Navigation Links
Outdated practice of annual cervical-cancer screenings may cause more harm than good
Date:7/9/2013

For decades, women between the ages of 21 and 69 were advised to get annual screening exams for cervical cancer. In 2009, however, accumulating scientific evidence led major guideline groups to agree on a new recommendation that women be screened less frequently: every three years rather than annually.

Despite the revised guidelines, about half of the obstetrician-gynecologists surveyed in a recent study said they continue to provide annual exams an outdated practice that may be more harmful than helpful, said Drs. Russell Harris and Stacey Sheridan of the Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

"Screening is not the unqualified good that we have advertised it to be," they wrote in an editorial titled, "The Times They (May Be) A-Changin': Too Much Screening is a Health Problem." The editorial accompanied a research study reviewing physician practices around cervical-cancer screening and vaccination for human papilloma virus (HPV), which has been linked to cervical cancer.

The study, "Physicians Slow to Implement HPV Vaccination and Cervical Screening Guidelines," was published July 9 in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine.

"Screening for cervical cancer and other cancers such as breast and prostate, has clear potential for harms as well as benefits, and these must be carefully weighed before a rational decision about screening can be made," wrote Harris and Sheridan, who are professor and assistant professor of medicine, respectively, at UNC's School of Medicine. They also hold adjunct appointments at UNC's Gillings School of Global Public Health.

The study noted physicians said they were comfortable with longer testing intervals, but were concerned their patients might not come in for annual check-ups if Pap tests, the screening test for cervical cancer, were not offered. The problem, Harris said, is that annual Pap tests produce more abnormal results leading to additional, invasive testing that itself bring risks.

"Many women have 'abnormal' [Pap test] findings that are not cancer, but may be a 'cancer precursor.' We know that the great majority of these abnormal findings would never progress to actual invasive cancer, yet these women are referred" for further, more invasive testing, Harris said.

One such test, called a "colposcopy," [cohl-PAH-scoh-pee], involves examining the cervix for possibly cancerous lesions, followed frequently by a biopsy, i.e., taking a small sample of the lesion, which can cause pain and bleeding, as well as potential psychological harm. "The screening test itself can raise concern about dreaded cancer; a positive screening test heightens this worry; finding a cancer precursor, even one of uncertain importance, just increases worry further," they wrote.

The authors recognize the important benefit of screening for cervical and other cancers, but "screening every three years [for cervical cancer] retains about 95 percent of the benefit of annual screening, but reduces harms by roughly two-thirds." Less-frequent screening also reduces costs significantly in terms of patient and physician time and laboratory testing supplies and other resources.

The newest cervical-cancer and HPV screening recommendations were released in March 2012, too recent to have been included in the July 9 study. Women should still begin Pap tests at age 21 and every three years afterward, but women between the ages of 30 and 65 may choose to extend the Pap test interval to every five years, provided they also get an HPV test, according to the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force and the American Cancer Society, among others. However, the authors added, "the debate about a do-less approach to screeningfor cervical cancer and other conditions as wellis ongoing."

The editorial concluded: "Bob Dylan sang about changing times before they actually changed, yet his singing moved the public discussion in a positive direction. Our sense is that the right song for the current discussion is about helping people come to appreciate the harms screening does and move us toward a better balance of benefits and harms."


'/>"/>

Contact: Kathy Neal
kcneal@unc.edu
919-740-5673
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Doctors Detail High Costs of Fighting Malpractice Claims
2. Blending conference translates substance abuse research into practice
3. AGA releases first independently developed ABIM-approved Practice Improvement Module in GI
4. Simulation technology allows users to safely practice phacoemulsification cataract surgery
5. Meditation practice may decrease risk for cardiovascular disease in teens
6. Meditation practice may decrease risk for cardiovascular disease in teens
7. Alex Galindo, Attorney and Partner at Curd, Galindo & Smith, LLP, Court Wins Against the County of Riverside's Motion to Dismiss Medical Malpractice Case
8. IU gastroenterologist develops practice guidelines for most prevalent liver disease
9. AIUM and AUA guideline development leads to practice accreditation for urologic ultrasound
10. CWRU nurse researcher surveys infection control practices for home patients
11. E-Records Linked to Fewer Malpractice Claims
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/31/2016)... , ... May 31, 2016 , ... ... 4, 2016 Cool Vendors in Security Infrastructure Protection report by Gartner1 Inc. , ... a series of research reports evaluating these innovative vendors and their products and ...
(Date:5/31/2016)... (PRWEB) , ... May 31, 2016 , ... ... multichannel marketing services firm and statement solutions provider, for the tenth consecutive ... the May 2016 issue of Advertising Age, and SourceLink ranked eighteenth in the ...
(Date:5/31/2016)... N.J. (PRWEB) , ... May 31, 2016 , ... ... and print media enterprise focused on patients with cancer, has added Cancer ... readers and website visitors with more timely content on continuing successful careers while ...
(Date:5/30/2016)... ... May 30, 2016 , ... As the CDC relaxes ... children and their efforts to keep their households lice free. , According to ... enacting new policies that keep kids in the classroom despite the fact that they ...
(Date:5/30/2016)... ... May 30, 2016 , ... Zane Benefits, ... publication of an original infographic, " Health Benefits Reimbursement Compliance Timeline ." ... Zane Benefits complies with various federal regulations and reforms. , Navigating the new ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/26/2016)... ALBANY, New York , May 26, 2016 ... Transparency Market Research "Medical Waste Management Market - U.S. Industry ... the medical waste management market in the U.S. was valued ... expand at a CAGR of 3.4% from 2015 to 2023 ... report provides exhaustive analysis of current and emerging needle free ...
(Date:5/26/2016)... May 26, 2016   Change Healthcare ... analytics, network solutions and technology-enabled services designed ... entered into a strategic channel partnership with ... software solutions and revenue cycle management services ... and rehabilitation clinics to optimize revenue, operational ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... -- According to a new market research ... by Therapeutic Area (Oncology, Cosmeceutical/Plastic Surgery), by Application (Drug ... Hospitals/ Clinics) - Forecast to 2021", published by MarketsandMarkets, ... the forecast period of 2016 to 2021. This market ... from USD 117.3 Million in 2016, at a CAGR ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: