Navigation Links
Partial bans on smoking don't save jobs in restaurants and bars
Date:5/18/2009

Washington, DC, May 18, 2009 Some cities and states around the country have completely banned smoking in public places. Others have instituted partial bans to avoid negative economic consequences, such as loss of employment in restaurants and bars due to reduced patronage by smokers. But a new study from Minnesota finds that there is no significant difference between partial bans, complete bans and even no bans, in terms of their impact on number of employees in restaurants and bars.

"This is the first study to compare the economic consequences of partial bans, total bans and no bans on smoking in public places. Because they don't have any differential effect on employment in restaurants and bars, it is obvious that a total ban on smoking is the only way to protect employees and patrons from second hand smoke, which is known to cause lung cancer, heart disease and respiratory diseases" according to study author Elizabeth Klein, Ph.D., MPH, Assistant Professor in the Health Behavior & Health Promotion Division of the College of Public Health at Ohio State University. Klein conducted the study while she was at the University of Minnesota. The study is published in the June issue of Prevention Science, a peer reviewed journal of the Society for Prevention Research.

Klein studied ten cities in Minnesota from 2003 to 2006, using data from the Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development. Employment was based on per capita figures to allow comparison among non-urban, small cities, suburban and large cities for a 45-month period. The range of employment in restaurants and bars across the various cities was 467 to 11, 296, and the total number of establishments ranged from 20 to 440 per city.

Communities that had a total ban on smoking in public places had 2 fewer employees per 10,000 residents compared to those without any ban on smoking. They also 9 fewer employees per 10,000 community members compared to communities with partial bans on smoking.

"These differences are not statistically significant, they are not disastrous, and they are not long-term, as are often predicted by opponents of any type of bans on smoking in public places," Klein said.

"Before Minnesota passed a complete ban on smoking in public places, some communities had complete bans; some had partial bans while others had no bans on smoking in public places. The different types of bans provided a perfect opportunity to study how these laws affected employment in restaurants and bars," according to Klein.

Klein's study covered free standing bars, which included lounges, taverns and nightclubs; and full service restaurants, which included family style restaurants, fine dining and steak houses.

Klein's paper notes that the concern for the economic health of bars was one of the reasons that led to a rollback of a county level, comprehensive clean indoor air policy in Hennepin County in Minnesota, which includes Minneapolis. The rollback in Hennepin County was eventually reversed by the comprehensive state-level ban on smoking in all public places.

"The fact that large scale changes in employment were not observed in Minnesota should be useful to policy makers across the country as they weigh the known health benefits of bans on smoking in public places against any perceived loss of employment in restaurants and bars," Klein said.


'/>"/>

Contact: Prabhu Ponkshe
prabhu@preventionresearch.org
703-918-4860
Society for Prevention Research
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. New Keppra XR(TM) Dosage Strength Offers Simplified Treatment Option for People Living With Partial-Onset Seizures
2. Marinus Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Announces Positive Results of its Phase 2 Clinical Trial of Ganaxolone as Adjunctive Therapy in Adults With Partial Onset Seizures
3. Smoking behavior partially explains socioeconomic inequities in lung cancer incidence
4. Study: Adding Vimpat significantly reduces partial-onset seizures in adults with epilepsy
5. Partial Breast Irradiation Now Provided by Rocky Mountain Oncology Center
6. LegalView Reports Record Numbers of Drug Reactions in U.S., Partially Caused by Heparin
7. Keppra XR(TM) Offers Convenient Dosing For People With Partial Onset Seizures
8. VA Partial Birth Abortion Infanticide Act Constitutional, Should Be Upheld, Argues Americans United for Life Brief
9. Care Investment Trust Inc. Announces Fourth Quarter and Partial Year 2007 Results
10. Partial Face Transplant Patient Doing Well
11. UCB Announces FDA Filing for lacosamide in the Treatment of Partial Onset Seizures in Adults with Epilepsy
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/20/2017)... ... September 20, 2017 , ... “Finn Mouseson”: follows the exciting story of a ... This mouse sets out on a journey that will show that friends are to ... of newly published author and illustrator, Melody Gersonde-Mickelson, who has earned a bachelor’s degree ...
(Date:9/20/2017)... ... September 20, 2017 , ... “Psalms of Humidity”: is ... of mind and move the readers one step closer to God. “Psalms of Humidity” ... that his mistakes that have been made within his life are the very same ...
(Date:9/20/2017)... ... September 20, 2017 , ... “They Sang At Her Funeral”: a tale ... starts revealing the skeletons in their closets. “They Sang At Her Funeral” is the ... years young and married with five children and twelve grandchildren. Before becoming a writer, ...
(Date:9/19/2017)... ... ... Only a few physicians were selected to receive the prestigious 2016 Patients' Choice ... . The founder and medical director of Clevens Face and Body Specialists , ... and the University of Michigan. He has served patients throughout Central Florida and beyond ...
(Date:9/19/2017)... ... 2017 , ... Trusted debt-reduction firm CreditAssociates, LLC has announced two important milestones. ... of $835 million in resolved debt for its clients. , Credit card debt, unpaid ... categories of debt settled by the company. With more than a decade of combined ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:9/6/2017)... N.Y. , Sept. 6, 2017   PDI , ... announced it will host an educational session focused on ... bloodstream infection (CLABSI) prevention at the 2017 Annual Scientific ... which will take place at the Phoenix ... from Sept. 16-19, will also feature PDI,s ...
(Date:9/5/2017)... Sept. 5, 2017  Xyntek Inc. has announced another milestone in their continued ... office to meet the growing demands of customer engagements regionally.  ... Xyntek's new Midwest office is located at 318 West Adams Street, ... ... regionally. ...
(Date:9/1/2017)... Michael Penna , President and CEO ... for growth in his response to the July 13, ... seeking a buyer for eMDs. Penna,s company, Complete HealthCare ... Value Added Reseller and national leader in the independent ... "As the healthcare market continues to dictate consolidation, healthcare ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: