Navigation Links
People prefer 'carrots' to 'sticks' when it comes to healthcare incentives
Date:6/26/2013

To keep costs low, companies often incentivize healthy lifestyles. Now, new research suggests that how these incentives are framed as benefits for healthy-weight people or penalties for overweight people makes a big difference.

The research, published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science, shows that policies that carry higher premiums for overweight individuals are perceived as punishing and stigmatizing.

Researcher David Tannenbaum of the Anderson School of Management at the University of California, Los Angeles wanted to investigate how framing healthcare incentives might influence people's attitudes toward the incentives.

"Two frames that are logically equivalent can communicate qualitatively different messages," Tannenbaum explains.

In the first study, 126 participants read about a fictional company grappling with managing their employee health-care policy. They were told that the company was facing rising healthcare costs, due in part to an increasing percentage of overweight employees, and were shown one of four final policy decisions.

The "carrot" plan gave a $500 premium reduction to healthy-weight people, while the "stick" plan increased premiums for overweight people by $500. The two plans were functionally equivalent, structured such that healthy-weight employees always paid $2000 per year in healthcare costs, and overweight employees always paid $2500 per year in healthcare costs.

There were also two additional "stick" plans that resulted in a $2400 premium for overweight people.

Participants were more likely to see the "stick" plans as punishment for being overweight and were less likely to endorse them.

But they didn't appear to differentiate between the three "stick" plans despite the $100 premium difference. Instead, they seemed to evaluate the plans on moral grounds, deciding that punishing someone for being overweight was wrong regardless of the potential savings to be had.

The data showed that framing incentives in terms of penalties may have particular psychological consequences for affected individuals: People with higher body mass index (BMI) scores reported that they would feel particularly stigmatized and dissatisfied with their employer under the three "stick" plans.

Another study placed participants in the decision maker's seat to see if "stick" and "carrot" plans actually reflected different underlying attitudes. Participants who showed high levels of bias against overweight people were more likely to choose the "stick" plan, but provided different justification depending on whether their bias was explicit or implicit:

"Participants who explicitly disliked overweight people were forthcoming about their decision, admitting that they chose a 'stick' policy on the basis of personal attitudes," noted Tannenbaum. "Participants who implicitly disliked overweight people, in contrast, justified their decisions based on the most economical course of action."

Ironically, if they were truly focused on economic concerns they should have opted for the "carrot" plan, since it would save the company $100 per employee. Instead, these participants tended to choose the strategy that effectively punished overweight people, even in instances when the "stick" policy implied a financial cost to the company.

Tannenbaum concludes that these framing effects may have important consequences across many different real-world domains:

"In a broad sense, our research affects policymakers at large," says Tannenbaum. "Logically equivalent policies in various domains such as setting a default option for organ donation or retirement savings can communicate very different messages, and understanding the nature of these messages could help policymakers craft more effective policy."


'/>"/>

Contact: Anna Mikulak
amikulak@psychologicalscience.org
202-293-9300
Association for Psychological Science
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. For Fourth of July, People from over 190 Countries Shared Emotions of Pride, Patriotism and Celebration From 123Greetings.com
2. Lakeland, Florida Joins Best Halfway House Recovery Network, Providing Resources for People Seeking More Support in Their Recovery from Drug and Alcohol Addiction
3. Yoga Course
4. “Shapeshifter Yoga” Teaches People How to Learn Yoga Easily and Quickly – V-kool
5. Healthy Food Recipes
6. “Honey Garlic And Vinegar Miracle” Teaches People How To Make Healthy Meals – Health Review
7. New Mirena IUD Complications Lawsuits Allegations Report: Resource4thePeople Reports Important Multidistrict Litigation Hearing Scheduled
8. Key West, Florida Joins Best Halfway House Recovery Network, Helping People Seek Further Recovery from Drug and Alcohol Addiction
9. David Icke to Launch Global TV and Radio Station Called The People's Voice
10. Arc Creates Huge Mosaic Mural to Highlight the Need for Greater Respect of People with Disabilities
11. New Evidence Based Information on Treatment for Over 8 Million People in the U.S. Affected With Disorders of the Vestibular System
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:6/23/2017)... , ... June 23, 2017 , ... ... Act (BCRA), their proposed healthcare bill to repeal and replace the Affordable Care ... Senate bill would make significant cuts to Medicaid, a public health insurance program ...
(Date:6/23/2017)... ... June 23, 2017 , ... Everybody has their own ... others prefer to read it, and some people don't like it at all. FindaTopDoc ... what they found: , Erotic literature can give readers a taste of their deepest, ...
(Date:6/23/2017)... ... June 23, 2017 , ... 21 Middle East and South Asia Leaders ... leaders from government, business and civil society in 11 countries across the Middle East ... engaging in a transformative exchange of knowledge and ideas with the leading minds in ...
(Date:6/23/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... June 23, 2017 , ... Ulster University, ... June, 2017 from 9 am to 3 pm to present to graduate students exciting ... is an original curriculum project led by The Health Improvement Service of the ...
(Date:6/23/2017)... ... June 23, 2017 , ... Moore Insurance, an eastern ... access to asset protection and financial planning services, is teaming up with the ... lives of children with cancer and other chronic diseases. , The For A ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:6/16/2017)... WAYNE, N.J. , June 16, 2017 Datascope Corp. ... sold by Datascope Corp. for a potential electrical test failure code.     ... PRODUCT PART NUMBER ... CS100 IABP CS300 IABP ... ...
(Date:6/13/2017)... June 13, 2017 Zimmer Biomet Holdings, Inc. (NYSE ... announced that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has ... 2015 relating to its Zhejiang, China ... "The successful clearance of the Warning Letter related ... facility is a measure of the progress we have made ...
(Date:6/9/2017)... , June 9, 2017 More than 400 ... effort to help spread lessons learned from clinical research ... Diabetes Federation (IDF) and Eli Lilly and Company (NYSE: ... second phase of the Bringing Research in Diabetes to ... commitment to helping people with diabetes effectively manage their ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: