Navigation Links
Promoting healthy skepticism in the news: Helping journalists get it right
Date:11/20/2009

An editorial published online November 20 in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute discusses the exaggerated fears and hopes that often appear in news coverage of cancer research. The editorial provides guidance for both the media and journals to help alleviate the problem.

Lisa M. Schwartz, M.D., M.S., and Steven Woloshin, M.D., M.S., of Center for Medicine and the Media at the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice in New Hampshire, and Barnett S. Kramer, M.D., editor-in-chief of the JNCI, use recent media coverage of two studies from the New England Journal of Medicine and the JNCI to demonstrate their point.

Coverage of trial results of the new anti-cancer drug olaparib, which appeared in the NEJM, exaggerated hope in many ways. One national news outlet claimed the drug "was the most important cancer breakthrough of the decade," but failed to note that the study was uncontrolled (so there is no way to know if the drug accounted for the findings), and very preliminary (it is not known if the findings will ever translate into longer life).

The editorialists also point to coverage of a JNCI article on alcohol consumption and cancer risk among women, which may have caused unwarranted fear: "A drink a day raises women's risk of cancer," read one newspaper headline. Unfortunately, the coverage did not provide the magnitude of the risk. Comparing the highest level of drinking (≥15 drinks a week) to the lowest (one to two drinks per week), the investigators observed a 0.6% absolute increase in the risk of breast cancer diagnosis: from 2% to 2.6% for more than 7 years.

Journalists are not the only ones to blame, though, according to the editorialists. Medical journals sometimes leave important elements out of studies. In many cases, absolute risks and study limitations are omitted from the abstracts and journal press releases.

To help journalists and medical journals, the editorialists include tip sheets with guidance on questions to ask study authors, the interpretation of common statistics, and ways to highlight study limitations.

The tip sheets are posted on a new JNCI Web site for science writers: http://www.oxfordjournals.org/our_journals/jnci/resource/reporting_on_cancer.html

"We hope that effortswithin medical journals and those directed toward journalistswill help foster healthy skepticism in the news," the authors write. "Namely, setting a higher bar for covering very preliminary or inherently weak research, routinely providing data to support claims, and always highlighting study limitations."


'/>"/>

Contact: Steve Graff
jncimedia@oxfordjournals.org
301-841-1285
Journal of the National Cancer Institute
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Pittsburgh Partners Launch Promising Family-Centered Care Model: Special Focus on Promoting Parental Well-Being and Healthy Child Development
2. Swanson Health Products Joins Peggy Fleming in Promoting the Heart Health Benefits of Ubiquinol, a CoQ10 Dietary Supplement
3. KEAP1 Keeps major cancer-promoting protein at bay
4. The Scleroderma Foundation Applauds Introduction of First Bill in the Senate Promoting Research and Awareness of Scleroderma
5. What are the most effective ways of promoting physical exercise in adults?
6. Ridge Diagnostics Wins Growth-Promoting Loan From Biotech Center
7. Texas Health Resources Recognized by National Business Group on Health as Leading Employer Promoting Healthy Lifestyles for Employees
8. CVS Caremark Recognized with Gold Award from National Business Group on Health for Promoting Healthy Lifestyles for Employees
9. UPMC and UPMC Health Plan Recognized by National Business Group on Health As a Leading Employer Promoting Healthy Lifestyles for Its Employees
10. Insurance Leader Praises Senator Kennedy for Promoting Long-Term Care Aid for All Americans as Part of Health Reform
11. The Scleroderma Foundation Applauds Introduction of First Bill In Congress Promoting Research and Awareness of Scleroderma
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/9/2016)... ... February 09, 2016 , ... A new ... schedule rates and Medicare rates for a variety of medical services in Illinois ... Evaluation of the 2015 Fee Schedule Rates in Illinois, are professional medical ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... ... February 09, 2016 , ... Establishment Labs, a global ... David Hung to the company´s Board of Directors. , “We are honored ... and an exceptional entrepreneur.” said Juan Jose Chacon Quiros, CEO of Establishment Labs. "David’s ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... County, CA (PRWEB) , ... February 09, 2016 , ... ... on home whitening packages. Teeth whitening is among the most popular cosmetic procedures in ... for their whitening needs. This can put them at risk of teeth whitening-related damage. ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... ... February 09, 2016 , ... Two renowned photographers, Robert ... a photographic adventure on the island, June 14-19, 2016, hosted by Four Seasons Resort ... , After a successful debut in 2015, the Maui Photo Expedition workshop ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... ... February 09, 2016 , ... Shark Finds and Kevin Harrington, and the ... with GRIP-DRY. , GRIP-DRY is a newly patented product that has solved some of the ... the wet and early morning dew or right after a rain shower, might understand the ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/9/2016)... or "Company") (NASDAQ: UNIS ; ASX: UNS), a developer ... results for the second quarter of fiscal 2016 (three months ended ... Financial Results for the Second Quarter of Fiscal 2016 ... for the second quarter of fiscal 2016 was $4.5 million, compared ... from customers for the second quarter of fiscal 2016 were $17.8 ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... Bermuda, Feb. 9, 2016  Axovant Sciences Ltd. ... on the treatment of dementia, today announced further ... cognitive, behavioral and functional aspects of Lewy body ... in the U.S. Two out of the three ... expected to start later this quarter. In addition, ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... Feb. 9, 2016 Hearing protection devices refer ... energy transmitted to the inner ear. Hearing protection devices ... These devices are recommended for users exposed to noise ... refer to HPD that are inserted in the ear ... designed to provide more natural sound perception with the ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: