Navigation Links
Presumed consent not answer to solving organ shortage in US, researchers say
Date:11/29/2011

Removing organs for transplant unless person explicitly opts out of donation before death not best way to address scarcity, raises sticky ethical questions

Changing the organ donation process in this country from opt-in -- by, say, checking a box on a driver's license application -- to opt-out, which presumes someone's willingness to donate after death unless they explicitly object while alive, would not be likely to increase the donation rate in the United States, new Johns Hopkins research suggests.

Some organ donation advocates have pushed for a switch to an opt-out system, arguing it would be a positive step toward addressing the nation's profound organ shortage. They say most people support donation but never formally record their wishes and that an opt-out system -- known commonly as presumed consent -- might ease the burden of decision-making on grieving families at the time of death. Many thousands of people die every year waiting for organs that never come, and many viable organs are never made available for donation.

"Opt-out is not the magic bullet; it will not be the magic answer we have been looking for," says Dorry L. Segev, M.D., Ph.D., an associate professor of surgery at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and leader of the study published online in the journal Transplantation. "With opt-out the perception becomes, We will take your organs unless you take the time to fill out a form. That's a dangerous perception to have. We only want to use donated organs from people who intended to donate."

Enforcing an opt-out policy raises tricky ethical questions and could challenge the relationship between the transplant community and the general public, which should be mutually supportive, Segev adds.

Segev and his team conducted in-depth interviews with transplant experts in 13 European nations with presumed consent legislation. They found that, despite the laws, the process of organ do
'/>"/>

Contact: Stephanie Desmon
sdesmon1@jhmi.edu
410-955-8665
Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Congresswoman Maloney To Be Keynote Speaker: Momentum Builds for Hysterectomy Informed Consent Legislation
2. Clinical trials abroad: Making non-English language consent forms readable
3. Clinical trials: Comprehension unaffected by simplified consent forms or payment
4. Parents experience difficulty with consent process in pediatric cancer trials
5. Increased age of sexual consent in Canada may not protect teens at greatest risk: UBC study
6. Informed-consent forms should be shortened, simplified, Johns Hopkins bioethicists confirm
7. Informed-Consent Forms for HIV Research Too Long: Study
8. Penn-developed online informed consent tool could boost number of patients in cancer clinical trials
9. New Book Reveals How Qigong Could Be The Eastern Answer To Botox
10. SciAnswers.com Grows and Adds a Technical and Healthcare Professionals Job Board.
11. BestFoodFacts.org -- Food, Fiber and Fuel Questions Answered
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/4/2015)... Greifensee, Switzerland (PRWEB) May 04, 2015 ... entitled “ The Importance of Data Integrity in ... Bob McDowall as guest presenter. This webinar will ... EDT (15:00 GMT). , Data integrity is a ... information submitted to regulatory agencies. However, in recent ...
(Date:5/4/2015)... 04, 2015 Ticket Down is a reputable ... Cup (ICC) . While the World Cup is the ... every four years, the International Champions Cup is one of ... the all-time attendance record for soccer in the United States ... House at the University of Michigan. This year, the defending ...
(Date:5/4/2015)... May 04, 2015 Los Angeles ... offering a more comfortable and attractive alternative for patients ... choice for those who have lost teeth. Unfortunately, they ... insecure or slip at the worst possible moment and ... talks. They can also painfully pinch or rub gums, ...
(Date:5/4/2015)... Chicago, Ill., (PRWEB) May 04, 2015 ... the American Brain Tumor Association (ABTA) show that people ... their diagnosis and treatment options, including clinical trials, at ... of days to make difficult decisions about their course ... the launch of the first nationwide brain tumor volunteer ...
(Date:5/4/2015)... San Diego, CA (PRWEB) May 04, 2015 ... hosted a ribbon cutting ceremony at their brand new, ... of this year. The new building will not only ... patient population, but will also offer community and educational ... , The new facility is located next door to ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:METTLER TOLEDO Announces Live Webinar on the Importance of Data Integrity in a GXP Regulated Laboratory 2Health News:Cheap 2015 International Champions Cup (ICC) Tickets: Ticket Down Slashes Ticket Prices on International Champions Cup (ICC) Presale Tickets 2Health News:Cheap 2015 International Champions Cup (ICC) Tickets: Ticket Down Slashes Ticket Prices on International Champions Cup (ICC) Presale Tickets 3Health News:Cheap 2015 International Champions Cup (ICC) Tickets: Ticket Down Slashes Ticket Prices on International Champions Cup (ICC) Presale Tickets 4Health News:Los Angeles Dental Implants Doctor, Kevin Sands DDS, Now Offers a More Comfortable and Aesthetically-Pleasing Solution to Denture-Wearers 2Health News:American Brain Tumor Association Poll Underscores Need for Greater Awareness and Education at Time of Diagnosis 2Health News:American Brain Tumor Association Poll Underscores Need for Greater Awareness and Education at Time of Diagnosis 3Health News:San Diego Fertility Center Hosted a Ribbon Cutting Ceremony at Its New, Expanded Facility 2Health News:San Diego Fertility Center Hosted a Ribbon Cutting Ceremony at Its New, Expanded Facility 3
... in Australia have called upon the federal government to ... from war in Iraq and Afghanistan. ,Doctor Robert ... War says there needs to be a specific counseling ... ,He says the lack of services and ...
... a chemotherapy drug has recently been tested in ... and found //to have significant improvement in Progression-Free ... on Phase III trial on Satraplatin has shown: ... Improvement in Progression-Free Survival ,* ...
... has information about outbreak of Avian Influenza in ... outbreaks in Pakistan, the North-Western States bordering Pakistan ... bordering areas especially to check informal/illegal trade of ... surveillance especially of poultry and in areas visited ...
... get married is a waste of breath, a US expert ... // ,William Smith, the vice president of the Sexuality, ... a six-year study commissioned by the US Congress found that ... on pushing sexual abstinence outside marriage had had no discernible ...
... on a young woman, an Australian man gouged out both her ... to be the 28-year-old woman's partner, a man of around 30 ... the incident. ,The horrific string of events began ... of a Victorian country town- Malmsbury, 100 km northwest of Melbourne. ...
... Indiana legislators in the US have decided on raising tax ... ,As per a deal agreed upon on Sunday, the ... pack and the expected additional flow to the treasury, of ... fund several health programs. ,Most of the tax ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Row in Australia Over Mental Health Support Available for Returning Soldiers 2Health News:Satraplatin Benefits Hormone Refractory Prostate Cancer Patients 2Health News:Satraplatin Benefits Hormone Refractory Prostate Cancer Patients 3Health News:Satraplatin Benefits Hormone Refractory Prostate Cancer Patients 4Health News:Satraplatin Benefits Hormone Refractory Prostate Cancer Patients 5Health News:Steps To Prevent Out-Break Of Bird Flu 2Health News:Steps To Prevent Out-Break Of Bird Flu 3Health News:Smokers to Be Taxed to Fund Healthcare for Uninsured 2
(Date:5/4/2015)... Conn. , May 4, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... market private equity firm, announced today that ... portfolio company, BioPharm Communications. BioPharm specializes in the ... programs for the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industries. ... repaid to its shareholders half of their ...
(Date:5/4/2015)... -- RadiologyAuction will have their first auction starting May 5 ... the end of the auction on May 27 th ... Cr,s, Agfa and Sony, printers and GE portable x-rays ... equipment will be available at later auctions each month ... buying and selling imaging equipment, the brokers at RadiologyAuction ...
(Date:5/4/2015)... Calif. , May 4, 2015 Rogne ... for psoriasis, today announced that preclinical and mechanism of ... at the Society of Investigative Dermatology (SID) Annual Meeting ... in Atlanta, Georgia . ... advancing the development of RON2315, a novel, low MW ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Southfield Capital and BioPharm Communications Announce Dividend Recapitalization 2RadiologyAuction Announces Event Starting On May 5th 2Rogne Bioscience to Present Data from Topical Biologic Psoriasis Program at Upcoming SID Annual Meeting 2015 2
... national reference laboratory and a worldwide leader ... offers an extensive test menu of highly ... and anatomic pathology. Owned by the University ... than half of the nation's university teaching ...
... ARUP Laboratories is a national reference laboratory ... research and development. ARUP offers an extensive ... medical tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. ... Laboratories' clients include more than half of ...
... Laboratories is a national reference laboratory and ... and development. ARUP offers an extensive test ... tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned ... clients include more than half of the ...
... national reference laboratory and a worldwide leader ... offers an extensive test menu of highly ... and anatomic pathology. Owned by the University ... than half of the nation's university teaching ...
Medicine Products: