Navigation Links
Prostate cancer screening and treatment decisions must act on evidence, not beliefs
Date:1/25/2012

BOSTON Physicians advising men whether to be screened for prostate cancer with a PSA test must rely more on available evidence when recommending screening, biopsies and treatments rather than long held beliefs that PSA-based testing is beneficial for all, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center prostate expert Marc B. Garnick, MD, says.

Writing in the February edition of Scientific American, Garnick states the current system that relies on prostate-specific antigens levels in the blood is "deeply flawed," and physicians must take into account the fact "the PSA test does not tell you if a man has cancer, just that he might have it."

The recent US Preventative Services Task Force's assessment of studies published in 2009 shows more harm than good results from PSA testing, and that evidence favors moving away from aggressive early treatment for all and toward a more cautious, individualized approach an approach currently underway at BIDMC.

"Most people outside the medical community do not realize how flimsy evidence has been in favor of the PSA screening data," says Garnick, who is also an editor-in-chief of Harvard Medical School's Annual Report on Prostate Diseases and associated website.

"In a perfect world, a screening test would identify only cancers that would prove lethal if untreated. Then, men who had small, curable cancers would be treated, and their lives would be saved. Ideally, the treatments would not only be effective, they would have no serious side effects. Such a scenario would justify massive screening and treatment of everyone with a positive test."

However, doctors currently do not have a reliable way to determine which of these small cancers, caught by biopsy, are potentially dangerous and which would not cause harm throughout a man's lifetime. Moreover, all of the current treatments carry significant risks and long term side effects.

Despite successfully preventing a single death from prostate cancer, the number of men who would have to be treated and potentially suffer the consequences of treatment to achieve this prompted the Task Force to recommend against wide spread PSA testing for all men without symptoms of prostate cancer. according to Garnick.

In two studies from 2009, one conducted in Europe and the other in the US, healthy men in their 50s and 60s were randomly divided into two groups; one was periodically screened for prostate cancer using PSA testing or a digital rectal exam, or both. The other group was not offered routine testing, but received standard medical care as needed.

The European study showed that only the men who were tested and treated for prostate cancer had a 20 percent likelihood of dying from the disease, while neither study showed if the men who were tested and treated lived any longer than those who were not offered routine testing. Such a decrease in prostate cancer mortality was not found in the U.S. study.

In the European study, researchers then determined that in order to save one life from prostate cancer, approximately 1,400 men would have to undergo screening, which would result in 48 having to undergo treatment. The remaining 47 could suffer serious side effects, such as incontinence and impotence, as a result of radiation or surgery.

"The overall death rate from all causes was not statistically different in both the screened and unscreened groups," says Garnick. "Unfortunately, the mortality data collected over the past 25 years shows that the natural history of prostate cancer is not as straightforward as my colleagues and I once believed. Many cancers will never cause problems during the patient's lifetime, and hence do not need to be treated, at least immediately."

Results from a long-term Canadian study indicate that the death rate from the disease for men who elect active surveillance, or choosing to delay treatment after a PSA test led to the diagnosis of cancer is 1 percent over 10 years, compared with a 0.5 percent risk of dying from complications in the first month after prostate cancer surgery.

"The point is that the initial decision to forgo treatment is not necessarily the final one. Surgery, radiation and other therapies are still available later on, and most current data indicate that the outcome will not be negatively affected by the delay. Such an approach is improving our ability to tailor treatments for individuals rather than always treating everyone the same," says Garnick.

The outcomes of this decision indicate that doctors and patients need to be clear about their knowledge, and lack of knowledge, from a scientific point of view especially as we discuss these issues with our patients. "We need to have the courage to act on the evidence and not just our beliefs," says Garnick.


'/>"/>

Contact: Jerry Berger
jberger@bidmc.harvard.edu
617-667-7308
Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Drug May Slow Early Prostate Cancer: Study
2. Preoperative MRI may reduce risk of nerve damage in prostate cancer surgeries
3. Prostate cancer study proves drug delays disease progression
4. Eating smart: Researcher studies foods, dietary supplements that may reduce risk of prostate cancer
5. Cabazitaxel with radiation and hormone therapy may improve prostate cancer survival
6. Music May Ease Anxiety, Pain in Prostate Biopsy Patients
7. UNC scientists collaborate to find first major genetic mutation associated with hereditary prostate cancer risk
8. Scientists Identify Inherited Prostate Cancer Gene
9. Headphone music eases anxiety during prostate biopsies
10. PSA Test for Prostate Cancer Doesnt Save Lives: Study
11. Mass prostate cancer screening doesnt reduce deaths
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:1/16/2017)... ... 2017 , ... NexTec Group has been selected as a member of the ... accomplishments in the field of midmarket financial software. , Members of the VAR Stars ... is not based on revenue and those firms chosen represent a wide range of ...
(Date:1/15/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... January 15, 2017 , ... Whole Health Supply, LLC is announcing the ... There are also new avenues for purchase. , The 2017 edition has wide jaws ... issues for the older boomers as well as diabetics. This handle is reinforced for extra ...
(Date:1/15/2017)... ... January 15, 2017 , ... San Francisco Magazine ... Bay Area counties for 2017. Almost 1,000 nominations were submitted and a little ... process. Results were announced the magazine’s January 2017 issue . , Under ...
(Date:1/15/2017)... , ... January 15, 2017 , ... ... in Montclair, NJ is pleased to announce that it will be assisting HackensackUMC ... in Montclair and Glen Ridge townships, servicing all surrounding towns. The firm will ...
(Date:1/14/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... January 14, 2017 , ... AgileMinder develops ... , The Emoji Scale is now available on Apple as a fun, free ... ratings simply by choosing one of the ten color coded values on The Emoji ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/13/2017)... Jan. 13, 2017  Alfalfa, cattle, leafy greens and rosy ... sampling film , which emphasizes the food industry,s shift from ... how COPAN,s Swab Rinse Kit ... surface sampling process in the wake of the new ... COPAN is expanding the U.S. production of ...
(Date:1/13/2017)... Pa. , Jan. 13, 2017  Secretary of ... of students, professors, and community members at Misericordia University ... opioid epidemic in Pennsylvania . ... crisis I,ve seen so far in my professional career," ... has been hit hard by heroin and ...
(Date:1/13/2017)... BOISE, Idaho , Jan. 12, 2017 /PRNewswire/ ... status by Accreditation Commission for Health Care (ACHC) ... the largest national food and drug chain with ... service for pharmacy patients. Accreditation by ... meeting national standards to facilitate a higher level ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: