Navigation Links
Promise of genomics research needs a realistic view

CHAPEL HILL, N.C. - In the ten years since the human genetic code was mapped, expectations among scientists, health care industry, policy makers, and the public have remained high concerning the promise of genomics research for improving health.

But a new commentary by four internationally prominent genetic medicine and bioethics experts cautions against the dangers of inflated expectations an unsustainable genomic bubble and it offers ways to avoid it while still realizing "the true and considerable promise of the genomic revolution."

"This commentary is an attempt to bring some balance to the hopes and claims that swirl around the issue of genomic medicine. It is a cautionary essay that tries to extol the real and formidable potential of genomic medicine but also attempts to counter what we see as exaggerated claims, said lead author medical geneticist James P. Evans, MD, PhD, Bryson Distinguished Professor of Genetics and Medicine at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and the UNC Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center.

"Our fear is that if we are uncritical and nave in our enthusiasm for these exciting technologies we risk both diversion of precious resources and premature implementation which could hurt patients - as well as a backlash which will hurt our field," Evans warns.

The commentary appears in the February 18, 2011 issue of the journal Science. Co-authors with Evans are Eric M. Meslin, PhD, director, Center for Bioethics, Indiana University, Indianapolis; Theresa M. Marteau, PhD, FMedSci, professor of health psychology, Kings College, London, UK; and Timothy Caulfield, LL.M., F.R.S.C., Canada Research Chair in Health Law & Policy, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta.

"Breathtaking" is how the authors describe the progress already made in genomic research. But, they caution, the considerable promise of genomics must be evaluated through a realistic lens. Advances in individualized medicine, or pharmacogenetics for example, still require the importance of human behavior in health outcomes: the most powerful predictor of a drug's efficacy depends less on genetics than whether the patient takes the drug.

Among the reasons they cite making genomics the persistent recipient of "hyperbole" and inflated expectations, some are tied to impatience for practical applications, market forces and unbridled (but uncritical) enthusiasm. The news media also is named for "playing an obvious role in the creation of unrealistic hopes."

"These forces act together to produce a kind of "cycle of hype" that drive overly optimistic representations of the research," said co-author Timothy Caulfield.

In their short-list of recommendations for avoiding inflation of the "genomic bubble, Evans and co-authors offer the following: (1) reevaluate funding priorities to stress behavioral and social science research aimed at behavior change for improving health; (2) foster a realistic understanding "of the incremental nature of science and the need for statistical rigor," within the scientific community and that the media make more responsible claims for genomic research; (3) maintain a focus on developing high-quality evidence before integrating good ideas into medical practice.

"By highlighting the risks of continuing to promise results from genomic science, we were hoping to draw attention to a more sustainable approach to reaping the benefits from genomic science," said co-author Eric Meslin.

The authors assert their belief that the current age of genomics will provide great benefits to human health "Ours is not a call to gut existing research or too-rigidly tie funding to degree of disease burden The pursuit of our common goal improved human health demands that we take a hard look at disease causation and order our priorities accordingly."


Contact: Les Lang
University of North Carolina School of Medicine

Related medicine news :

1. Innovative virtual reality exposure therapy shows promise for returning troops
2. Peer support offers promise for reducing depression symptoms
3. 2 Experimental Drugs Show Promise for Rare Pancreatic Cancer
4. Electronic cigarettes hold promise as aid to quitting
5. Universal Flu Vaccine Shows Promise in Early Trial
6. Biomarker test shows promise for melanoma diagnosis
7. Stents Show Promise in Treating Brain Blockages
8. Study shows promise for new drug to treat Fragile X
9. New Drug Strategy Shows Promise Against HIV
10. Robotic surgery for head and neck cancer shows promise
11. Y-90 radioembolization offers promise for late-stage liver cancer
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Promise of genomics research needs a realistic view
(Date:11/30/2015)... , ... November 30, 2015 , ... ... Beard and Brooke Bennett are collaborating with brands across various categories through traditional ... influential figures make up an elite group of Gold Medal Moms who can ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... December 01, 2015 , ... The National ... 2015-2016 inductee into its VIP Woman of the Year Circle. She is recognized ... networking organization exclusively for professional women, boasting 850,000 members and over 200 operating ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... 30, 2015 , ... During the National Family Caregivers Month, ... two webinars on topics of ‘Medical and Palliative Care Decisions,’ and ‘Self-Care for ... . , With a loved one's diagnosis of mesothelioma, the closest family member ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... MOSI recently added two state-of-the-art augmented reality ... to the Jurassic to their collection of interactive exhibits within the Kids In Charge! ... will allow guests to get closer than ever to a range of animals as ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... ... across the United States to access life-saving information provided directly from top ... will consist of three individual conferences in three major cities: Houston, San Francisco, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... 2015  Kevin Smith has been appointed Chief ... pioneer in wireless monitoring of vital signs.  As ... , Mr. Smith will be responsible for the ... He will also directly oversee partnering with US ... for SensiumVitals, the first early warning detection device ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... LAKE, N.J. and SAN DIEGO ... and Arena Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (NASDAQ: ARNA ) today ... has accepted for filing the New Drug Application (NDA) ... the extended release formulation will offer patients a chronic ... ® ) is currently approved as an ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... iCAD, Inc. (Nasdaq: ICAD ) ... solutions for advanced image analysis and workflow tools ... Radiological Society of North American (RSNA) 2015 Annual ... November 29 to December 4, 2015. The company ... automated breast density assessment solution, PowerLook® Advanced Mammography ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: