Navigation Links
Physician calls for more rigorous standards for drugs up for FDA approval
Date:3/9/2010

A hospitalist at the University of Rochester Medical Center calls for more stringent Federal guidelines governing the approval of potential new drugs, in a commentary in the March 10 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Alec B. O'Connor, M.D., M.P.H., associate professor in the Hospital Medicine Division of the Department of Medicine, says that while the U.S. Food and Drug Administration does an "incredible job, considering its long list of responsibilities and budget constraints," the agency should be empowered to demand more detailed data when a new drug is being considered for approval.

O'Connor's main point is that the FDA should require studies comparing the effectiveness and safety of a new drug to an established first-line drug when considering a drug for approval. Currently the agency does not require such studies, known as "active comparator trials," though some large studies of new drugs do include them. In many cases, to gain approval, the main criterion besides safety is that a new drug must be shown to be more effective than placebo.

"When new medications have been compared only to placebo, not to drugs already on the market, it's very difficult to know whether and how we should prescribe them to patients," O'Connor said. "For example, if a new medication to treat depression is approved based only on placebo comparisons, it's very difficult to know how the new drug compares with the dozens of medications already approved for depression. Faced with the extensive and very successful marketing undertaken by the drug manufacturer, oftentimes physicians will assume that the newer drug is more effective or has important advantages over older treatments, even though there may be no evidence showing that to be so."

"The current system makes it very difficult to evaluate a new, more expensive treatment against an established, less expensive option," added O'Connor. "We should consider a different standard for approval that a drug not just outperform placebo, but that it also undergo direct comparison with at least one treatment considered the standard of care. In this way we can ensure that new, less effective treatments do not replace older, more effective and cheaper ones. Requiring new drugs to be compared with established treatments before drug approval would also decrease the amount of federally funded comparative effectiveness research required down the road."

O'Connor began studying issues related to drug approval a few years ago, when he began a meta-analysis of the effectiveness of approved medications to treat severe nerve pain, known as neuropathic pain. With the help of colleagues, he was able to unearth a great deal of information from unpublished studies available deep within the FDA web site. Oftentimes these studies contained negative data about new medications information that was largely unknown in the medical community.

In his commentary, O'Connor calls for revisions to the Code of Federal Regulations, which spells out the guidelines FDA uses to evaluate new medications. O'Connor notes that Congress, not FDA, sets the guidelines that FDA follows.

Last year O'Connor published another commentary in JAMA drawing attention to the availability of information about new drugs through FDA and suggesting ways to make the data easier to find for physicians and others.

"The FDA has its own statisticians who analyze data and arrive at their own conclusions regarding studies," said O'Connor. "They have no financial conflict of interest, and there is no pressure to produce favorable results for a drug. Such an independent analysis is a gold mine for researchers and physicians seeking information about the safety and efficacy of a medication that has recently been approved.

"I have a huge amount of respect for FDA. The amount of time and effort the agency puts into each new drug review is incredible. They do an incredible task with a finite amount of time and resources. The FDA is an ally in maintaining public health and protecting our patients," he added.


'/>"/>

Contact: Tom Rickey
tom_rickey@urmc.rochester.edu
585-275-7954
University of Rochester Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Increased distance to physician associated with thicker skin cancer at diagnosis
2. Broad-based group of physicians calls for improvement in stroke treatment
3. Latest DES Analysis Stresses Importance of Physicians Well-Trained in Implantation Technique and Patient Follow-Up
4. Psychiatrists are the least religious of all physicians
5. Physician Skin Care Specialist Says Proposed New Rules for Sunscreen Products Will Better Protect the Public
6. One of the Largest Post-WHI Physician Surveys Shows More Education is Needed: Patient Misinformation About Hormone Therapy Remains High
7. Texas Largest Physician Carrier Announces 5th Successive Rate Cut on Anniversary of Lawsuit Reform
8. Maimonides Expands Circulation of Physicians Practice Journal to Staten Island Doctors
9. Scientists, physicians present latest findings in personalized cancer treatment and prevention
10. NNN Healthcare/Office REIT Acquires St. Mary Physicians Center in Long Beach, California
11. Physician Team at Northwestern Memorial Performs Rare Oral Gallbladder Removal
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/3/2016)... ... ... Branches, Inc. is proud to have been selected as a Macy’s grant ... Miami. Macy’s is a wonderful community partner and has helped to support Branches’ student ... and academic support to elementary students 5 days a week. Summer Shade, a 7 ...
(Date:5/3/2016)... City, UT (PRWEB) , ... May 03, 2016 , ... ... Utah, recently announced that its Allegro Anti-aging Cream, a revolutionary new anti-aging skin ... signs of aging and repair damaged skin, has sold over seventy-five thousand units worldwide ...
(Date:5/3/2016)... , ... May 03, 2016 , ... Dave Newberry, broker/owner ... Interim Care Center (PICC) annual fundraiser luncheon on Friday, May 20. “We have ... the smallest victims of drug abuse,” said Newberry. , PICC is a local Kent, ...
(Date:5/2/2016)... ... 2016 , ... RNK Products, Inc. (RNK) is beta testing ... the stethoscope stream to go over the video conferencing audio channel. This ... , Remote auscultation involves two software elements on the PC: , 1)    Network transport ...
(Date:5/2/2016)... , ... May 02, 2016 , ... ProElectric Cartoon is ... Pro X. Pick and choose from a variety of electric styles including zap, sizzles, ... Users can customize shadow, dof blur, three dimensional rotation, and much more. ProElectric Cartoon’s ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/2/2016)... YORK , May 2, 2016 Kalorama ... EMR (Electronic Medical Records) market in a recent white ... sales, vendor switches, Increased physician usage, a growing market are ... were noted in Kalorama,s report EMR 2016: ... report marks Kalorama,s seventh complete study of the EMR ...
(Date:5/2/2016)...  Celsion Corporation (NASDAQ: CLSN ), an ... the first cohort of patients in its Phase ... combining GEN-1, the Company,s DNA-based immunotherapy, with the ... patients with advanced ovarian cancer who will undergo ... the first three patients dosed, GEN-1 plus standard ...
(Date:4/29/2016)... Jersey , April 29, 2016 ... Suite for Life Sciences, Product Development Capabilities in ... Life Science Customer Base . ... provider, today announced the acquisition of Skura Corporation,s ... global leader in adaptive sales enablement technology for ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: