Navigation Links
Picking quality health care: New study shows a little context makes a big difference
Date:9/10/2009

WASHINGTON A hospital pneumonia survival rate of 93 percent may sound good, but knowing that it's actually merely "fair" can help people pick a better hospital, according to new research. A "good" survival rate would be from 95 percent to 98 percent, medical experts say.

Better use of quality-of-care ratings can lead to greater consumer control, more effective health-care choices, and provider competition over quality instead of cost, says a report published by the American Psychological Association.

The findings are timely, given the ongoing debate over health-care and health-insurance reform. Providers and the media are showering decision-makers with raw numbers about everything from those pneumonia survival rates to the percentage of heart attack patients given key drugs and post-stay patient ratings. Typical measurements describe hospitals, nursing homes, doctors, treatments and health-insurance plans.

When it's hard to interpret the numbers, people are tempted to choose based on cost, such as monthly premiums, or even how they feel at the moment, said a report on the research, which was published in the September issue of the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied.

In four different studies, researchers asked people to pick fictional hospitals and health-insurance plans based on cost and quality-of-care data. Across the studies, getting the numbers in context strongly influenced decisions. People took quality data into account to a significantly greater degree when they were shown how the experts would rate the information.

When participants saw quality ratings expressed in context, in ranges such as "good," "fair" and "poor," they weighed quality more and cost less than participants who saw the same numbers out of context, the researchers found. For example, when choosing health-insurance plans, 54 percent of participants chose a higher-quality plan when given its numbers in context, while 39 percent chose it when given numbers out of context. Similarly, among older adults, 54 percent chose higher-quality plans when the numbers were evaluated; only 35 percent chose them when the numbers were without context.

Participants shown how to evaluate health-care data also leaned less on their momentary moods, which had nothing to do with quality measures.

The four studies involved 303 people age 18 to 64; 207 participants age 65 to 99 (an important group given the choices faced by older adults); 218 people age 18 to 51; and 83 students up to age 37. The studies were led by Ellen Peters, PhD, of Decision Research, a non-profit research group in Eugene, Ore., and the University of Oregon.

Being helped to interpret the numbers made the biggest difference for people who were less good with numbers generally. For them, such guidance helped them rise above the passing moods that they reported.

"Information providers cannot present 'just the facts,'" the authors wrote. If helped to integrate quality-of-care information into their judgments and reduce reliance on cost, people can make better decisions, they asserted.

The same goes for those making public policy and allocating health-care dollars. "Decision-makers need help in interpreting not only what the numbers are but what they mean," wrote the authors.

"Without [such help], today's world of instantaneous information could lead to a greater influence of irrelevant sources of affect [mood] and emotion, especially for the less numerate among us."


'/>"/>

Contact: Public Affairs Office
public.affairs@apa.org
202-336-5700
American Psychological Association
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Are we cherry picking participants for studies of antidepressants?
2. Picking the Right Toys Isnt Childs Play
3. Paragon Technologies SI Systems Brand Awarded A $1.0 Million System Expansion Contract for an Automated Light-Picking System
4. Regions Hospital Selected to Participate in National Cardiac Care Quality Improvement Effort
5. WRX Launches National Labor Efficiency Quality Award
6. California Walnut Industry Delivers High-Quality Crop
7. FaxBack Announces a New VoIP Fax ATA, based on HTTPS, Which Provides a Level of Quality for VoIP Faxing Equal to PSTN Connections
8. Patients pretreatment quality of life can predict overall lung cancer survival
9. San Francisco Health Plan Recognized as Top Health Plan for Quality in the California Medi-Cal Program
10. Michigan Chamber of Commerce Joins Employers for Quality Health Care; Calls for Health Care Reform - But Not If It Raises Taxes, Kills Jobs
11. Emerson Ecologics Introduces the Emerson Quality Partner(TM) Program
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:3/24/2017)... , ... March 24, 2017 , ... The Radiology ... Quest Awards . The annual awards, now in their 12th year, are among the ... the winners. , In 2016, the awards were retooled to recognize achievements in both ...
(Date:3/24/2017)... ... March 24, 2017 , ... ... Premier Center for Shamanic Healing and Spiritual Awakening, proudly presents her Sacred ... 2017. This sacred and spiritual journey during the Summer Solstice will also ...
(Date:3/24/2017)... ... 2017 , ... The law firm of Enea, Scanlan & Sirignano, LLP, ... resident Lauren C. Enea has joined the firm as an associate attorney. Ms. Enea, ... in elder law, Medicaid planning and applications, and Wills, Trusts and Estates. Samantha ...
(Date:3/24/2017)... ... 2017 , ... “Finding Christ Through Social Media: Year One ... the writer’s path toward true communion with God. “Finding Christ Through Social Media: ... creation of published author Lea Michelle Johnson, a follower of Christ, wife and ...
(Date:3/23/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... March 23, 2017 , ... In 2016 ... now estimates that there could be four million Zika-related cases in the Americas within ... with numbers of US cases reported per year skyrocketing to an estimated 329,000. Yet, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:3/24/2017)... 2017   The Accreditation Council for Medical ... in the pharmaceutical industry has appointed Dr. ... newly formed scientific advisory board. Dr. Chin will ... first ever medical affairs think tank within the ... the ACMA, please visit  www.medicalaffairsspecialist.org .  Connect ...
(Date:3/24/2017)... DUBLIN , Mar. 24, 2017 Research and ... (IPF) Pipeline Analysis, 2016" report to their offering. ... The IPF pipeline is very strong with ... Corporation, Merck & Co., Inc., Biogen and Sanofi are involved in the ... candidates, of which one is in Phase III stage, 15 are in ...
(Date:3/24/2017)... , March 24, 2017 Today ... Equipment stocks, which are: Neovasc Inc. (NASDAQ: NVCN), Hologic Inc. ... Inc. (NASDAQ: SSH ). These companies are part ... prior gains on Thursday, March 23 rd , 2017, with ... while shares of health care companies in the S&P 500 ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: