Navigation Links
Presumed consent not answer to solving organ shortage in US, researchers say
Date:11/29/2011

Removing organs for transplant unless person explicitly opts out of donation before death not best way to address scarcity, raises sticky ethical questions

Changing the organ donation process in this country from opt-in -- by, say, checking a box on a driver's license application -- to opt-out, which presumes someone's willingness to donate after death unless they explicitly object while alive, would not be likely to increase the donation rate in the United States, new Johns Hopkins research suggests.

Some organ donation advocates have pushed for a switch to an opt-out system, arguing it would be a positive step toward addressing the nation's profound organ shortage. They say most people support donation but never formally record their wishes and that an opt-out system -- known commonly as presumed consent -- might ease the burden of decision-making on grieving families at the time of death. Many thousands of people die every year waiting for organs that never come, and many viable organs are never made available for donation.

"Opt-out is not the magic bullet; it will not be the magic answer we have been looking for," says Dorry L. Segev, M.D., Ph.D., an associate professor of surgery at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and leader of the study published online in the journal Transplantation. "With opt-out the perception becomes, We will take your organs unless you take the time to fill out a form. That's a dangerous perception to have. We only want to use donated organs from people who intended to donate."

Enforcing an opt-out policy raises tricky ethical questions and could challenge the relationship between the transplant community and the general public, which should be mutually supportive, Segev adds.

Segev and his team conducted in-depth interviews with transplant experts in 13 European nations with presumed consent legislation. They found that, despite the laws, the process of organ donation in those countries does not differ dramatically from the process in countries, such as the United States, that require explicit consent. They also found that the United States ranked third among the nations surveyed in rates of organ donation from the deceased, with 26.3 deceased donors per million population. Only Spain (34.1) and Portugal (26.7) did better.

"It does not appear that by simply having presumed consent legislation on the books that donation rates will rise," says Brian J. Boyarsky, the Hopkins researcher who conducted the interviews.

Segev says that in the United States, whether or not someone is declared as an organ donor prior to death, physicians will approach family members and ask whether they would still like to donate their loved one's organs. The family gets to make the final decision, regardless of the deceased's stated intentions, Segev says.

What he and his colleagues learned was that even in the countries with presumed consent, donation was still discussed with the potential donor's family at the time of death, even though doctors were legally permitted to transplant those organs. In six of the 13 countries, there is actually a legal requirement that doctors speak with relatives. This is done to be transparent with the family about the donation process and to obtain a complete medical and social history of the potential donor. Donation would not proceed if the family objected, just as in the United States, in all but one of the countries surveyed (Portugal), the researchers found. This is because of a fear of negative press, the participants told Segev's team, and a desire to respect the wishes of the grieving family so as to prevent psychological harm.

Implementing presumed consent legislation, Segev argues, would take a huge amount of time and energy with minimal payoff. Many countries with presumed consent have much lower rates of organ donation than the United States, he notes.

Segev says there are still lessons to learn from countries like Spain, whose donation rate far surpasses the United States. In Spain, there are dedicated physicians at every hospital who are knowledgeable about transplant issues and who screen for potential donors, manage their care and approach families. He believes these dedicated physicians are a key reason why Spain has a higher rate of donation, not the mere existence of presumed consent.

"We need to foster more awareness of transplantation and transplant issues to procure more organs for lifesaving transplants rather than force people to donate their relatives' organs if they fail to opt-out before death," he says.

The most important thing, Segev adds, "is that people need to be very clear with their next of kin while they are still alive about whether or not they want to be organ donors. That's who will ultimately make the decision."


'/>"/>
Contact: Stephanie Desmon
sdesmon1@jhmi.edu
410-955-8665
Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Congresswoman Maloney To Be Keynote Speaker: Momentum Builds for Hysterectomy Informed Consent Legislation
2. Clinical trials abroad: Making non-English language consent forms readable
3. Clinical trials: Comprehension unaffected by simplified consent forms or payment
4. Parents experience difficulty with consent process in pediatric cancer trials
5. Increased age of sexual consent in Canada may not protect teens at greatest risk: UBC study
6. Informed-consent forms should be shortened, simplified, Johns Hopkins bioethicists confirm
7. Informed-Consent Forms for HIV Research Too Long: Study
8. Penn-developed online informed consent tool could boost number of patients in cancer clinical trials
9. New Book Reveals How Qigong Could Be The Eastern Answer To Botox
10. SciAnswers.com Grows and Adds a Technical and Healthcare Professionals Job Board.
11. BestFoodFacts.org -- Food, Fiber and Fuel Questions Answered
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... January 23, 2017 , ... Zachary Cattell, President of the ... healthcare industry expert at the 2017 Sector Summit hosted by Ivy Tech Community ... host Gerry Dick, will feature an employer and an association representative from five ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... January 23, 2017 , ... Moisture measurement is a necessary ... is paramount to success. Selecting an inappropriate measurement method can cause costly errors, ... the same equipment. Rare or expensive substances are wasted and production may even ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... California (PRWEB) , ... January 23, 2017 , ... "ProRandom is a set of camera ... to create dynamic looks in Final Cut Pro X," said Christina Austin - CEO of ... up to two layers of text with video footage. ProRandom works by using a ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... IL (PRWEB) , ... January ... ... and Education Foundation (OREF), in partnership with the American Society of Anesthesiologists® ... Safety Foundation (APSF), the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) and the ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... , ... January 23, 2017 , ... “The Inn at the Mill”: a story ... fears in her quest to become happy and content. , “The Inn at the ... has also lived in Germany and Vermont and is now living in Berks County on ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/24/2017)... NEW YORK , Jan. 23, 2017 /PRNewswire/ ... a long way from conventional syringes with vials ... free systems. These modern devices have become preferred ... demand for prefilled syringes has been rising strongly ... of healthcare facilities are now adopting this format ...
(Date:1/24/2017)... , January 23, 2017 ... Growth A majority of medicines ... formulating Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (API), and such processes require ... glycol. Production of pharmaceutical solvents continues to ... excluding Japan (APEJ) region as ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... 23, 2017 Endo International plc (NASDAQ / ... today filed a joint motion in the U.S. District ... seeking the entry of a ten-year Stipulated ... disputes between the FTC and Endo relating to the ... its Opana® ER and Lidoderm® products.  It also resolves ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: