ... and second in the Chicagoland area. "The ...
(Date:1/15/2014)...  Valeant Pharmaceuticals International, Inc. (NYSE: VRX ... under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976 ("HSR") ... its indirect wholly-owned subsidiary, Sapphire Subsidiary Corp. ("Purchaser"), for ... Solta Medical, Inc. (NASDAQ: SLTM ) ("Solta") ...
(Date:1/15/2014)... , Jan. 15, 2014  A novel wearable injector slightly ... and painless for patients to self-inject prescription drugs in the ... including cancer, blood diseases, autoimmune deficiencies, and genetic disorders.  ... grow to $220B by 2018, according to analysts.   Many of ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Cadence Fitness & Health Center Certified as Medical Fitness Facility 2Cadence Fitness & Health Center Certified as Medical Fitness Facility 3Valeant Pharmaceuticals Announces Receipt Of Antitrust Clearance For Its Previously Announced Acquisition Of Solta Medical, Inc. 2Valeant Pharmaceuticals Announces Receipt Of Antitrust Clearance For Its Previously Announced Acquisition Of Solta Medical, Inc. 3Enable Injections Presents A New Class of Injectors for Drug Delivery at PEPTalk, Drug Delivery Partnership Meetings 2
... Laboratories is a national reference laboratory and ... and development. ARUP offers an extensive test ... tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned ... clients include more than half of the ...
... reference laboratory and a worldwide leader in ... an extensive test menu of highly complex ... anatomic pathology. Owned by the University of ... half of the nation's university teaching hospitals ...
... ARUP Laboratories is a national reference ... laboratory research and development. ARUP offers an ... unique medical tests in clinical and anatomic ... ARUP Laboratories' clients include more than half ...
... a national reference laboratory and a worldwide ... ARUP offers an extensive test menu of ... clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned by the ... more than half of the nation's university ...
Medicine Products: