Navigation Links
Private insurers' Medicare Advantage plans cost Medicare an extra $34.1 billion in 2012
Date:5/10/2013

A study published online today finds that the private insurance companies that participate in Medicare under the Medicare Advantage program and its predecessors have cost the publicly funded program for the elderly and disabled an extra $282.6 billion since 1985, most of it over the past eight years. In 2012 alone, private insurers were overpaid $34.1 billion.

That's wasted money that should have been spent on improving patient care, shoring up Medicare's trust fund or reducing the federal deficit, the researchers say.

The findings appear in an article published in the International Journal of Health Services by Drs. Ida Hellander, Steffie Woolhandler and David Himmelstein titled "Medicare overpayments to private plans, 1985-2012: Shifting seniors to private plans has already cost Medicare US$282.6 billion."

Hellander is policy director at Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP), a nonprofit research and advocacy group. Woolhandler and Himmelstein are professors at the City University of New York School of Public Health, visiting professors at Harvard Medical School and co-founders of PNHP.

Medicare has contracted with private insurance plans previously referred to as Medicare HMOs and now called Medicare Advantage plans since 1985. Such plans, most of them for-profit, currently cover about 27 percent of Medicare enrollees and have been growing at a fast clip. UnitedHealth and Humana are among the largest players in this market, and together operate about one-third of such plans.

Medicare pays these privately run plans a set "premium" per enrollee for hospital and physician services (averaging $10,123 in 2012) based on a prediction of how costly the enrollee's care will be.

The authors find that private insurers have four strategies that make them more costly than the traditional Medicare program.

  1. Private plans cherry-pick healthier beneficiaries who cost less to care for, guaranteeing large profits. Although private plans must accept all seniors who choose to enroll, they cherry-pick by selectively recruiting the healthiest seniors through advertising, office location, etc. They also induce sicker ones to disenroll by making expensive care inconvenient.

  2. They recruit otherwise healthy seniors with very mild (and inexpensive) cases of sometimes serious conditions automatically triggering higher premiums for these beneficiaries from the risk-adjustment scheme implemented in 2004, but escaping payments for expensive care. For instance, many seniors have very mild cases of arthritis, heart failure and bronchitis that require little or no treatment.

  3. They enroll patients who get most of their care free at the Veteran's Administration.

  4. They heavily lobby Congress to raise their reimbursement. The insurance industry successfully induced Congress and the Bush administration to add bonus payments to Medicare Advantage premiums beginning in 2003.

Since the study was completed, the industry has again successfully lobbied the administration to raise payments to Medicare Advantage plans, reversing a planned cut of 2.2 percent in reimbursement rates and instead obtaining a 3.3 percent increase. Stock prices of private insurers soared over the announcement.

"We've long known that Medicare has been paying private insurers more than if their enrollees had stayed in traditional fee-for-service Medicare, but no one had added up the total extra cost to the taxpayer since contracting with private insurers began 27 years ago," said Dr. Ida Hellander, lead author of the study. "Nor has anyone systematically examined the many ways that private insurers have gamed the system to maximize their bottom line at taxpayers' expense."

"In 2012 alone, private insurers are being overpaid $34.1 billion, or $2,526 per Medicare Advantage enrollee," Hellander said.

Co-author Dr. Steffie Woolhandler said: "It's clear that having Medicare Advantage programs compete with Medicare doesn't save us money. In fact the opposite is the case. The private plans only add waste, and the aggregate waste is staggering enough to be a significant drag on the economy.

"It's time we look to proven, cost-effective ways of providing high-quality care to Medicare's beneficiaries and to the entire population," Woolhandler said. "That means taking a fresh look at the single-payer model of reform."


'/>"/>

Contact: Mark Almberg
mark@pnhp.org
312-782-6006
Physicians for a National Health Program
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. West Hollywood Welcomes FBE Personal Trainer, Private Fitness And Weight Loss Center Minutes From Beverly Hills
2. New Private Exchange for Health Insurance Coming to New Jersey
3. Business-Grade Cloud Hosting Solutions now Available over the BroadConnect Private Network
4. Newport Board Group, a National Business Advisory Firm of CEOs Serving the Emerging Middle Market, Releases a Technology Roadmap for Private Companies
5. Case Studies, Best Practices of Companies Operating Private Exchanges to Be Reviewed in May 14 Webinar
6. Private Companies Will Face Increased Competition for Sales in 2013 - Newport Board Group Releases Seven Strategies Designed to Improve Customer Retention
7. Healer, Psychotherapist and TV Show Host, Heather Hans, Expands Private Practice
8. Ultimate Aquatics, announces the acquisition of SUP Products, the industry leader in U.S. Made Private Label Hybrid Molded Composite (HMC) Stand Up Paddle Boards (SUP) & Accessories.
9. United Benefit Advisors Webinar: Private Lessons from The Public Sector, Strategies for Controlling Health Care Cost
10. Corporate Whistle Blower Center Now Urges Employees of Any Type Of Private Contractor in Afghanistan or Iraq to Step Forward for Rewards if They Possess Proof of Fraud
11. The Olive Oil Source Announces New Bottle Options for Private Label Shiners
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/8/2016)... ... February 08, 2016 , ... Delta Dental of California and its ... cancer. , Gary D. Radine, who recently retired as president and CEO of Delta ... 2015 CEO of the Year , helped lead the effort to raise funds ...
(Date:2/8/2016)... ... February 08, 2016 , ... Eating ... a significant number of women and men with eating disorders report a history ... best predicts the development of an eating disorder. , At the 2016 ...
(Date:2/8/2016)... ... February 08, 2016 , ... GrassrootsHealth published data from ... type 2 diabetes in the GrassrootsHealth cohort with substantially higher vitamin D levels ... in public health,” states Carole Baggerly, Director of GrassrootsHealth, “the safety and ...
(Date:2/8/2016)... ... February 08, 2016 , ... Joshua Rosenthal, PhD, Chief Scientific ... can use newly released government data on populations and physicians to better calculate ... capture the value they create to succeed in new economic models for value ...
(Date:2/8/2016)... , ... February 08, 2016 , ... ... only four states in the U.S. require dental technicians to be certified or ... the dental industry, NADL created the “What’s In Your Mouth?” campaign to inform ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/9/2016)... report "Global Anti-Bacterial Drugs Market Assessment & Forecast: 2015 - 2019" ... North America continued to lead global anti-bacterial ... into revenues worth US$ 16,907.3 million. North ... , Latin America , Middle-East ... market is inclined towards North America and ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... BETHESDA, Md. , Feb. 9, 2016 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ ... community for pharmaceutical professionals developing and manufacturing sterile ... Global Sterile Manufacturing Regulatory Guidance Comparison – With ... regulatory guidance documents issued by the U.S. FDA, ... World Health Organization. --> ...
(Date:2/8/2016)... Feb.8, 2016 Alzheimer Diagnostic Tests - ... Medical Devices sector report , "Alzheimer Diagnostic ... an overview of Alzheimer Diagnostic Tests currently in ... on the pipeline products with comparative analysis of ... report reviews major players involved in the pipeline ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: