Navigation Links
Pediatricians Say No to Expulsions, Suspensions at Schools

By Amy Norton
HealthDay Reporter

MONDAY, Feb. 25 (HealthDay News) -- Suspending or expelling a child from school should be a rare last resort and not a routine punishment for bullying, drug use or other infractions, according to a new policy statement from the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP).

The AAP, a leading group of pediatricians, said school "zero-tolerance" policies toward kids' behavior problems do no good.

If the parents are at work when a child is out of school, more inappropriate behavior often occurs, the authors said in the statement, which was published online Feb. 25 in the journal Pediatrics. Students who are suspended or expelled are more likely to never get a high school diploma, end up in the juvenile justice system or eventually land a low-paying job or no job at all.

"There's a tremendous price to pay not just for the kid involved, but for society," said Dr. Jeffrey Lamont, a pediatrician at Marshfield Clinic in Weston, Wis., who wrote the new AAP statement.

But if zero-tolerance policies keep troublemakers out of school, don't the "good" kids benefit? That's not what the research shows, Lamont said.

What's more, Lamont said, the policies are not only targeting kids who are a danger to their peers but also students with a wide range of behavior issues.

U.S. schools started turning to the zero-tolerance approach in the 1980s, as a way to curb drug use and violence. The idea got a boost in the 1990s with the passage of the Gun-Free School Zone Act, which required schools to expel students caught with firearms on school grounds.

"The problem was that schools adopted zero-tolerance policies that extended to lesser offenses, like disrespecting a teacher," Lamont said.

In 2006, a task force set up by the American Psychological Association found after a decade of research that there was no evidence that zero-tolerance policies had made schools any safer or helped kids' school performances. But there was evidence, the task force found, that the policies were disproportionately targeting black and Hispanic kids.

"You have to ask yourself why that is," Lamont said.

The AAP had no estimate for how many U.S. school districts had zero-tolerance policies. But they are "very common," said Katherine Cowan, director of communications for the National Association of School Psychologists.

Cowan said the new AAP policy is in line with her group's thinking on the issue. "It's great to have pediatricians weighing in on this now," she said, noting that pediatricians play a big role in spotting kids' behavioral and health issues early on.

Cowan said there are "obvious, silly examples" of zero-tolerance being too rigidly applied, such as suspending elementary school kids because their parents packed a butter knife with their lunch. Last month, a Pennsylvania kindergartener was suspended for threatening classmates with her Hello Kitty "bubble gun."

Most often, however, suspensions and expulsions are doled out when kids do misbehave. The issue, Lamont and Cowan said, is that the punishment doesn't fit the crime.

"And we have alternatives that are proven to work," Cowan said.

One example the AAP points to is a program called Positive Behavioral Interventions & Supports, already used in more than 16,000 U.S. schools. Many state education departments have "technical assistance" centers that help schools implement the plan.

The program's goal is to prevent behavior problems or keep them from escalating. The first step is for schools to come up with expectations for all students' behavior -- such as keeping your hands to yourself when you're in the hallway or speaking up when you see a student being bullied -- and making those expectations clear.

The response to rule-breaking is also made clear; if it's minor, a teacher might handle it with a simple reminder of the school's expectations. If it's serious, parents might be called in or the child might get counseling from a school psychologist or other professional.

The other key is that kids are also recognized for good behavior, Lamont said. "Put yourself in the kids' place," he said. "Not many adults would stay with a job where all they hear is criticism. Why do we expect something from children that we wouldn't expect of adults?"

Lamont said there is evidence that the program does improve behavior problems in schools. "From the federal government on down, people support this," he said.

Cowan said that although many schools still have zero-tolerance policies, a shift is taking place. "I think we are seeing a trend of schools moving away from it," she said, "because the research is pretty clear."

More information

Learn more about getting Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports into schools.

SOURCES: Jeffrey Lamont, M.D., clinical assistant professor, University of Wisconsin, Madison, and pediatrician, Marshfield Clinic, Weston, Wis.; Katherine Cowan, director, communications, National Association of School Psychologists, Bethesda, Md.; March 2013 Pediatrics

Copyright©2012 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Many Parents of Kids With Autism Dont Put Faith in Pediatricians
2. Circumcision Benefits Are Significant, Pediatricians Say
3. Pediatricians Group Urges Flu Shot for Kids Aged 6 Months and Up
4. Survey of ER docs and pediatricians highlights need for training, tools to manage kids concussions
5. Give Teens Access to Emergency Contraception, Pediatricians Say
6. Dont Cut School Recess, Pediatricians Say
7. Some Schools Dont Let Kids Carry Asthma Inhalers
8. Study: More Pre-Teens Get Vaccines When Middle Schools Require Them
9. U.S. Schools Throwing the Book at Unhealthy Drinks
10. U.S. High Schools Lax in Preventing Dating Abuse: Study
11. Sugary Sports Drinks Plentiful at U.S. Schools: Study
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Pediatricians Say No to Expulsions, Suspensions at Schools
(Date:12/1/2015)... ... December 01, 2015 , ... The workstation boundaries for ... IMAGE Information Systems launches MED-TAB™ -- the world’s first portable DICOM-calibrated medical image ... 29 to December 4, 2015. , MED-TAB is expected to change teleradiology ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... ... , ... The importance of volumetric breast density assessment for ... abstracts accepted for presentation here, at the 101st Annual Radiology Society of North ... of Volpara Solutions’ quantitative breast imaging software tools for providing breast imaging and ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... ... December 01, 2015 , ... For ... That is why Hollister Incorporated has launched the VaPro Plus Pocket™ touch free ... in the VaPro touch free catheter portfolio,” said Michael Gresavage, Vice President North ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... ... December 01, 2015 , ... SAN FRANCISCO, Calif. (December 1, ... organization has awarded Education and Developmental Therapies (EDT), an Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) ... exceptional special needs providers that excel in synthesizing the areas of clinical quality, ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... ... December 01, 2015 , ... McLean, ... been awarded a fixed price per sprint agile development contract to support the ... million over five years, provides software engineering, infrastructure, as well as operations and ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:12/1/2015)... --> --> ... by Type of Drug (Monoclonal Antibodies, Interferon-Alpha, Interleukins, Vaccines, (Therapeutic ... Analysis - Global Forecast to 2020", published by MarketsandMarkets, the ... Million by 2020 from USD 40,281.6 Million in 2015, at ... Browse 37 market data T ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... Pharma Tech Outlook recently conducted a comprehensive ... Management Solution Providers - 2015 .  After careful consideration ... CIOs, VCs, analysts, and the Pharma Tech Outlook editorial ... 10 clinical data management solution providers (check out the ... 36 respectively). --> ...
(Date:12/1/2015)... Ohio , Dec. 1, 2015 ... to its GeneSight® Psychotropic test giving healthcare providers an ... medication decisions for patients suffering from depression, anxiety, ... other behavioral health conditions. i ... --> With the addition of two ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: