Navigation Links
Presumed consent not answer to solving organ shortage in US, researchers say
Date:11/29/2011

Removing organs for transplant unless person explicitly opts out of donation before death not best way to address scarcity, raises sticky ethical questions

Changing the organ donation process in this country from opt-in -- by, say, checking a box on a driver's license application -- to opt-out, which presumes someone's willingness to donate after death unless they explicitly object while alive, would not be likely to increase the donation rate in the United States, new Johns Hopkins research suggests.

Some organ donation advocates have pushed for a switch to an opt-out system, arguing it would be a positive step toward addressing the nation's profound organ shortage. They say most people support donation but never formally record their wishes and that an opt-out system -- known commonly as presumed consent -- might ease the burden of decision-making on grieving families at the time of death. Many thousands of people die every year waiting for organs that never come, and many viable organs are never made available for donation.

"Opt-out is not the magic bullet; it will not be the magic answer we have been looking for," says Dorry L. Segev, M.D., Ph.D., an associate professor of surgery at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and leader of the study published online in the journal Transplantation. "With opt-out the perception becomes, We will take your organs unless you take the time to fill out a form. That's a dangerous perception to have. We only want to use donated organs from people who intended to donate."

Enforcing an opt-out policy raises tricky ethical questions and could challenge the relationship between the transplant community and the general public, which should be mutually supportive, Segev adds.

Segev and his team conducted in-depth interviews with transplant experts in 13 European nations with presumed consent legislation. They found that, despite the laws, the process of organ do
'/>"/>

Contact: Stephanie Desmon
sdesmon1@jhmi.edu
410-955-8665
Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Congresswoman Maloney To Be Keynote Speaker: Momentum Builds for Hysterectomy Informed Consent Legislation
2. Clinical trials abroad: Making non-English language consent forms readable
3. Clinical trials: Comprehension unaffected by simplified consent forms or payment
4. Parents experience difficulty with consent process in pediatric cancer trials
5. Increased age of sexual consent in Canada may not protect teens at greatest risk: UBC study
6. Informed-consent forms should be shortened, simplified, Johns Hopkins bioethicists confirm
7. Informed-Consent Forms for HIV Research Too Long: Study
8. Penn-developed online informed consent tool could boost number of patients in cancer clinical trials
9. New Book Reveals How Qigong Could Be The Eastern Answer To Botox
10. SciAnswers.com Grows and Adds a Technical and Healthcare Professionals Job Board.
11. BestFoodFacts.org -- Food, Fiber and Fuel Questions Answered
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/31/2015)... New York (PRWEB) , ... August 31, 2015 , ... ... autumn, when play-offs and the World Series will dominate the sports world. Fans desire ... and eventually advance to the final series. For children, especially those who are too ...
(Date:8/31/2015)... , ... August 31, 2015 , ... ... Month 2015 in September by sharing the facts about the role of heredity ... and BRCA2 genetic mutations because of Angelina Jolie Pitt’s decisions to have both ...
(Date:8/31/2015)... ... August 31, 2015 , ... ... airway management device that could effectively deliver oxygen with a lower risk of ... a better way, I invented the Adam Device." , The Adam Device offers ...
(Date:8/31/2015)... , ... August 31, 2015 , ... A year ago ... team is preparing to release a new issue commemorating the successful first year. ... they need for a potentially difficult time in their lives,” says Melissa Wolfert, founding ...
(Date:8/31/2015)... ... August 31, 2015 , ... The ... the use of health IT to create efficiencies in healthcare information exchange, announces ... . Taking place at the Hyatt Regency Reston in Reston, Va. from October ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:New Children's Baseball Series Offers Young Fans a Way to Celebrate the World Series 2Health News:Foundation for Women’s Cancer Alerts Women to the Facts About the Role of Heredity in Gynecologic Cancers 2Health News:Foundation for Women’s Cancer Alerts Women to the Facts About the Role of Heredity in Gynecologic Cancers 3Health News:Foundation for Women’s Cancer Alerts Women to the Facts About the Role of Heredity in Gynecologic Cancers 4Health News:InventHelp® Client's Invents Medical Device to Restore Respiratory Function (BGF-905) 2Health News:Seniors Guide Magazine Celebrates Its First Year in Columbus With A Special Anniversary Issue 2Health News:Seniors Guide Magazine Celebrates Its First Year in Columbus With A Special Anniversary Issue 3Health News:WEDI Announces Program for Annual Fall Conference: WEDI-Con 2015 2Health News:WEDI Announces Program for Annual Fall Conference: WEDI-Con 2015 3
... WASHINGTON, Nov. 20 POLITICO recently published an ... America (PhRMA) Senior Vice President Ken Johnson. In the ... PhRMA,s commitment to supporting this historic effort. , Johnson states ... growing and reiterates PhRMA,s position that everyone in ...
... , LOS ANGELES, Nov. 20 As we approach ... people in Los Angeles sadly don,t have enough to eat. To ... of Philadelphia. Children, workers, people you see every day are hungry ... continues to increase. , The Jewish Federation of Greater Los ...
... be removed by surgery) liver cancer, an interventional radiology ... a liver transplant may significantly increase a patient,s chance ... the December issue of the American Journal of ... most common cancer in the world and is responsible ...
... adults who have alcohol dependence problems drink significantly more than ... has found. The findings suggest that older problem drinkers ... drink even more than younger abusers to achieve the effects ... adults over age 60 who have alcohol dependence drink more ...
... Patient Advocate Foundation (PAF) is a national, non-profit ... with chronic, life-threatening and debilitating diseases. Last year, ... 9.5 million contacts for information. PAF,s companion ... national, non-profit organization dedicated to the mission of creating ...
... ... the Dobbs Ferry Pavilion of St. John,s Riverside Hospital announced it has been granted a ... Breast Center is the only medical facility in Westchester County - and one of only ... ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:The Jewish Federation Unveils Blueprint to End Hunger in Los Angeles 2Health News:The Jewish Federation Unveils Blueprint to End Hunger in Los Angeles 3Health News:Older problem drinkers use more alcohol than do their younger counterparts 2Health News:Statement by the Scientific Advisory Board of the Patient Advocate Foundation/National Patient Advocate Foundation on Changes to the USPSTF Mammography Guidelines 2Health News:Ashikari Breast Center Receives Full Accreditation from National Accreditation Program for Breast Centers 2Health News:Ashikari Breast Center Receives Full Accreditation from National Accreditation Program for Breast Centers 3
(Date:8/31/2015)... 31, 2015 BioLight ... BLGTY) ("BioLight" or the "Company"), a firm that ... ophthalmology and cancer diagnostics, today announced that its ... identified several new genetic markers with high potential ... treated with bisphosphonate drugs and was able to ...
(Date:8/31/2015)... Premune and Innovet ... licensing agreement for Redonyl ® Ultra. The product, ... veterinary dermatology market, is a nutritional supplement based on ... in dogs and cats. Redonyl ® Ultra is ... has been received positively in the country by veterinarians ...
(Date:8/31/2015)... DUBLIN , Aug. 31, 2015 ... the addition of the "Prescription Pain Drugs ... Medical Marijuana - Global Markets, Competitors and Opportunities: ... to their offering. Pain is ... associated with actual or potential tissue damage. At ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:BioLight Reports Positive Clinical Study Results for Identifying New Genetic Markers to Predict Risk of Developing BRONJ 2BioLight Reports Positive Clinical Study Results for Identifying New Genetic Markers to Predict Risk of Developing BRONJ 3BioLight Reports Positive Clinical Study Results for Identifying New Genetic Markers to Predict Risk of Developing BRONJ 4Premune Broadens Portfolio With Novel Innovet Skin Health Product 2Premune Broadens Portfolio With Novel Innovet Skin Health Product 3Premune Broadens Portfolio With Novel Innovet Skin Health Product 4Prescription Pain Drugs Including Opioid, Anticonvulsant, Injectable/ Inhaled, Topical/ Transdermal, Medical Marijuana - 2015-2020 Analysis and Forecasts 2Prescription Pain Drugs Including Opioid, Anticonvulsant, Injectable/ Inhaled, Topical/ Transdermal, Medical Marijuana - 2015-2020 Analysis and Forecasts 3
Silicone Elastomer-Coated Latex Foley Catheters 2-Way (Pediatric)...
Midstream Catch Kits...
Midstream Catch Kits...
... BVM 6500 enables physicians ... determine UEBW (ultrasound estimated ... volume using 3-dimensional V-mode ... was designed to assist ...
Medicine Products: