Navigation Links
Not so fast -- sex differences in the brain are overblown
Date:10/27/2010

People love to speculate about differences between the sexes, and neuroscience has brought a new technology to this pastime. Brain imaging studies are published at a great rate, and some report sex differences in brain structure or patterns of neural activity. But we should be skeptical about reports of brain differences between the sexes, writes psychological scientist Cordelia Fine in Current Directions in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science. The results from these studies may not necessarily withstand the tests of larger sample sizes or improved analysis techniquesand it's too soon to know for sure what such results, even if they prove to be reliable, might mean for differences in male and female minds.

Bookstores are full of popular books on the differences between men's and women's brains. Fine, who works at Macquarie University in Australia, first became interested in the issue as a parent. She was reading a book about how the differences between boys' and girls' brains mean they should be taught differently. But as an academic, she was curious about the research on which these claims were based, and looked up the original studies.

"There were huge discrepancies between what the neuroimaging studies showed and the conclusions and claims that were being drawn from them," she says. In the article and her new book, Delusions of Gender, Fine dissects the ways that research goes astray between the scanning machine and the sound bite.

Some of the problems start with the research. The studies Fine came across were often conducted with small numbers of men and women, where the differences seen could have been due to chance. It's very easy and obvious for neuroscientists to compare the sexes by default. But when neuroscientists habitually check for sex differences, some researchers, just by chance, will find statistically significant differences between the two groupseven if there's no real difference between men and women overall.

This problem of false positive results is understood by the neuroscientists who do the research; they know that one study with 20-odd participants that finds some small region of difference between males and females is not the final word on the issue. But these often subtle, questionable differences are readily seized on by popular writers, Fine says.

Another problem is how to interpret sex differences in the brain. Neuroscientists are only beginning to understand how neural activity brings about complex psychological phenomena. The temptation, to which popular writers are particularly vulnerable, is to use gender stereotypes to bridge that gap in scientific knowledge.

The fact that neuroimaging studies use complex, expensive machines that seem to take pictures of the brain may also make their results seem more real, reliable, and impressive than behavioral studies. As a result, substantial behavioral evidence of gender similarity, or the sensitivity of gender differences to context, can be overshadowed by a single finding of a sex difference in the brain.

"A healthy dose of skepticism is required when it comes to reports of sex differences in the brain and what they mean," says Fine, who is concerned that claims about differences in male and female brains are reinforcing old-fashioned gender stereotypes.


'/>"/>

Contact: Keri Chiodo
kchiodo@psychologicalscience.org
202-293-9300
Association for Psychological Science
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Medicare data reveals differences in orthopedic surgical outcomes
2. Survey finds significant racial differences in lung cancer beliefs
3. Few differences in outcomes between open and laparoscopic prostate surgery
4. American Stroke Association Late-Breaking Science Report: Surgery, Stenting to Open Blocked Neck Arteries Similar in Safety, Efficacy, But Show Differences in Stroke, Heart Attack and Death Rates at Certain Ages
5. Poll reveals sleep differences among ethnic groups
6. Poll Reveals Sleep Differences Among Ethnic Groups
7. Transcription factors may dictate differences between individuals
8. Bad Habits Explain Class Differences in Health: Study
9. Gender Differences Show in Risk of Narcotic Abuse
10. Differences in language circuits in the brain linked to dyslexia
11. Exploring gender differences in colorectal cancer screenings
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... TopConsumerReviews.com recently gave a best-in-class ... . , The healthcare industry in the United States has undergone major changes over ... of needing to have a doctor’s order to get a blood test or other ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... Women’s Excellence in ... pain. In addition to oncology services, the new center will specialize in ... heavy bleeding during menstruation), uterine fibroids, and uterine and pelvic adhesions (scar tissue). ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... ... and marketers of high-quality anti-aging skincare solutions, recently announced the launch of two ... are an affordable, yet effective alternative to expensive plastic surgery or in-patient cosmetic ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... 16, 2017 , ... “God Will Break Every Chain”: an inspirational story for those shackled by ... of published author, Evangelist Joann Shivers, a writer and a woman of great faith and ... at an early age. She was born and raised in Vero Beach, Florida and ...
(Date:8/15/2017)... ... August 15, 2017 , ... Medicine ... out to a patient who feels isolated. It’s developing relationships and thereby growing ... President Daniel R. Wilson, MD, PhD, invited three renowned authors and academic leaders ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:8/2/2017)... Calif. , Aug. 2, 2017 ... Continental Who,s Who as a Pinnacle Lifetime Professional ... the Key Account Manager at Turing Pharmaceuticals, AG. ... negotiations, troubleshooting and relationship building.                ... has more than 25 years of experience as ...
(Date:8/2/2017)... a next-generation full-service pharmacy, has announced the launch of its ... Washington D.C. metropolitan area. CaryRx aims to ... through the convenience of its patient-friendly mobile app. Prescriptions can ... to any location in D.C. ... Washington D.C. ," says Areo Nazari , ...
(Date:7/31/2017)... MEMPHIS, Tenn. , July 31, 2017 Three Tru-D ... in Yongsan, South Korea . Tru-D, short for "Total ... patient and operating rooms after an environmental services (ES) professional cleans the ... ... "Although ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: